John Cilli Of Sag Harbor Dies August 18

icon 1 Photo

author on Aug 24, 2015

Sag Harbor native John Cilli died at home on August 18, about two months after a diagnosis of esophageal cancer. He was 87.

Mr. Cilli was born after his parents purchased what is now known as part of Cilli Farm. Two months premature and weighing only 3 pounds, he was wrapped in cotton and placed in a shoe box on the open oven door of an old wooden stove, which served as a makeshift incubator. He worked for many years at Cove Side Dairy, the family-run dairy farm now known as Cilli Farm. In his “retirement,” Mr. Cilli recycled scrap metal and gave away hundreds of his handmade stools and trivets, telling the recipients they had officially joined “The Club.”

Known for his striped railroad hat, suspenders and truck with a horn that made an ah-OOH-gah sound, Mr. Cilli was a regular at a local deli where he met friends for coffee and conversation. Quite the raconteur, he would regale friends, relatives and strangers with tales from his past.

Mr. Cilli is survived by his wife of more than 50 years, Anita; and daughters, Karen Sperling and husband Ray of Sag Harbor, Beth Castor and husband Ed of Texas, and Janet Christiansen and husband Ed of Pennsylvania; grandchildren, Nicholas, Emily and Rebecca Castor, and Kathryn and Sarah Christiansen; a stepdaughter, Diana Morana and husband Dominick; and a step-great-grandchild, Dominick Morana. He is also survived by a sister, Ange Cole of Southampton; and numerous nieces and nephews. He was predeceased by siblings, Vito “Red,” Dominick, Rose, Jean and Nick.

A funeral was held at St. Andrew’s Church in Sag Harbor on Saturday, August 22. Interment followed at St. Andrew’s Cemetery.

Memorial donations may be made to the Sag Harbor Volunteer Ambulance Corps, Box 2725, Sag Harbor, NY 11963 or East End Hospice, Box 1048, Westhampton Beach, NY 11978.

You May Also Like:

Southampton Town Approves 2026 Budget, Piercing Tax Cap, Hiking Pay for Employees

The Southampton Town Board this week unanimously adopted a $143.3 million operating budget for the ... 18 Nov 2025 by Michael Wright

School News, November 20, Southampton Town

Bridgehampton School Honors Local Heroes at Annual Veterans Day Ceremony On November 10, Bridgehampton School ... by Staff Writer

To Lob or Not To Lob? That Is the Question

Pickleball has many different shots depending on your court position, your opponent’s court position and ... by Vinny Mangano

Westhampton Beach Athletes Ready To Take Talents to Next Level

Thomas Machin has had the goal of playing baseball in college since he was 9 ... by Desirée Keegan

Rizzo Finishes 11th in the State To Earn All-State Honors at Cross Country Championships

Evelyn Rizzo capped her breakout cross country season with an 11th place finish at the ... by Drew Budd

Southampton's Hayden Gilmartin Finishes Cross Country Career at State Championship Meet

Hayden Gilmartin finished her high school cross country career at one of the last meets ... by Drew Budd

Southampton Brings Back Boys Volleyball at Junior High Level This Winter; District Also Sending Swimmers to East Hampton

Junior high boys within the Southampton School District should be preparing themselves to bump, set ... by Drew Budd

A Reprieve From Wind, Finally

Waterfowl season is upon us. Saturday will be the main season opener for most duck ... by Mike Wright

Patricia C. Farrell of Sag Harbor Dies November 17

Patricia C. Farrell of Sag Harbor died on November 17 on Quioque. She was 92. A visitation will take place on Friday, November 21, from 3-7 p.m. at the Brockett Funeral Home in Southampton. A funeral Mass will be celebrated on Saturday, November 22, at 10 a.m. at St. Andrew’s Catholic Church in Sag Harbor. Memorial donations to East End Hospice (eeh.org) and Sag Harbor Food Pantry (sagharborfoodpantry.org). A complete obituary will appear in a future edition of The Press. by Staff Writer

Early Momentum Fades as Bonac Football Drops County Semifinal to Sayville

Following his team’s 28-14 loss at Sayville in the Suffolk County Division III semifinal on ... by Drew Budd