Former Legislator George Guldi Ruled Guilty of Fraud, Again - 27 East

Former Legislator George Guldi Ruled Guilty of Fraud, Again

icon 1 Photo
Former Legislator George Guldi at a 2018 court appearance.

Former Legislator George Guldi at a 2018 court appearance.

Kitty Merrill on Jan 26, 2023

George Guldi, a former Suffolk County legislator representing the South Fork and one-time Westhampton Beach resident, along with an accomplice, has been convicted of defrauding Ditech Financial LLC, a mortgage lender, out of more than $250,000, Damian Williams, the U.S. attorney for the Southern District of New York, announced on Wednesday, January 25.

Said Williams: “George Guldi, while in prison, concocted and conducted a scheme along with his co-conspirator, Victoria Davidson, to brazenly steal more than $250,000 through blatant lies. Today, a jury held them accountable for their scheme, and they will both face justice for their shameless misconduct.”

In February 2017, Ditech Financial LLC received a payment of approximately $250,000 from JPMorgan Chase in connection with the settlement of a lawsuit between several financial institutions. Ditech mistakenly treated the funds as a payment from Guldi toward his own mortgage, and it sent him a letter that March stating that it would not credit the payment because he owed more than the payment amount.

Guldi, 69, now a resident of Ludlow, Vermont, was in prison at the time, serving a four-to-12-year sentence for insurance-related offenses, at the Marcy Correctional Facility in upstate New York. He knew that he had not actually sent any money to Ditech, then enlisted Davidson, 57, of Lakeville, Connecticut, in a scheme, according to authorities.

Calling Davidson from prison, Guldi directed her to try to “break” the funds “loose.” The call was recorded.

Williams said during the ensuing weeks, Davidson called Ditech at least 19 times, telling multiple lies in an effort to get the money. She said she was an attorney and an officer in Guldi’s company. Turning the tables, she also said Guldi sent the money to Ditech accidentally and wanted it back.

By April, Davidson’s lies had worked. Ditech wired the funds to her personal bank account. Within two weeks, most of the money was gone. Davidson drained the funds out of her account, paying various expenses for herself and Guldi and purchasing multiple cashier’s checks. Within months, it was all gone.

Guldi and Davidson were each convicted of federal felonies: one count each of bank fraud, wire fraud and conspiracy to commit wire fraud and bank fraud.

The conspiracy and bank fraud counts carry a maximum sentence of 30 years in prison, and the wire fraud count carries a maximum sentence of 20 years in prison.

Guldi is scheduled to be sentenced on May 30 and Davidson on May 31.

A disbarred attorney, Guldi served eight years as a Suffolk County legislator — from 1995 until 2003, when then-East Hampton Town Supervisor Jay Schneiderman bested Guldi in his campaign for reelection to the legislature.

Prior state grand larceny charges, filed in 2011, found Guldi guilty of an $82 million mortgage scam, which he pleaded guilty to in 2017. He was also found to have pocketed approximately $870,000 in insurance payouts, which were issued to either rebuild his Westhampton Beach home after it burned down or pay off the $1.2 million that was owed on his outstanding mortgage.

The Griffing Avenue home later went into foreclosure and was torn down by the village in 2015 after becoming an eyesore.

You May Also Like:

Safeguard the Future

Regarding the article on September 10, about Poxabogue Field [“Fate of Southampton Town-Owned Poxabogue Field, Within Sagaponack Village, Is Debated at Town Board Meeting,” 27east.com, September 10]: Most people care about the environment and understand how essential natural resources are for water quality and maintaining wildlife diversity, to support our ecosystems (and us). Changing the designated status of Poxabogue Field into open land makes sense, as it aligns with many of the area’s environmental objectives. We do need food from farms, and, in 1987, the vision for a farm made sense. However, today we face significant water pollution issues, loss ... 13 Sep 2025 by Staff Writer

Questionable Motive

My mother wanted me to be a brain surgeon, so after graduating from high school, I opened my medical practice. I know — at that point I had no college degree, nor a medical school diploma. I never interned at a hospital, or for that matter ever met a brain surgeon. So, it came as no surprise that no patients came to my medical practice, which failed almost as soon as it started. At this point, you must be asking yourself: What does all this have to do with the selection of the Southampton Town clerk in this November’s election? ... by Staff Writer

Expanded View

Longtime Westhampton Beach resident Mark Bernardo is running for Southampton Town clerk in the November election. Mark has managed complex teams and large budgets during a highly successful career in television design and production with all three major networks, starting with the original “Saturday Night Live.” He has won three Emmys and a Peabody Award, the last for his contribution to ABC News’s coverage of Superstorm Sandy. He has designed and consulted on advertising campaigns for Fortune 500 companies and staffed projects with million-dollar budgets as a creative director. This pursuit of excellence and sense of service carries over into ... by Staff Writer

Don't Divide Us

The stop lights that were set up at Halsey Neck Lane and Hill Street this Monday made Hill Street look different. They made Hill Street not look like Hill Street. A detour: In the early 1700s, Hill Street was called the Queen’s Highway (Queen Anne); in the mid-1700s, the King’s Highway (the King Georges). But after the success of the rebellion of the colonies against monarchical rule, there was no more “highway” association with Hill Street — it was called the Road to Shinnecock, and, after that, the Hill Street (a reference to the first hill, where the movie theater ... by Staff Writer

Great Showing

The Water Mill Village Improvement Association would like to extend our heartfelt thanks to all underwriters, sponsors, participants, spectators, and volunteers for making our car show a resounding success. It was a wonderful day on the village green, with hot weather and clear skies. Over 130 cars, trucks and motorcycles were on display, and many spectators came out to enjoy the show. This year, more than 20 dedicated volunteers assisted with setup, show operations and breakdown. We were thrilled to welcome “The Tavern Food Truck” — the food was fantastic! Our tentative date for the 25th Water Mill Car Show ... by Staff Writer

Let It Be

Last week’s article “Fate of Southampton Town-Owned Poxabogue Field, Within Sagaponack Village, Is Debated at Town Board Meeting” [27east.com, September 10] brought to light the concerns of some Southampton Town Board members that changing the status of Poxabogue Field from agriculture to open space/nature preserve might set a precedent that keeps farmers in the future from selling their land to the Community Preservation Fund. This is not the case. Poxabogue Field is a unique parcel, since it is located in the Long Pond Greenbelt Nature Preserve, where it sits next to Poxabogue Pond, one of the greenbelt’s famous string of ... by Staff Writer

We Are Not Immune

I was born in Dublin in 1960 and grew up watching Northern Ireland tear itself apart. Once violence was unleashed, it became the language of politics. Over three decades, more than 3,500 people were murdered before peace was finally secured through the Good Friday Agreement. To put that in perspective, adjusted for population, it would be the equivalent of over one million Americans murdered. The compromises reached then were not so different from what might have been negotiated years earlier — except they came after decades of trauma. That is why the murder of Charlie Kirk today horrifies me. I ... by Staff Writer

When Is Coming

I live in Eastport, opposite the Eastport School. I use the crosswalk, which is on Montauk Highway — a crosswalk where my son, 40 years ago, along with the crossing guard, were inches away from being struck by a tractor-trailer speeding and almost could not stop. Throughout the years it has become worse. Yesterday, in crossing, I saw worse: A car was stopped to let me cross, and a high-performance car at a very high speed in a school zone, with horn blaring, crossed the double line and went through the school zone area at approximately 60 mph. There are ... by Staff Writer

What You Don't See

Close your eyes and picture yourself asking for one more day. This isn’t about death — it’s about fear. Not the kind that comes from a horror movie, but the fear that creeps into everyday life: at the grocery store, the mall, anywhere. I was born a U.S. citizen to immigrant parents who taught me to be strong and courageous. But in today’s society, courage doesn’t erase the fear that haunts me daily. The papers that prove my right to be here feel meaningless when people like me are still discriminated against and treated like threats. None of us is ... by Staff Writer

Protect the Field

After living near and looking at beautiful Poxabogue Field daily for over 30 years, watching the grasses change colors through the seasons, the view across to Poxabogue Pond, the wildlife thriving there — protected Eastern box turtles; ground-nesting birds, including American woodcocks; deer, butterflies, beetles, moths, foxes, field mice, rabbits, woodchucks, snakes, salamanders, and all hidden animals that find protection to thrive in what has become an undisturbed grassland habitat after coming back from being a hayfield many years ago — I was thrilled when I heard it was being saved by our Community Preservation Fund dollars [“Fate of Southampton ... by Staff Writer