Murder Suspects Lured Victim To Secluded Area For Robbery, According To Court Documents

icon 1 Photo
The two suspects charged with murder, Tyara Lemus, left, and Alcides Lopez-Cambara were arraigned on second-degree murder charges Thursday morning in Riverhead Town Justice Court. STEVE WICK

The two suspects charged with murder, Tyara Lemus, left, and Alcides Lopez-Cambara were arraigned on second-degree murder charges Thursday morning in Riverhead Town Justice Court. STEVE WICK

Joe Werkmeister and Steve Wick on Dec 10, 2020

The two Hampton Bays suspects charged with the murder of a former Sag Harbor man in Riverhead last month allegedly lured the victim to a secluded area with the intention of robbing him and then beat him with a “blunt force object,” according to the felony criminal complaint filed in Riverhead Town Justice Court.

The younger defendant, Tyara Lemus, 18, — both suspects reportedly lived at 7 Allomara Road — allegedly admitted to authorities taking part in the robbery, according to the court document.

Police found Marco Grisales, 39, in a vehicle abandoned on Roanoke Avenue November 11 and he had died from a head injury, said Detective Lieutenant Kevin Beyrer, the head of Suffolk County police’s homicide squad, in an interview last month. Investigators remained on scene for about 14 hours and no weapon was found at the crime scene.

Cell phone communication between the defendants allegedly links them to the crime, according to the criminal complaint filed against Alcides Lopez-Cambara, 40.

Both defendants were remanded without bail during brief court appearances Thursday morning. Their attorneys both entered pleas of not guilty on their behalf at their arraignments before Riverhead Judge Lori Hulse.

Suffolk County police announced the arrests early Thursday morning.

Neither the assistant district attorney nor the defendant’s attorneys shed any light on the killing during the arraignment. It’s unclear how the defendants and victim knew each other.

They are both due to appear in court again December 15 in what would be a virtual court appearance.

Attorney Austin Manghan of Riverhead, who represented Ms. Lemus, requested that the December 15 date be for paperwork.

“I anticipate that there will be a handup on that date, so I’m not looking for her to appear on that date,” he said, since the case will eventually be transferred to county court due to the felony charge. A grand jury indictment would then be used to bring the case to county court.

While both defendants appeared before the judge in person at Riverhead Town Justice Court, part of the proceeding was done virtually. Mr. Manghan and the assistant district attorney, Daryl Levy, both participated virtually.

Mr. Lopez-Cambara was represented by attorney John Halverson of Patchogue.

Mr. Halverson said he intended to make a bail application at some point.

An interpreter was used virtually during the arraignments to translate for both defendants.

Both suspects would be facing a life sentence based on the second-degree murder charge.

Mr. Lopez-Cambara still has a case pending in Southampton Town Justice Court related to a February arrest in Hampton Bays for driving while ability impaired by alcohol and drugs and aggravated unlicensed operation of a motor vehicle.

This article originally appeared on the Riverhead News-Review website and is republished here with permission.

You May Also Like:

Protests Over ICE Detentions Continue To Ripple Across South Fork

Protests over the detention of at least a dozen people by federal immigration agents in ... 15 Nov 2025 by Staff Writer

Arrest Made in Amagansett Hit-and-Run That Left Pedestrian Seriously Injured

An Amagansett woman suffered serious injuries when she was struck by a car on Montauk ... by Staff Writer

Brown Budda Opens Cannabis Shop in Southampton, but Town Threatens Court Action

Southampton Town has threatened to take a second cannabis dispensary to court because the business ... 14 Nov 2025 by Michael Wright

Benjamin ‘Shonowe’ Kellis Haile of the Shinnecock Nation Dies November 12

Benjamin “Shonowe” Kellis Haile of the Shinnecock Nation died on November 12 in Southampton. He was 60. A complete obituary will appear in a future edition of The Press. by Staff Writer

Westhampton Beach Fire Department Extinguishes Car Fire

The Westhampton Beach Fire Department was paged out for a car fire just north of ... by Staff Writer

Growing Wellness: New Community Garden at Stony Brook Southampton To Offer 'Produce Prescriptions'

Since its creation, the Food Lab at Stony Brook Southampton has been committed to studying ... by Cailin Riley

In Wake of Immigration Detentions, Advocacy Group Is Left With Many Holes To Plug

While the ICE sweep last week that ensnared a dozen immigrants has sparked outrage and ... 13 Nov 2025 by Michael Wright

Bars Over Southampton Village Hall Windows, Former Jail Cells, Will Be Removed

For some unlucky people, the workplace can feel like a prison. There’s no reason to ... by Cailin Riley

Cleaning Out

There is no setting on binoculars that works in the fog — everything in the distance remains indistinct, and that is fine. Here, the low place, called Sagg Swamp, begins a nearly uninterrupted corridor of unbuilt-upon land: wetlands, ponds and kettleholes; the Long Pond Greenbelt runs for miles to the old harbor. Today, contained, the only fog is there. It rises up from the dark muck to smudge the damp foliage with its dreamy, silver light. So, above, as the crow flies, the air is tinted between gold and pink. Fog is a reoccurring theme, because it reveals a sense ... by Marilee Foster

'Novembrance'

Gaudy October is gone. The November landscape is muted colors, falling leaves and skeletal branches. The month opens with reminders of death. In the Catholic Church, November first is All Saints’ Day. On November 2, All Souls Day is dedicated to praying for the souls of the departed. The Mexican tradition of the Day of the Dead is celebrated on the same days but has a more festive air. It’s also observed across the United States. The All-Souls Procession has been an annual event since 1990 in Tucson, Arizona. San Antonio, Texas, is known for its Muertos Fest and river ... by Denise Gray Meehan