In a Battle of Young Squads, East Hampton/Pierson Girls Soccer Top Hampton Bays - 27 East

In a Battle of Young Squads, East Hampton/Pierson Girls Soccer Top Hampton Bays

icon 15 Photos
East Hampton eighth-grader Shayla Buestan heads toward the goal.   MICHAEL O'CONNOR

East Hampton eighth-grader Shayla Buestan heads toward the goal. MICHAEL O'CONNOR

Elle Reidlinger congratulates Rihanna Pinos after scoring a goal.   MICHAEL O'CONNOR

Elle Reidlinger congratulates Rihanna Pinos after scoring a goal. MICHAEL O'CONNOR

Hampton Bays freshman Val Lopez bring the ball downfield.   MICHAEL O'CONNOR

Hampton Bays freshman Val Lopez bring the ball downfield. MICHAEL O'CONNOR

Hampton Bays senior goalie Jordyn Heaney makes an initial stop on a shot but East Hampton senior Rihanna Pinos knocked in the rebound for the first goal of the game.   MICHAEL O'CONNOR

Hampton Bays senior goalie Jordyn Heaney makes an initial stop on a shot but East Hampton senior Rihanna Pinos knocked in the rebound for the first goal of the game. MICHAEL O'CONNOR

Hampton Bays freshman Nikolle Medina controls the ball.   MICHAEL O'CONNOR

Hampton Bays freshman Nikolle Medina controls the ball. MICHAEL O'CONNOR

Hampton Bays senior Damaris Garcis tries to stop an East Hampton player.   MICHAEL O'CONNOR

Hampton Bays senior Damaris Garcis tries to stop an East Hampton player. MICHAEL O'CONNOR

East Hampton eighth-grader Elle Reidlinger sends the ball.   MICHAEL O'CONNOR

East Hampton eighth-grader Elle Reidlinger sends the ball. MICHAEL O'CONNOR

East Hampton eighth-grader Shayla Buestan races the ball downfield.   MICHAEL O'CONNOR

East Hampton eighth-grader Shayla Buestan races the ball downfield. MICHAEL O'CONNOR

East Hampton eighth-grader Gabriela Montes fends off Hampton Bays eighth-grader Alejandra Montoya.   MICHAEL O'CONNOR

East Hampton eighth-grader Gabriela Montes fends off Hampton Bays eighth-grader Alejandra Montoya. MICHAEL O'CONNOR

Hampton Bays sophomore Brianna Farrell takes on East Hampton freshman Kaylee Munoz.  MICHAEL O'CONNOR

Hampton Bays sophomore Brianna Farrell takes on East Hampton freshman Kaylee Munoz. MICHAEL O'CONNOR

Hampton Bays sophomore Brianna Farrell heads the ball.   MICHAEL O'CONNOR

Hampton Bays sophomore Brianna Farrell heads the ball. MICHAEL O'CONNOR

Bonacker Shayla Buestan takes a shot on goal.   MICHAEL O'CONNOR

Bonacker Shayla Buestan takes a shot on goal. MICHAEL O'CONNOR

Hampton Bays goalie Jordyn Heaney comes out to stop East Hampton's Shayla Buestan.  MICHAEL O'CONNOR

Hampton Bays goalie Jordyn Heaney comes out to stop East Hampton's Shayla Buestan. MICHAEL O'CONNOR

East Hampton eighth-grader Shayla Buestan gets the ball passed Hampton Bays goalie Jordyn Heaney for a goal.   MICHAEL O'CONNOR

East Hampton eighth-grader Shayla Buestan gets the ball passed Hampton Bays goalie Jordyn Heaney for a goal. MICHAEL O'CONNOR

Hampton Bays freshman Emely Reinoso.  MICHAEL O'CONNOR

Hampton Bays freshman Emely Reinoso. MICHAEL O'CONNOR

Drew Budd on Oct 4, 2023

It hasn’t been the easiest season thus far for the East Hampton/Pierson girls soccer team.

Players and coaches came into this fall knowing that it was going to be an uphill battle from the start. After graduating 12 seniors following the conclusion of last season, eight of whom were starters, head coach Cara Nelson knew that playing in Division II wasn’t going to help her program. She petitioned Section XI to play in Division III instead, to have some competitive games, which meant being ineligible from the postseason. While it’s helped, she didn’t know the unknown — that she would lose both of her goalkeepers to injures in the first two weeks of the season, and that three additional players would sustain season-ending injuries as well, which has only made the team that much younger.

Last week at Hampton Bays, another young team, the Bonackers knew they had one of their few opportunities for a victory and they came through in a hard-fought 2-1 decision on September 28. It was just the team’s second victory of the season after a 3-0 nonleague win over Port Jefferson in the season opener on August 30.

Due to all of their injuries, the Bonackers feature three eighth-graders and a freshman who Nelson said they plan to build the program around the next few years, and it was the young underclassmen who shined in last week’s victory.

After sophomore Hailey Benenaula took a shot from outside the box, senior Rihanna Pinos crashed the net for the rebound and scored to give East Hampton a 1-0 lead at halftime. In the second half, eighth-grader Elle Reidlinger played a ball in to fellow classmate Shayla Buestan, who dribbled past a pair of defenders and broke toward the goal, burying the ball in the back right corner to put East Hampton up, 2-0.

Hampton Bays, which earned its lone victory this season in a 1-0 contest at home over Wyandanch on September 23, scored a late goal to avoid the shut out, but East Hampton was able to hold on for the one-goal victory. Hampton Bays senior Jordyn Heaney made nine saves in goal. Additional information on Hampton Bays was not provided.

East Hampton hosted Mount Sinai on Tuesday, is scheduled to play at Babylon this Friday at 5 p.m. and then will host Amityville this Tuesday, October 10, at 4:30 p.m.

Hampton Bays will play at Amityville this Thursday, October 5, at 5 p.m. and then will host Port Jefferson on October 11 at 4:30 p.m.

You May Also Like:

Whalers Take First Game Over Bees in New Boys Soccer Rivalry

For years they played together. Now they play against one another. For several years, Pierson ... 15 Oct 2025 by Drew Budd

Weekly Roundup: Bonac Boys Soccer, Westhampton Beach Girls Soccer Earn First Wins; Southampton Field Hockey Defeats West Babylon

Calle’s Hat Trick Leads to
Bonac Boys Soccer First Win The East Hampton boys soccer team defeated Huntington, 6-3, at home on October 8 for their first victory of the season. Eduardo Calle scored a hat trick and had an assist, while Esteban Diaz scored two goals and assisted on two others. Bryan Pillco scored the other goal for the Bonackers (1-10-2 overall) and Adrian Arango made five saves in goal. Bonac Boys Volleyball
Defeats Central Islip The East Hampton boys volleyball team took down Central Islip in three straight sets, 25-17, 25-9, 25-13. The Bonackers are 4-5 overall. Strong Second Half
for ... by Drew Budd

Weekly Roundup: Bonac Boys Golf Hands Westhampton Beach Its First Loss; Pierson Boys Soccer, Field Hockey Earn First Wins; Alvarez's Two Goals Lead Mariner Boys Soccer

East Hampton Boys Golf Hand ’Canes Their First Loss Charlie McMillan shot a match-low 33 to help lead the Bonackers to a 7.5-1.5 victory over previously unbeaten Westhampton Beach at the Amagansett Golf Club on Monday. East Hampton outshot the Hurricanes, 199-208. Zach Berger shot a team-low 38 for the ’Canes. Though both teams still had to finish out the rest of their regular season schedules this week, if they win out, East Hampton and Westhampton Beach will share the League VIII title this season. Bonac Swimmers Lose Tight Meet to Ward Melville Down two points going into the final event, ... 8 Oct 2025 by Staff Writer

Second-Half Surge Propels Bridgehampton Boys Soccer to Thrilling Tie With Greenport

With 1:05 remaining in the second overtime of a 3-3 tie, Bridgehampton senior goalie Kai ... by Drew Budd

Weekly Roundup: Early Lapse Doesn't Hurt Bonac Girls Swimmers; Hampton Bays Girls Volleyball Back in Win Column; Paga's Header Leads Hurricane Boys Soccer To Big Win

East Hampton Field Hockey
Stops Losing Streak Merritt Bistrian-Emptage had a goal and an assist and Sabrina Texis added a goal to lead East Hampton (4-5 in Division II) to a 2-0 victory over Southampton at the Hon. Fred W. Thiele Jr. Recreational Facility on Stephen Hand’s Path on Thursday, September 25, snapping what had been a three-game losing streak. Brynley Lys added an assist and Izzy Briand made two saves in goal. Alexis Trotman made six saves for Southampton. Despite Early Troubles
Bonac Swimmers 
Win Another Meet The East Hampton/Pierson/Bridgehampton girls swim team defeated Northport/Commack, 99-69, in their final nonleague meet ... 30 Sep 2025 by Staff Writer

Bridgehampton Enjoying Its First Foray Into Varsity Boys Soccer

Yes, Bridgehampton has its first-ever varsity boys soccer team this fall, and yes, the Killer ... 24 Sep 2025 by Drew Budd

Weekly Roundup: Bonac Football Avenges Last Year's Playoff Loss at Hills West; Cook Leads Mariners Cross Country to First Win; Hampton Bays Girls Soccer Tallies Two Wins

Bonac Football Avenges
Last Year’s Playoff Loss The East Hampton/Pierson/Bridgehampton football team defeated host Half Hollow Hills West, 35-10, on Saturday afternoon, on the same field the Bonackers suffered a 52-6 loss in the opening round of the Suffolk County Division III playoffs last season. Theo Ball threw for 190 yards and three touchdowns, one of them to Jackson Ronick who also rushed for 75 yards and two touchdowns. Charlie Stern caught three receptions for 115 yards and recorded six tackles on defense. Livs Kuplins had six tackles and an interception and caught a 25-yard reception for a touchdown for the ... 23 Sep 2025 by Staff Writer

Weekly Roundup: Bridgehampton Boys Soccer, Hampton Bays Boys Volleyball Picks Up First-Ever Victories; East Hampton Girls Soccer On Fire

Bonac Boys Cross Country
Defeats Harborfields The East Hampton boys cross country team defeated Harborfields, 17-38, in its season opener on its home course on school grounds on September 9. According to head coach Kevin Barry, it’s only the second dual meet loss for the Tornadoes in the last five years. The Bonackers swept the top four placements to win the meet outright. Senior Sean Perez, in his first-ever cross country race, won the 2.5-mile race in 13:52, followed closely by senior Liam Knight (13:59) and sophomores Jasper Samuelson (14:09) and Watts Comly-Bolick (14:13). East Hampton Girls Soccer
Stays Undefeated The Bonackers ... 17 Sep 2025 by Staff Writer

Mistakes Pile Up in Pierson Boys Soccer’s Defeat to Port Jeff

There’s work to be done. That was the takeaway after the Pierson boys soccer team ... 16 Sep 2025 by Drew Budd

Pierson Boys Soccer Enters New Chapter Under Haley Luzim

This year will be a rebirth for the Pierson boys soccer team. The past two ... 3 Sep 2025 by Casey Finelli