Gary J. Tuttle Of Eastport Dies November 21

author on Nov 26, 2012

Gary J. Tuttle

Gary Jack Tuttle, a longtime resident of Eastport, died on Wednesday, November 21, just a few weeks before his 66th birthday.

Mr. Tuttle enlisted in the U.S. Marine Corps in March 1966 and served for three years, including an 18-month tour of duty in Vietnam. After returning to Long Island, he joined the carpenters union and worked for a few years with the union before spending several years working for Horton Construction of Mattituck. During this time, he married his first wife, Claudette Jeanroy, in August 1973, and they lived in Aquebogue, where they raised their children, Robert and Daniel.

After his divorce, he married Priscilla Downs of Westhampton Beach, and the couple moved to Eastport. Mr. Tuttle continued to work for Horton Construction until 1991, at which time he went into business on his own. Over the years, he worked for many local people on remodels, new construction and roofs. He redid the roof on the steeple at Eastport Bible Church in the early 1990s.

Mr. Tuttle developed rheumatoid arthritis in the late 1990s and was unable to continue working as he had in the past, although he still continued to work at small jobs.

Mr. Tuttle also spent much of his time hunting for antiques, refinishing older pieces of furniture, and collecting records and other valuables. Over the past few years, he rented space at an antiques store on Montauk Highway in East Moriches, where he would spend many hours reading and speaking with regular customers.

A very large part of his life was the church community at Eastport Bible Church, where he has served as an elder on the board of trustees, taught Adult Sunday School classes, and worked as a leader in both the Youth Group and Stockade programs. He was working on the parsonage garage the day he died.

Mr. Tuttle was well-known to many in Eastport and had daily routines during which he would stop at many of the establishments in town to visit with local people.

He is survived by his five children, Robert and Daniel from his first marriage, and Charles, Faith, and John from his present marriage. He is also survived by his wife of almost 25 years, Priscilla; a sister, Merrilee Clark of Speonk; and two brothers, James Tuttle of Pennsylvania and Steven Tuttle of Indiana. He is predeceased by his parents, Jack and Norma Tuttle.

Visitation was at Follett and Werner Funeral Home on Sunday, November 25, and a private interment was held on Monday, November 26, at the Eastport Cemetery. A memorial service was held at Eastport Bible Church on Monday, November 26, at 7 p.m.

You May Also Like:

Turnout, Turnout, Turnout!

Election 2025 is now in the history books. What happened? Why did it happen? What does it mean for 2026? As we look across the nation in this off-year election, there is overwhelming consensus that the 2025 election was a big victory for Democrats. Democrats won gubernatorial elections with moderate candidates in New Jersey and Virginia. Zohran Mamdani, a Democratic Socialist, was elected mayor of New York City as a Democrat, with a majority of the vote in a three-way race. In California, Governor Gavin Newsom’s redistricting proposal was approved by more than 60 percent of the vote. Democrats also ... 20 Nov 2025 by Fred Thiele Jr.

Warm Air, and Hot Air

There’s a highly threatening and new reality for hurricanes. Unusually, the East Coast of the United States was not struck this year by any hurricanes. And thus, luckily, we were not hit by one of these extreme hurricanes that first meanders as a minor storm and then, in just a day or so after feeding from waters made ever-hotter by climate change, rise to the worst hurricane level, Category 5 on the Saffir-Simpson hurricane scale. But it’s just a matter of time. The National Weather Service of the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Agency defines online Category 5 as: “Winds 157 ... 19 Nov 2025 by Karl Grossman

Community News, November 20

YOUTH CORNER Toddler & Teeny Tumbling Project Most at the Community Learning Center, 44 Meadow ... by Staff Writer

Landmark Status

At the Sag Harbor Cinema on Saturday, a group of admirers came together to pay ... by Editorial Board

Southampton Lifts Term Limits for Regulatory Board Appointments, Shortens Terms

The Southampton Town Board last week approved removing term limits for members of the town’s Planning Board and Zoning Board of Appeals, but at the same time cut the terms for members from seven years to four years. The board had only extended the terms for members of the two quasi-judicial regulatory boards from four to seven years in 2022 — to match state Town Law guidelines that say member terms should be equal to the number of members on a board. The town imposed a limit of two terms on members. At the time, appointments were also staggered with ... by Michael Wright

Southampton Will Temporarily Lift Limits on Short-Term Rentals for US Open in June 2026

Southampton Town will lift its restrictions prohibiting the rental of a home for less than ... by Michael Wright

Flanders Man Who Died in Kayaking Mishap Remembered as Protector by Girlfriend and Family

When Shane Garcia’s friends and family talk about him, there’s a common theme that emerges: ... by Cailin Riley

Simioni Puts Pressure on Fellow Board Members To Ask ARB To Release Draft of Historic Preservation Survey

Southampton Village Trustee Ed Simioni is putting pressure on village officials, including Mayor Bill Manger ... by Cailin Riley

New Traffic Patterns on CR39 Slow To Show Improvements

The first week of the new traffic patterns on County Road 39 in Southampton and ... by Michael Wright

Red Horse Market Now Open in Southampton Village

Those who live and work in Southampton Village once again have another option for grabbing ... by Cailin Riley