Former Southampton Village Mayor Douglas Murtha Dies June 8

icon 2 Photos

authorGreg Wehner on Jun 9, 2016

The first time Dennis Farrell met Douglas Warren Murtha, who would eventually become his brother-in-law, he was impressed.

“I met him when I was in my mid 20s,” Mr. Farrell said. “How can you not like a guy who owns a lot of restaurants and clubs?”

Over the course of his life, not only was Mr. Murtha a three-term mayor of Southampton Village, he was also the owner of several local establishments, among them the Driver’s Seat in Southampton Village and the Chart Inn in Hampton Bays.

“He knew so many people in his travels,” Mr. Farrell said. “He could be in Florida, Manhattan or around the East End, and would run into people he knew. They always had kind words and memories.”

Mr. Murtha, who was 74, died on June 8 at Broadlawn Nursing and Rehabilitation Center in Amityville. A funeral Mass was held on Monday morning at the Basilica of the Sacred Hearts of Jesus and Mary in Southampton.

Mr. Murtha was born in Brooklyn on March 4, 1942, to John and Anne Bauer Murtha. The family eventually moved to Seaford, where he and his three brothers, Jack, Bob and Gary, grew up.

As a young man, Mr. Murtha was an athlete who participated in wrestling and football. At Hofstra University, he was honored as an all-time letterman for his performance on the football team, playing as a linebacker and a running back in 1962 and 1963.

After graduating from Hofstra, he went on to become a teacher and the athletic director at the Lawrence Woodmere Academy in Woodmere.

Mr. Murtha would tend bar on the South Fork in the summers, and he moved east in the 1970s to open the Cruiser Club in Hampton Bays. Following the success of that nightclub, he opened the Chart Inn on the canal in Hampton Bays, which became a popular dining spot.

“Doug was wonderful, warm, inclusive and had a great sense of humor,” Mr. Farrell said.

While working in the Hamptons, Mr. Murtha met Susan Farrell, who was doing the same thing. They were married in 1976 at Saint Agnes Cathedral in Rockville Centre and raised two sons, Douglas and Robert, in Southampton. Doug Murtha Jr., 37, lives in Texas, and Robert Murtha, 27, lives in Georgia.

Beginning in the 1970s, Mr. Murtha and a partner, John Barnhill, owned the Driver’s Seat in Southampton Village, which was a fixture on Jobs Lane for more than 40 years, before selling it in 2005 to Irma Herzog.

Mr. Murtha was first elected mayor of the Village of Southampton in 1993. He served three two-year terms, and he was known for helping to provide access to village beaches as well as access for handicapped and physically challenged residents and guests in the business district.

“I believe Doug was instrumental in negotiating the land for what is now the Rogers Memorial Library, as well as the land for what is the Police Justice Center,” Mr. Farrell said. “Probably the biggest of his accomplishments was the compliance for people with disabilities at the beach, [the Long Island Rail Road] and in the business district in the village.”

A former Southampton resident, Wendy Wagner, had worked with Mr. Murtha to make more areas accessible for the handicapped for 17 years, beginning when he was mayor Southampton Village. “He was an amazing man,” she said. “He was totally committed to the project.”

One of the things he would say, she said, was “Someday, everything will be accessible, and nobody will think about any of this.”

The last time she saw Mr. Murtha, who had Alzheimer’s disease, he told her that he did not know who he was.

“I said, ‘Doug, you’re a great man and everyone loves you,’” she said.

Along with serving as the mayor of Southampton, Mr. Murtha was a member of the Southampton Rotary Club, Kiwanis and Southampton Little League. He loved playing golf and boating, and he was a huge New York Giants fan.

At a Southampton Village Board meeting on June 9, current Southampton Village Mayor Mark Epley noted the death of Mr. Murtha, who had lived right down the block.

“He loved Southampton and was a good community guy,” Mr. Epley said. “He will be missed, but I know he’s in a better place.”

In addition to his wife, sons, and two brothers, Bob and Gary, Mr. Murtha is survived by three grandchildren, Cadence, Kaia and Madeleine.

You May Also Like:

Southampton Wants To Streamline Review for Locally Subsidized Housing Projects

Southampton Town plans to create a new zoning overlay district specifically for affordable housing projects ... 2 Dec 2025 by Michael Wright

Gathering Facts

Bob Giuffra is undoubtedly one of the country’s most accomplished litigators. He is also the chair of the Lake Agawam Conservancy and in that capacity wrote an unfortunate and misleading letter last week [“Playing Politics,” Letters, November 27] accusing me of staging a “political ambush” for raising concerns over the village’s review and supposed “approval” of recent plantings along Gin Lane. He further claimed that I pressured the village attorney, an allegation that would be laughable if it were not so recklessly untrue. One would expect a greater regard for facts from an attorney of Mr. Giuffra’s stature before attaching ... by Staff Writer

Long Island State Parks Dashboard Permits for 2026 Season

The New York State Office of Parks, Recreation and Historic Preservation announced that the following dashboard permits will be available for purchase beginning Tuesday, December 2, and through Tuesday, March 31, for the upcoming 2026 season: Fishing 4-Wheel Drive Access Permit, Surfing 4-Wheel Drive Access Permit, Stargazing, Night/Sport Fishing, Camp Hero Fishing, Nighttime Photography and Regional SCUBA-Diving. Permits can be purchased online or by phone. There will be no in-person sales. All permits will be mailed to the applicant once processed. Purchase online or by phone through New York State Parks Reserve America: Visit the New York State Parks Reserve ... by Staff Writer

Payroll Case Against Riverhead Contractor Thrown Out

The December 2024 indictment of Southampton contractor Robert Terry and his Riverhead-based company, Terry Contracting ... by Denise Civiletti

Jon Alan Baer of Sag Harbor Dies November 30

Jon Alan Baer, a lifelong resident of Sag Harbor, died on November 30. He was 80. Born on June 25, 1945, in Southampton, he was the son of Kosty Joseph Baer and Mary Olive Klingler. His life was marked by commitment to education and the arts. After graduating from Pierson High School, he earned two master’s degrees from the State University of New York at Albany in 1977 and 1978, followed by a doctorate in philosophy in 1993. His academic accomplishments reflected his love of learning and his dedication to understanding the world around him. From 1969 to 2000, he ... by Staff Writer

Joy and Happiness

To the members of our community near and far: We would like to thank everyone who came out to enjoy the Parade of Lights and tree lighting in Agawam Park this past Saturday evening. It was another fantastic experience for Southampton. We are grateful to our fire and EMS departments that participated in the parade, decorating their trucks and vehicles and bringing so much joy and happiness to all those who lined the streets. Thank you to the Voices of Southampton, under the direction of James Tartaglia, for their beautiful singing, and special thanks to the Southampton Fire Department chiefs ... by Staff Writer

Meaningful Recognition

On behalf of Southampton Village Ocean Rescue (SVOR), we are deeply grateful to Mayor Bill Manger and the Southampton Village Board, including Trustee Roy Stevenson, our liaison, for formally adopting the local law authorizing up to a 10 percent property tax exemption for SVOR members. A heartfelt thank you to Eileen Powers, village attorney, for her diligent work in facilitating this resolution, guiding it smoothly to completion in a timely manner. We also value Scott Russell, village administrator, for his important input and we sincerely appreciate the continued support of the village we proudly serve. Thanks to the efforts of ... by Staff Writer

Connecting to History

David Rung’s recent letter regarding the proposed Southampton Village Historical Walking Tours [“Wasted Dollars,” Letters, November 20] seems to misunderstand the intent of this initiative. The idea is not to recreate Google Maps or offer a generic navigation tool. Rather, this project envisions self-guided historic walking tours of Southampton Village — particularly within the village business district — designed to celebrate and share our community’s rich history. Southampton has many remarkable stories to tell, from its founding to the many historic landmarks that define our identity today. Many visitors and even some residents are unaware of the depth of that ... 1 Dec 2025 by Staff Writer

Lack of Ethics

The November 25 Southampton Village Board work session delivered yet another reminder of our village’s lack of ethics. There were many cringeworthy moments, but none more uncomfortable than watching Trustee Roy Stevenson forced to read a prepared statement recusing himself because the matter involved his golf buddy and major campaign donor. That donor received a reduction in his taxable assessed value through the settlement of an Article 7 tax grievance. What made the moment even more troubling was that Mayor Bill Manger also came into the meeting with a prepared statement expressing his intention to vote in favor of the ... by Staff Writer

Santa Coming to Westhampton Beach

The Village of Westhampton Beach will host its annual Christmas Tree and Menorah Lighting Celebration on the Village Green on Saturday, December 6, from 5:30 to 6:30 p.m. At 6 p.m., the Westhampton Beach Fire Department will escort Santa to the Green, joining decorated fire trucks from neighboring departments in a festive parade of lights down Main Street. The trucks will leave the Westhampton Beach firehouse at 5:45 p.m., travel south on Sunset Avenue to Hansen Place and then left onto Potunk Lane before proceeding to Main Street toward the Village Green, where Santa will greet children of all ages. by Staff Writer