Flanders Man Sentenced to 25 Years to Life in Fatal 2021 Shooting of Tyrell Durham - 27 East

Flanders Man Sentenced to 25 Years to Life in Fatal 2021 Shooting of Tyrell Durham

icon 1 Photo
Michael Gilbert was sentenced this week to 25 years to life in prison for the 2021 murder of Tyrell Durham.

Michael Gilbert was sentenced this week to 25 years to life in prison for the 2021 murder of Tyrell Durham.

authorStaff Writer on Nov 2, 2023

Michael Gilbert was sentenced to 25 years to life in prison on Thursday, November 2, following a jury trial in Riverside that found him guilty of murder in the fatal shooting of Tyrell Durham, 37, of Moriches, two years ago.

Gilbert, who is 29 and lived on Riverside Avenue in Flanders at the time of the murder, fired a .22 caliber semi-automatic handgun at Durham six times following a late-night argument Durham had with Gilbert’s girlfriend, said Suffolk County District Ray Tierney in a statement following the sentencing hearing.

Gilbert fled the scene following the shooting at a Moriches apartment complex, but surrendered to Suffolk County Police Department homicide detectives about a month after the November 26, 2021 shooting.

He was convicted at the Arthur M. Cromarty Criminal Court Complex in Riverside in late September of this year by a jury that found him guilty of second-degree murder and criminal possession of a weapon in the second degree, both of which are felonies.

“What started out as a verbal argument escalated to murder,” Tierney said. “We hope that this lengthy prison sentence provides some measure of justice for Tyrell’s family and friends, all of whom still mourn his tragic loss.”

You May Also Like:

75 Years of Service: Westhampton War Memorial Ambulance Celebrates Milestone

The Westhampton War Memorial Ambulance Association marked its diamond anniversary with a celebration event on ... 17 Jul 2025 by Dan Stark

Hickling, Purpura Claim This Year's Sis Rice Minsch Memorial Trophy

Luke Hickling and Nick Purpura have a knack at winning the Sis Rice Minsch Memorial ... 16 Jul 2025 by Drew Budd

Southampton Police Reports for the Week of July 17

SOUTHAMPTON VILLAGE — A New Jersey man was charged with assault following a road rage incident on June 30 following a motor vehicle accident on Hill Street. Police arrived at the scene and determined that Kevin E. Guevara-Martinez, 26, of New Jersey was fighting with a 43-year-old Hampton Bays man. Both men were arrested. Guevara-Martinez was charged with assault in the third degree, a misdemeanor. The Hampton Bays man had to be taken to the hospital for treatment of injuries and was charged there with harassment in the second degree, a violation. SOUTHAMPTON VILLAGE — A Southampton man, Dashawn Barner, ... by Staff Writer

Community mourns Dr. Peter Sultan, Westhampton surgeon who died suddenly during Jamesport triathlon Sunday

A beloved local surgeon died Sunday morning after collapsing during the Jamesport Triathlon. Dr. Peter ... by Denise Civiletti

Town Hosts Its Annual Mike Diveris Battle of Southampton Lifeguard Tournament

This year’s annual Mike Diveris Memorial “Battle of Southampton” Lifeguard Tournament on July 8 at ... by Drew Budd

New Traditions, Same Spirit: Sag Harbor Cup Raises Over $50,000 for Junior Sailing Scholarships

The 43rd annual Sag Harbor Cup, hosted by the Breakwater Sailing Center & Yacht Club, ... by Michael Mella

Southampton Artists Association Celebrates 25 Years of Art in the Park

In 2000, artistic couple Nancy and Chuck Polis approached the Southampton Village Trustees and mayor ... by Hope Hamilton

Southampton Village Board, Residents Discuss Traffic Once Again

It’s mid-July, and that means the issue that’s top of mind for almost every resident ... by Cailin Riley

Student-Written Book Published by OLA Offers Real Advice for Navigating Middle School

“Get a good first impression.” “Stay out of drama.” “Beware of the stairs.” These are ... by Dan Stark

Nipped in the Bud

The Southampton Town Board last week hurriedly adopted a change of zone affecting properties along Montauk Highway, or Main Street, bordering downtown Hampton Bays. The lawmakers said it was an effort to protect the hamlet from large commercial developments in the corridor. The move also effectively extinguished a proposal by Mottz Green Grocer to build a cannabis dispensary in the former North Fork Bank building next to the Carvel store in the corridor. The lawmakers say blocking the pot shop was an unintended — but welcome — consequence of the zone change. The business owners have cried foul. And hamlet ... by Editorial Board