Fire Destroys Former Montauk Highway Motel in Hampton Bays

icon 4 Photos
Smoke poured through the roof.  COURTESY HAMPTON BAYS FIRE DEPARTMENT

Smoke poured through the roof. COURTESY HAMPTON BAYS FIRE DEPARTMENT

Hampton Bays firefighters prepare to enter the burning structure.  COURTESY HAMPTON BAYS FIRE DEPARTMENT

Hampton Bays firefighters prepare to enter the burning structure. COURTESY HAMPTON BAYS FIRE DEPARTMENT

Smoke poured from the gaping hole in the roof, as seen from a drone during the Friday afternoon fire on East Montauk Highway in  Hampton Bays. COURTESY HAMPTON BAYS FIRE DEPARTMENT

Smoke poured from the gaping hole in the roof, as seen from a drone during the Friday afternoon fire on East Montauk Highway in Hampton Bays. COURTESY HAMPTON BAYS FIRE DEPARTMENT

Smoke billowed from a fire on East Montauk Highway  in Shinnecock Hills Friday afternoon.     DONALD FLANNERY

Smoke billowed from a fire on East Montauk Highway in Shinnecock Hills Friday afternoon. DONALD FLANNERY

Kitty Merrill on Apr 1, 2022

Fire ravaged an apartment building in Hampton Bays on Friday, April 1, leaving a number of tenants homeless. The Hampton Bays Fire Department was called to the fire on East Montauk Highway at 3:42 p.m. and continued working the site for hours, finishing up at 9 p.m.

Chief James Kappers was first on the scene at 3:45 p.m. and found the building fully engulfed. All occupants had been cleared out of the building. During the early moments of the blaze, Town Code Compliance and Emergency Management Administrator Ryan Murphy said all of the residents of the building had been accounted for.

“The only thing unaccounted for are four missing cats as far as we know right now,” he said Friday afternoon.

Southampton Town Police reported the closure of the highway westbound at Peconic Road at 3:55 p.m. By 4:11 p.m., both lanes had been closed from North Road at the west to Peconic Road.

The first pumper truck to arrive sustained damage to its undercarriage on the steep overgrown driveway. Department spokesman Michael Zarro was on that first truck and on scene within minutes. He said you could feel the heat radiating from the blaze as far as 20 feet away. “That building went up quickly,” he said.

In all, the fire department sent its two pumper trucks, a tanker truck, a lighting and rescue truck, and an aerial platform truck, as well as its contingent of fire police to the scene. Southampton Fire Department sent an engine and also deployed its rapid intervention team to the scene, to stand by in case firefighters working on the interior became trapped.

Given the condition of the building, however, there was fear of a roof collapse and most of the work to cut down the flames took place as an exterior attack, Zarro explained.

Firefighters from the Flanders Volunteer Fire Department provided assistance, standing by at the Hampton Bays Firehouse. Hampton Bays ambulance was on the scene to offer aid to firefighters; one was injured, treated, and released at the scene, Zarro said.

By 4:46 p.m., the bulk of the fire had been knocked down. The rest of the early evening’s work focused on hitting hot spots.

PSEG-LI and National Grid both sent teams to the fire and Suffolk County was called to clear the road after debris from the blaze slid down the hill and onto Montauk Highway. The Red Cross was also notified of displaced residents, Zarro said.

The property, located at 317 East Montauk Highway, is described as a 13-unit apartment complex, owned by L Squared, Victor La Terra’s company. It includes two structures and there are pending code enforcement charges there, town officials said. There is also a pending lawsuit that La Terra filed in federal court in 2020, accusing the town of targeting his business because his tenants were predominantly Latino.

The fire was in the front building closest to Montauk Highway. That building has multiple apartments.

Fire marshals were on the scene by late Friday afternoon. Preliminary indications suggest the fire started in one of the downstairs apartments.

Murphy reported that when they arrived on the scene, fire marshals spoke with a tenant who said he’d left a pot of rice cooking on the stove and went out, only to return to find smoke. With the investigation still underway as of Monday, April 7, Murphy said the office wasn’t ready to list that as the fire’s main cause, though it certainly could have been a contributing factor.

For Spanish-language reporting on this story, visit tuprensalocal.com.

You May Also Like:

Southampton Police Reports for the Week of November 27

WESTHAMPTON BEACH — Mark Green, 44, of Westhampton Beach, was arrested by Westhampton Beach Village Police on November 21 and charged with driving while ability impaired by drugs, a misdemeanor. At approximately 3:13 p.m., police conducted a traffic stop on Rogers Avenue after observing a Mercedes-Benz operating without a front license plate. The driver, Green, exhibited signs of cannabis impairment, and officers observed a burned cannabis joint in the vehicle’s center console, police said. Field sobriety tests and advanced roadside impairment testing indicated impairment: Green was placed under arrest and transported back to police headquarters for processing and to await ... 27 Nov 2025 by Staff Writer

‘Good for Everyone’: ACCESSforALL Helps Arts Groups, Businesses Push Forward on Inclusion

In Brian O’Mahoney’s eyes, “disability” does not need to be an intimidating word. But for ... 26 Nov 2025 by Michelle Trauring

Community News, November 27

HOLIDAY HAPPENINGS Hampton Bays Fire Department Turkey Trot The Hampton Bays Fire Department will host ... by Staff Writer

School News, November 27, Southampton Town

Southampton Students Inducted Into National Honor Society Thirty Southampton High School students were recently inducted ... by Staff Writer

Gold Stars and Dunce Caps

⭐️ : To Cami Hatch, for reminding everyone why learning to swim and lifeguard training are important. The East Hampton graduate, now a University of Tennessee student, has been studying in Italy and was visiting Malta recently when she heard a fellow beachgoer whistling. “That whistle unlocked a new mode in my brain. For lifeguards, when you hear a whistle it means, ‘Heads up — get ready to go,’ as Big John and Johnny Ryan have instilled in us over the years,” she said, shouting out her lifeguard instructors. She dove in and saved a foundering Englishman, who was in ... by Editorial Board

Monday Traffic Snarls Implode Hopes for Improvements Along CR39

Traffic on Monday night in the Southampton region was snarled to an extent that, while ... by Michael Wright

New Shinnecock Curriculum Begins in Southampton Elementary Classrooms

Standing at the podium at a recent Southampton Board of Education meeting, ELA teacher Nature ... by Michelle Trauring

Yacht Hampton 'Boating Club' in Noyac Comes to Planning Board

The owner of a Noyac marina that has served as a hub for boat charters, ... by Michael Wright

'Bled by Our Side'

The combination of the new Ken Burns documentary on the American Revolution and the rosy image of the first Thanksgiving led me to recall a 1778 event that exemplifies the true relationship between the white settlers and the Indigenous population. And that relationship spread west as the settlers did. During the war, the Stockbridge Mohicans, along with the Oneida, Tuscarora and a handful of other Indigenous nations, allied with the American colonists in their struggle for independence from Britain. Many of these communities hoped that their military support would ensure recognition of their sovereignty and protection of their lands. Instead, ... by Tom Clavin

Another Chance

Will Governor Kathy Hochul sign, or again veto, a bill to protect horseshoe crabs that again passed by large majorities in the State Legislature earlier this year? Hochul vetoed the same bill last year. She claimed then that the Horseshoe Crab Protection Act was “well intentioned,” but their management should best be left with the state’s Department of Environmental Conservation. She said the DEC has “significant rules and regulations regarding commercial and recreational fishing in the state.” It currently has an annual quota of 150,000 horseshoe crabs that can be taken. Environmentalists have been actively calling on Hochul to sign ... by Karl Grossman