John ‘Jack’ A. Kelly of Sag Harbor And Portland, Maine, Dies May 7

icon 1 Photo
John Kelly

John Kelly

author27east on May 15, 2020

John “Jack” A. Kelly of Sag Harbor died in his apartment in Portland, Maine, on May 7. He was 92.

Mr. Kelly was born in Brooklyn on July 20, 1927, the son of John and Joanne (Flaherty) Kelly. He was the third of four children.

Jack lived a full life, his family said. He was a dedicated Grandad, who was always there to pick up his grandchildren from the bus stop or from school, they recounted.

He was driving up until this past December. He worked out three times a week until the age of 91.

He attended Mass every day. He was a Eucharistic minister and a volunteer who counted money for the church.

He also did his own shopping and cooking up until six months before his death. He was a kind man who was positive, caring and always quick with a “dad” joke, according to his family.

He entered the U.S. Navy in 1945 as a high school student. He was a Fireman, First Class V6 USNR.

Following the Navy, he entered the seminary, which he attended for seven years.

After changing his course, he decided to go into education. He received a diploma from Hofstra University in education. He would go on to become a guidance counselor, then a math teacher and finally an assistant principal of West Hollow Junior High in Dix Hills. He worked in the education field for 27 years before retiring.

He married Marion Rita (nee Hefferon) on March 21, 1970. They lived in West Islip, until moving to Southampton. They were married for 32 years before her death in 2002.

He then lived with his daughter Marion, her husband, Chris, and their three children for the past 17 years in both Southampton and Sag Harbor. He recently moved to Portland to be near his daughter Cara and her family. He enjoyed getting to see “Maine’’ grandchildren, but did not like the cold.

He is survived by his daughters, Annmarie Kelly of New York, Marion Tanner of Sag Harbor and her husband Chris, Cara Colgan of Portland, Maine, and her husband Patrick.

He was also survived by eight grandchildren, Stefani Kiefer, John Ryan Gillespie, Ethan Tanner, Quinn Tanner, Gillian “Gigi” Tanner, Cassius Colgan, Mavis Colgan and Magnus Colgan. He was also survived by his sister Eunice Valentine Donlan of New Jersey and her husband Frank; as well as several nieces, nephews, grandnieces and grandnephews.

Mr. Kelly was predeceased by his brother Martin Kelly and sister Joan Kelly.

A small Mass was held on Monday, May 11, in Portland. A Celebration of Life will be held once the requirement of social distancing related to the current pandemic has passed.

Memorial donations in Mr. Kelly’s name can be made to Big Brother Big Sister of Long Island, 145 Sycamore Ave., Islandia, NY 11749, or at www.bbbsli.org; or the Southern Maine Big Brother Big Sisters, 625 Main Street, Westbrook, ME 04092, or at www.SoMeBigs.org.

To share memories of Mr. Kelly or to leave the family an online condolence, please visit www.athutchins.com.

You May Also Like:

Southampton Baseball Player Bailey Brown Is One of Nation's Best

Bailey Brown has quickly solidified herself as one of the best girls baseball players in ... 3 Dec 2025 by Desirée Keegan

Sign the Ban

Pity the poor horseshoe crab. It is, without question, a survivor almost beyond compare. Consider this: There are fossils of the creature dating back 445 million years. Dinosaurs arrived about 200 million to 250 million years ago — which means the time between us and dinosaurs is equal to the time between dinosaurs and the earliest horseshoe crabs. And they’re still here, nearly unchanged. But they finally may have met their match. The American horseshoe crab has “vulnerable” status, according to the International Union for Conservation of Nature. The population faces a whole series of challenges, including sea-level rise, coupled ... by Editorial Board

Southampton Boys Regroup, Target Another Playoff Run; Girls Keep Growing Program

With aspirations of making it to the New York State Championships, the Southampton boys basketball ... by Drew Budd

Reloaded Bridgehampton Boys Take Aim at 10th State Title

From the hunters to the hunted. That’s the way Bridgehampton boys basketball head coach Carl ... by Drew Budd

Pierson Girls Eye Playoff Push; Boys Seek Big Jump After Rebuild

For the past two years, the Pierson girls basketball team has lost by just a ... by Drew Budd

Southampton Village Denies FOIL Requests for Draft Historic District Report

The status and availability of a report prepared by the firm Preservation Studios, which was ... by Cailin Riley

Season Already Underway for East Hampton/Pierson/Southampton Boys Swim Team

The East Hampton/Pierson/Southampton boys swim team’s season is already underway, as the team competed in ... by Drew Budd

Hampton Bays Girls Confident They'll Have Solid Showing This Season

Experience is a key component for the Hampton Bays girls basketball team this season. Not ... by Desirée Keegan

Ryan Hernandez Takes Over Senior-Laden Westhampton Beach Boys Basketball Squad

The Westhampton Beach boys basketball team has made the playoffs the past two seasons, which ... by Drew Budd

Westhampton Beach Girls Looking To Pick Up Where They Left Off

Returning four of the starting five should prove beneficial to the Westhampton Beach girls basketball ... by Desirée Keegan