New Community Center And Affordable Apartments Eyed For Bridgehampton - 27 East

New Community Center And Affordable Apartments Eyed For Bridgehampton

icon 1 Photo
Town officials approved the concept of demolishing the existing community center and building a new one that includes affordable apartments in Bridgehampton.   KITTY MERRILL

Town officials approved the concept of demolishing the existing community center and building a new one that includes affordable apartments in Bridgehampton. KITTY MERRILL

Kitty Merrill on Aug 15, 2022

A new 13,000-square-foot Southampton Town community center replete with 15 or 16 affordable apartments may be on the horizon for Bridgehampton.

Members of the Southampton Town Board discussed the concept during their Thursday, August 11, work session. At the table were Housing Director Kara Bak, Planning and Development Administrator Janice Scherer and Town Engineer Thomas Houghton.

The goal of the confab was to solicit the sense of the board on the concept. Members were unanimously supportive.

“I’m all for it,” Councilwoman Cynthia McNamara said. “We need to do more stuff like this.”

Councilman Rick Martel appreciates the dual use of the building. “I think it’s low impact to the community,” he said, adding, “It’s a step into the future for us.”

Built in 1986, the current community center is showing its age, and, said Houghton, is “underutilized.” Located on 3.5 acres on the Bridgehampton-Sag Harbor Turnpike, it would be demolished to make way for the new center and apartments.

Given the high price of housing on the East End, Supervisor Jay Schneiderman noted that “We’re looking at our own lands to see if there’s anything we could do” to provide more affordable housing, Additionally, he noted that areas east of the Shinnecock Canal are where the demand is greatest.

No plans or illustrations were available, but there will be a concept sketch for the public to view as the process moves forward for the needed zoning change.

First up is a code tweak to permit housing at the site — it’s currently not allowed. Schneiderman wants to have a public hearing to garner input from the community before incurring the expense of hiring an architect and designer. An affordable housing overlay may be added to the parcel, Scherer said.

Grants may be available to defray building expenses if units are dedicated for seniors or developmentally disabled residents. Schneiderman said he prefers the units be used for workforce housing rather than senior dwellings.

“I’m leaning toward not restricting it to seniors,” he said. “We really need workforce housing.”

While opponents who come out against such housing generally worry about increased students and the impact on the local school districts, Scherer noted the Bridgehampton School District is not overcrowded.

“We’re not talking about some big apartment building,” the administrator added.

The property’s look and feel from the street won’t be different from what’s there now — “only nicer,” Scherer opined.

The goal is to shift from the 1980s industrial design to one that reflects the residential, shingle style of the nearby Bridgehampton Child Care and Recreational Center, Houghton said. Bringing the building into the future will mean sustainability features, like solar panels and electric vehicle charging stations, will be included.

Rent payments for the apartments could cover the debt service on their construction cost. Bak said a one-bedroom could go for $1,450 a month for eligible low-income residents, and $1,904 for moderate-income individuals.

There will be a small sewage treatment plant on the site, “but we haven’t really ‘flushed’ that out yet,” Scherer punned.

“I feel like we have almost a moral obligation to move forward,” Schneiderman said, as he asked colleagues on the dais to weigh in.

Councilman John Bouvier offered that the plan is a minor project toward the goal of solving a major problem. “The project is a good start,” he said. “It integrates and fits well into the community.” Plus, he added, town officials have always had a goal of distributing affordable dwellings throughout the town.

To that end, Councilman Tommy John Schiavoni pointed to larger-scale projects proposed in Sag Harbor Village and East Hampton Town, just over the border. He was hopeful more housing near the eastern portion of Southampton Town would help.

Adam Potter, the face of Friends of Bay Street, is proposing a mixed-use development with 79 units of affordable housing and 30,000 square feet of commercial space on Bridge and Rose streets in downtown Sag Harbor Village.

In East Hampton, a community housing project envisions up to 60 affordable units. Earlier this spring, members of the East Hampton Town Board voted to add an affordable housing overlay to property off State Route 114 in the Wainscott School District, just outside of Sag Harbor.

Schiavoni emphasized that the Bridgehampton project would be built regardless of whether the Community Housing Fund referendum is approved in November. But the money it amasses through a half percent tax on real estate transfers could be used for construction, it was noted. Rent money would then go back into the fund.

The board voted earlier this summer to send the proposed CHF to the Suffolk County Board of Elections for placement on the ballot.

“I’d like to see the people who live here volunteer for the Bridgehampton Fire Department and Ambulance. They need people,” Schiavoni said.

“This could be a model we could do on properties this size and with this many units,” Schneiderman concluded.

Currently, the town requires any developer to set aside 20 percent of units as affordable when residential projects are proposed. Scherer noted that during a recent discussion with the Suffolk County Planning Commission, when she told them the town requires 20 percent set aside, “They suggested increasing it to 30 percent.”

Accessory dwelling apartments are the best way to address the need to provide affordable units, Schneiderman put forth. If a homeowner creates an apartment within an existing footprint, “Nobody would know it’s even there,” he said. Scherer reported her department received pushback from potential creators of accessory apartments when it comes to finding income-eligible tenants. People don’t want to be told to whom to rent.

The supervisor asked for a full-bodied discussion of the accessory apartment program to be scheduled. “I want to make it as easy as possible to do it,” he said.

You May Also Like:

Oddly Misguided

Last week’s Express Session at The American Hotel focused on the subject of parking [“Sag Harbor Panel Tackles Parking Problems, Business Impacts at ‘Local Matters’ Discussion,” 27east.com, October 29]. The format called for the audience to ask questions of the panelists, unlike prior Express Sessions, where preprepared subjects were given to the panel by the moderator for comment. About halfway through this meeting, former Mayor Jim LaRocca rose to deliver an off-topic statement critical of the village’s review boards’ conduct regarding the 2 Main Street/7-Eleven properties on West Water Street. Mr. LaRocca suggested that the review boards were working in ... 3 Nov 2025 by Staff Writer

Poisoned Dialogue

To John Neely [“Get Facts Right,” Letters, October 23], thank you for your comments. I’ll try to address them briefly. James Comey, John Brennan and James Clapper seriously damaged the United States’ reputation for fairness and justice. They have been exposed for using politically motivated lies to subvert our presidency. There is plenty of evidence to back up my argument. Unfortunately, it will be difficult to convict, due to legal statutes of limitation. Your comments about the affordability of health care, housing, etc. are problems directly attributable to the obscene amounts of money Democrats flooded our economy with during COVID. ... by Staff Writer

Welcome Home

The Pierson High School Class of 1995 extends its sincere appreciation to Sag Harbor Elementary School Principal Matt Malone and his security staff for their warm hospitality during a recent tour of both the elementary and high school campuses. The alumni also wish to recognize Jorge Maya for his time and effort in serving as the group’s guide through the elementary school. In addition, the Class of 1995 expresses its deepest gratitude to Eric Peele and the staff at Page Sag Harbor restaurant, as well as Amber Tagliasacchi and the staff at Il Cappuccino, for their generous support and exceptional ... by Staff Writer

A Pattern

I encourage everyone to watch the last Southampton Village Board meeting. You’ll again see exactly what we’ve come to expect from Southampton Mayor Bill Manger: a pattern of concealment and condescension that has defined his time in office. This latest episode is no exception. When a trustee simply asked him to release his plan to expand the historic district — something he promised during last June’s Express News Group mayoral debate — he immediately deflected and attacked the person who asked. During the debate, he publicly agreed that any expansion should be decided by the entire board. Instead, he’s now ... by Staff Writer

Not Funny

In response to the cartoon “Paw Prints”: I may not share all your opinions. Sometimes I find your cartoons amusing. But I am really offended by the October 23 “White House Halloween Party (or is it?).” The character in front, in a Playboy bunny outfit, is sexist. Nothing funny or imaginative about it. Joanne Rosko Southampton by Staff Writer

Sound Familiar?

Andrew Messenger naively and grossly underestimates the environmental degradation caused by an overabundance of lawns [“Leave My Lawn Alone, Please,” Viewpoint, Residence, October 30]. Groundwater pollution is a major environmental problem. A Sagg Pond watershed update with Dr. Molly Graffin of the Cornell Cooperative Extension Marine Program recently discussed research findings showing groundwater nitrogen toxicity 30 to 40 feet underground draining into Sagg Pond. Large pipes are being sent deep into the ground to create a long semipermeable barrier to scrub the water of the poisonous nitrogen and are proposed for a much larger area. For this major engineering project ... by Staff Writer

Indivisible

“Nobody wants you here.” This is what a passerby in an expensive foreign sports car yelled at me while I participated in a demonstration against our current administration’s tactics. For me, that is always a hilarious statement. My roots here in Southampton predate the Constitution, the Bill of Rights and the foundation of our republic. I would bet a good sum that he is a recent city transplant who does not know the difference between a republic and a democracy. His point of view, one can only guess at, obviously pro-Trump. One set of very wealthy people see him as ... by Staff Writer

Passion for Animals

I want to thank everyone for the wonderful outpouring of support I’ve received since I began writing letters. What started as one message defending the rights of the Shinnecock Nation and Indigenous people has grown into something larger, thanks to you. Your kind words have inspired me to write about a variety of topics that matter to our community. But at heart, my greatest passion is helping animals. Right now, there are many cats and dogs in need of homes, and I’m currently fostering several wonderful cats myself. If you’ve ever thought about fostering or adopting, I encourage you to ... by Staff Writer

A Reminder

The damage to the bridge that carries Route 27 over the Shinnecock Canal reminds us how vulnerable we are on the South Fork to climate change and its impact on infrastructure. It is also a reminder that regional commuter traffic has exploded over the past 25 years, leaving no margin for error. While the bridge repair is a major setback, even smaller incidents like tree damage or fender-benders have outsized impact on a road system operating well beyond its design capacity. We need to continue regional planning efforts to improve transportation, increase workforce housing, and give tools to residents and ... by Staff Writer

No Empathy

For several years, I have read Ed Surgan’s letters, usually in disbelief. I’ve often thought about replying but always considered it a waste of time, though I was always delighted at others who were enraged enough to do so, especially Frances Genovese (whose brilliant letters should be bound and published in a dedicated volume as a historical document of our times), and now John Neely [“Get Facts Right,” Letters, October 23]. But Surgan’s letter in The Southampton Press on October 30 [“Bankrupt Leadership”] suggesting that this administration is “uncommonly skilled,” and that all protests are a result of TDS (“Trump ... by Staff Writer