Federal Lawsuit Over East Hampton Airport Withdrawn, Though Town Sees a Possible Motive - 27 East

Federal Lawsuit Over East Hampton Airport Withdrawn, Though Town Sees a Possible Motive

icon 1 Photo
The National Business Aviation Association has withdrawn a federal lawsuit against East Hampton Town, saying that a recent state court ruling addressed the group's desire to block restrictions on aircraft.

The National Business Aviation Association has withdrawn a federal lawsuit against East Hampton Town, saying that a recent state court ruling addressed the group's desire to block restrictions on aircraft.

authorMichael Wright on Nov 30, 2022

A national aviation organization has withdrawn the lawsuit it filed last spring against East Hampton Town in federal court challenging the town’s authority to impose flight restrictions at East Hampton Airport.

A spokesman for the National Business Aviation Association said the suit was withdrawn because an October ruling by a Suffolk County judge has already blocked the town from limiting flight traffic, and it specifically cited the federal law that the NBAA’s lawsuit had focused on.

State Supreme Court Justice Paul Baisley ruled on October 20 that the town’s plans to temporarily close East Hampton Airport and reopen it as a private airport, with new rules limiting air traffic, had not been crafted in accordance with state law. The proposal failed to thoroughly lay out what the impacts of the new airport on other communities would be — which the town had said it planned to study during the first months of the new rules, with plans to then use those findings to fine-tune its restrictions.

Baisley also said that regardless of the process of crafting the limits, the town could not impose restrictions on air traffic because the federal Airport Noise and Capacity Act, or ANCA, left that authority solely with the Federal Aviation Administration.

“From that moment on, our effort became duplicative,” Alex Gertsen, the NBAA’s director of airports, said on Monday of the group’s reasoning for withdrawing its lawsuit. “Our position was that the town was not able to [impose restrictions] because it would violate ANCA. And since the state court issue was about [the New York State Environmental Quality Review Act] as well as ANCA, we felt that we don’t need to continue the application at the federal level.”

The federal suit was part of what an attorney for the town last week called a “constellation” of legal attacks on the town by aviation interests over the proposal to impose limits on flight traffic.

Three lawsuits by separate groups of aviation-related plaintiffs were brought in Suffolk County court — the cases that ultimately landed with Baisley — plus a fourth in Nassau County court and the NBAA case in federal court. There is also an administrative appeal to the FAA by two local charter pilots, which also focuses on the town’s authority under ANCA.

Gertsen said that the NBAA had filed its suit in May only because the challenges in the state courts, which had been filed in February, had been repeatedly delayed as three judges recused themselves from the cases and the May 17 deadline for the town’s planned closure of the airport approached.

Ultimately, the arguments over a temporary restraining order in the Suffolk County case was heard by Baisley on the same day that the NBAA took its request to halt the town’s plans to U.S. District Court Judge Joanna Seybert.

As the attorneys for the NBAA and town were just beginning to make their arguments to Seybert, word came down that Baisley had issued a temporary restraining order on the town’s privatization plans. Seybert immediately agreed to put further movement of the federal case on the shelf.

But the town had hoped that Seybert and the federal court case would actually give them a window to dispense with the ANCA issue once and for all.

When the town tried to impose very similar restrictions on flights at the airport in 2015, it was Seybert who ruled that the ANCA precluded the town taking such steps without going though a years-long FAA application process.

That was before federal grant assurances expired in 2021, though, and the town and its attorneys have said that development gives the town the power to close the public airport if it sees fit and reopen it as a technically new and private facility.

Private airports typically are able to set their own parameters for flights to and from their runways through “prior permission required,” or PPR, rules.

The town has said it worked closely with FAA officials on its plans to transition East Hampton Airport to a private facility and adopt a PPR that would impose curfews and limit flights by commercial aircraft and most helicopters to just one per day per aircraft — and expects that the FAA would stand by the position that the town was acting within its rights.

One of the town’s attorneys, Bill O’Connor, told the Town Board last week that his team planned to ask Seybert to invite the FAA to make its position on the town’s PPR proposal known — a potential watershed moment on the ANCA matter. “I do expect to see some decisions out of that court soon,” he said at the time.

The town has appealed the Baisley ruling, but O’Connor said it may well be two years before the state appeals court could be expected to offer a decision on the matter.

Attorneys told the Town Board last week that they are already working on recrafting the privatization proposal to address the failures under state law in Baisley’s decision in hopes of reintroducing the matter.

Town officials said that the NBAA withdrawing the federal suit could be a calculated maneuver to stop the higher federal court from determining that the ANCA issue is moot.

“I think it could be interpreted as a strategic move to head off the federal court from addressing the ANCA issues under significantly changed circumstances from the last time they looked at this,” East Hampton Town Supervisor Peter Van Scoyoc said. “We remain confident that our defense of the NBAA legal claims is strong, and that this lawsuit never should have been brought in the first place.”

Regardless, Gertsen said that the NBAA has taken the opportunity of the lawsuit’s withdrawal to appeal to town officials to work with aviators to craft new voluntary limitations on flights in the hope that the sort of reductions in aircraft noise the town has said it is seeking can be achieved outside of the courts and without the town needing to jump through legal hoops to force through new rules.

“We feel the best path to preserving the long-term future of the airport is to come to the table with the town,” Gertsen said. “Voluntary procedures have been working. We’re not disagreeing that more can be done and the solutions can be enhanced. We’re doing a lot already and … we see a path forward within the legal framework to work out a solution.”

You May Also Like:

After Trump Executive Order, an Uncertain Future for Offshore Wind

Environmental and wind energy advocates have come out strongly against President Donald Trump’s January 20 ... 8 Feb 2025 by Christopher Walsh

Bird Flu Found on the East End | 27Speaks

The bird flu epidemic has reached the East End. H5N1 bird flu avian influenza has ... 7 Feb 2025 by 27Speaks

Southampton Robotics Students Put Their Skills To Work To Give Three-Legged Shelter Dog a New Lease on Life

It can be argued that any animal that finds its way to a shelter is ... by Cailin Riley

Sag Harbor Village Police Reports for the Week of February 6

SAG HARBOR VILLAGE — A woman came into Village Police headquarters on Division Street the evening of January 28, reporting that she was walking in the parking lot by Long Wharf when she looked down and saw what she thought was a pen. When she reached down and picked it up, she realized it was a live bullet. Police identified it as a 22-caliber rifle round and took possession of it. SAG HARBOR VILLAGE — A woman who had parked her car on Madison Street the morning of January 27 reported to police that it appeared that her wallet had ... 5 Feb 2025 by Staff Writer

Sag Harbor Businesses Say They See More Visitors, but Fewer Customers

Downtown Sag Harbor was packed last summer, with pedestrians crowding the sidewalks, and cars crowding ... by Stephen J. Kotz

Long Island's Last Ducks?

The destruction of nearly 100,000 ducks at Crescent Duck Farm in Aquebogue late last month due to an outbreak of the avian flu there was alarming, and a tragedy for the family running the farm and their employees. It’s unclear whether the last remaining duck farm on Long Island will be able to rebound. The outbreak at the farm was the latest in a series of scary global outbreaks in recent months, affecting the poultry industry and resulting in a sharp increase in cost to consumers. Locally, it follows an outbreak of the deadly virus at Spring Farm, a game ... by Editorial Board

Throw a Lifeline

The first two weeks of the second Donald Trump administration have been a fire hose of developments “flooding the zone,” so it’s easy to miss small developments that could have enormous impact in some quarters. One of those is the Federal Communications Commission and its new focus on NPR and PBS. The New York Times reported that FCC Chairman Brendan Carr has launched an investigation into “whether the news organizations’ member stations violated government rules by recognizing financial sponsors on the air.” Its conclusions could lead Congress to take away financial support. NPR and PBS acknowledge corporate sponsors on air, ... by Editorial Board

Sag Harbor Woman Loses $200,000 in Crypto Fraud

A Sag Harbor woman was defrauded out of more than $200,000 since the summer, when a fraudster first reached out to her via social media. The victim reported to Sag Harbor Village Police last Thursday afternoon that a man she knew only as David had begun communicating with her through Instagram. He encouraged her to invest money online through Coinbase and Cash App, telling her the cash would then be converted to cryptocurrency. Over several months she did so, transferring $170,500 from her checking account into Coinbase. The money would then be used to buy bitcoin, the profits from which ... by Staff Writer

Southampton Town Will Embark on New Comprehensive Plan

The Southampton Town Board and the town’s planning staff are embarking on the likely years-long ... by Michael Wright

Historian John Strong, a Fierce Ally of Native Nations, Dies at 89

When Tela Troge was in high school, she saw an advertisement for a lecture by ... by Michelle Trauring