Mary Roberta Lewis Hildreth of Sagaponack Dies July 26 - 27 East

Sag Harbor Express

Mary Roberta Lewis Hildreth of Sagaponack Dies July 26

icon 1 Photo
Mary Roberta Lewis Hildreth

Mary Roberta Lewis Hildreth

authorStaff Writer on Aug 21, 2023

Mary Roberta Lewis Hildreth of Sagaponack died on July 26 at the East End Hospice Kanas Center for Hospice Care on Quiogue. She was 94.

She was born in Sag Harbor on August 27, 1928, to Harold Flint Lewis and Elfrieda Lewis (née Garypie). She went to Southampton High School and graduated in 1946. She went on to earn a degree in education in 1950 from the State Teachers College at New Paltz (now SUNY New Paltz).

Hildreth taught fourth-grade in the East Hampton School District until she became a mother in 1953. She opened a private half-day nursery school six years later, when her second daughter was 3. She closed the nursery school in 1971 to help her husband in the Sagaponack General Store and Post Office.

She was an active member of the Bridgehampton Presbyterian Church and an advocate for the underdog and the lonely, her family said, helping those in need when she could, providing gifts for the poor at Christmas and writing weekly letters to shut-ins from the church.

Hildreth also was environmentally conscious, creating little waste by reusing plastic bags, serving small but nutritious meals, and line-drying laundry whenever possible.

The family would like to thank East End Hospice Kanas Center for Hospice Care for their loving support and guidance.

She is survived by her daughter, Deborah Gail Hildreth Phelps (and Ted Phelps) of Valatie, New York; son-in-law, John Moss of Mattituck; grandchildren, Bree Elizabeth Moss, Eric Hildreth Moss, and Eleanor Hildreth Phelps; sister, Dorothy Lewis Tennant (and Gil Tennant); sister-in-law, Mary Louise (Mimi) Hildreth Leonard; brother-in-law, Tom Sayer; several nieces and nephews; and two great-granddaughters. She was predeceased by her husband, Merrall Topping Hildreth; daughter, Donna Jeanne Hildreth Moss; and siblings, Beatrice Lewis Holden (and John Holden), Eleanor May Lewis Graves (and Stuart Graves Jr.), George Lewis (and Pamela Gaynor Lewis), and Nancy Lewis Sayre.

A Celebration of Life memorial service will be held at the Bridgehampton Presbyterian Church on August 27 at 2 p.m., with the Reverend Adrian Pratt officiating.

Memorial donations may be made to East End Hospice Kanas Center for Hospice Care, P.O. Box 1048, Westhampton Beach, NY 11978-7048; and The Bridgehampton Presbyterian Church, P.O. Box 3038, Bridgehampton, NY 11932.

You May Also Like:

Bridgehampton Child Care & Recreational Center's Literacy Nook Event Is Part of Larger Movement

As the executive director of the Bridgehampton Child Care & Recreational Center, Bonnie Cannon has ... 19 Jun 2025 by Cailin Riley

Sag Harbor Village Police Reports for the Week of June 19

SAG HARBOR VILLAGE — Sag Harbor Village Police arrested Jeffrey D. Ward, 59, of Sag Harbor on misdemeanor charges of driving under the influence of drugs and criminal possession of a controlled substance in the seventh degree, namely amphetamine, Friday night. Police had initially received a report of a possible drunk driver in the area of Jermain Avenue and Division Street. The officer sent to investigate reported that he spotted Ward behind the wheel of a 2009 Honda Accord on Jermain Avenue driving east very slowly in the westbound lane. The officer said that Ward also had his head down ... 18 Jun 2025 by Staff Writer

Use Discretion

You don’t need to hear it from us, but: Times are tense. It’s a moment when, in our local communities, we need to be more careful to avoid knee-jerk reactions, and while vigilance is a virtue, don’t assume everything you see on social media is what it appears to be. At the same time, communication is going to be key. An incident last week demonstrated that all of us — including local police agencies — need to be aware of the unique moment, and take steps to make sure people are not frightened needlessly. A photo circulated last week that ... by Editorial Board

Taking Charge

Sometimes the hardest thing is to acknowledge when you need a little more help — and to figure out the most cost-effective way to get it. Last week, the Sag Harbor Village Board said it was planning to hire a planner to work with its regulatory boards, rather than relying solely on outside help via contracts. It’ll seek proposals for “professional planning, engineering and on-call consulting services.” There’s no reason to think this is necessarily a reflection on the job being done by Nelson Pope Voorhis, the planning consulting firm from Melville that is contracted frequently by South Fork municipalities ... by Editorial Board

Do the Right Thing

When it comes to New York State’s mistreatment of the Montaukett Nation, it seems like Groundhog Day: A new year, but the same outcome, without fail. It’s insulting, it’s despicable — and it must end. This is the sixth time the State Legislature has put recognition of the Montaukett on the governor’s desk in Albany, with overwhelming, almost unanimous support. There is absolutely no ambiguity about the legislature’s support for the idea, and it’s been championed by local legislators for years. They’ve all done their jobs and deserve a note of thanks. Governor Kathy Hochul has vetoed the bill three ... by Editorial Board

Another HBCL Season Begins

The Westhampton Aviators and South Shore Clippers got the Hamptons Collegiate Baseball League season started ... by Drew Budd

Southampton Town United Honors Memory of Beloved Soccer Coach at Annual Festival

“Soccer truly has no borders.” That was the message spelled out on the back of ... by Cailin Riley

Harris Yulin, Titan of East End Theater, Dies at 87

When he was a young actor in New York City, Steve Hamilton went to see ... by Dan Stark

Surfrider Signs Offer Way for Beachgoers To Keep Tabs on Water Quality at Swimming Holes

The South Fork’s ocean beaches, the crown jewel of the region and the main engine ... by Michael Wright

Options for Pierson High School Gym Renovations, School Safety Plan Will Be Discussed at Next Board of Education Meeting

At the latest Sag Harbor Board of Education meeting on June 9, President Sandi Kruel made a point of encouraging the district to provide an update on the next steps in a proposed upgrade to the Pierson High School gymnasium. Members of the district’s educational facilities planning committee have been working over the last several months to come up with proposals for renovations and upgrades to the gym, which is in need of repair. The committee has focused on doing outreach within the community to see what parents and taxpayers think is feasible. “The board, over the next few weeks, ... by Cailin Riley