Flanders Man Found Guilty in 2021 Shooting Death of Tyrell Durham - 27 East

Flanders Man Found Guilty in 2021 Shooting Death of Tyrell Durham

icon 1 Photo
Michael Gilbert faces up to 40 years in prison in shooting death of Tyrell Durham

Michael Gilbert faces up to 40 years in prison in shooting death of Tyrell Durham

authorStaff Writer on Sep 28, 2023

Michael Gilbert, a 29-year-old Flanders man, was found guilty of second-degree murder this week in the fatal 2021 shooting of Tyrell Durham.

Gilbert shot Durham in Moriches, said Suffolk County District Attorney Ray Tierney, following an argument that Durham had with Gilbert’s girlfriend at a Moriches housing complex.

“A man is dead because a needless argument caused this defendant to pull a trigger and thoughtlessly take the victim’s life,” Tierney said.

The shooting at apartments at Tall Oaks Circle occurred after Gilbert overheard Durham, who was 37, yelling obscenities at Gilbert’s girlfriend, Lashonda Coles, on the telephone. Coles and Durham both lived in the housing complex.

The argument escalated and eventually Gilbert challenged Durham to “meet me outside.”

Durham obliged, and Gilbert then fired six shots from a .22 semiautomatic handgun, hitting Durham three times.

Gilbert is facing up to 40 years in prison following a jury trial at the Arthur M. Cromarty Court Complex in Riverside.

Along with the felony murder conviction, he was also found guilty of criminal possession of a weapon in the second degree, a felony. He will be sentenced on November 2.

You May Also Like:

Elaine Jones of East Hampton Dies September 18

An indefatigable champion of the working people and formidable presence on the East Hampton Town ... 21 Sep 2025 by Staff Writer

Quilts Made in Aftermath of 9/11 by Quogue School Students Finally Have Their Moment

Ginger Anderson, a longtime teacher at the Quogue School, was planning for retirement at the ... by Cailin Riley

Private Donors Will Fund Revamped Design of Outdoor Space Surrounding Southampton Arts Center on Jobs Lane in the Village

The Southampton Arts Center, a village-owned building that sits on 3 acres of village-owned property ... 20 Sep 2025 by Cailin Riley

Leader of Othodox Christians To Visit Southampton, Bless Shinnecock Bay

The religious leader of Orthodox Christianity, His All-Holiness Ecumenical Patriarch Bartholomew, will visit the East ... 19 Sep 2025 by Staff Writer

UPDATE: Town Police Say Missing Teenager Has Been Found Safe

UPDATE: 2:30 p.m. Saturday Southampton Town Police say 14-year-old Anya Larsen has been located and ... by Staff Writer

Annaliese Soros of Southampton and New York City Dies September 5

Annaliese Soros, mother, grandmother, music lover, patron, loving friend, and generous host, died on September ... by Staff Writer

Daniel Leopold Horwith of Wappingers Falls Dies September 7

Our beloved Daniel Leopold Horwith died in his apartment in Wappingers Falls, NY on September ... by Staff Writer

History Museum Files Federal Lawsuit Accusing Southampton of Abuse of Power Over Claim to Conscience Point Parcel

The non-profit Southampton History Museum has filed a federal lawsuit against Southampton Town officials, Suffolk ... by Michael Wright

Southampton Police Reports for the Week of September 18

SOUTHAMPTON VILLAGE — A resident reported to Southampton Village Police on September 12 that he had discovered a check made out to his company’s Oxford Health plan in the amount of $4,226 had instead been cashed by someone named Trinidad Delgado in the amount of $8,452. The man contacted his bank to report the fraud. WESTHAMPTON BEACH — A 41-year-old Merrick man was stopped by Westhampton Beach Police on September 15 at 7:33 p.m. and charged with driving while ability impaired by alcohol. He was pulled over to the parking lot of the Mill Road 7-Eleven after a police officer ... 18 Sep 2025 by Staff Writer

Dockside Defense: Protecting Montauk's Fishing Future | 27Speaks

The Suffolk County Legislature recently voted to establish a mechanism for preserving working waterfronts from ... by 27Speaks