Newly Elected County Legislator Catherine Stark Charged With Driving While Ability Impaired by Drugs After Riverhead Traffic Stop - 27 East
logo logo logo logo

Government / Police / Police News / Southampton Press / 2220192

Newly Elected County Legislator Catherine Stark Charged With Driving While Ability Impaired by Drugs After Riverhead Traffic Stop

icon 1 Photo
Catherine Stark

Catherine Stark

Tom Gogola on Dec 5, 2023

Suffolk County Legislator-elect Catherine Stark was charged with driving while ability impaired by drugs, a misdemeanor, after being pulled over by Riverhead Town Police on December 3.

Stark, 60, was elected in November to replace Al Krupski as Suffolk County’s 1st District legislator after Krupski left his post to successfully run for Southold Town supervisor. Stark, a Republican, had worked for the Democrat Krupski as a legislative aide before running for office this year.

According to multiple news reports, Stark pleaded not guilty to the charges on December 4 in Riverhead Town Justice Court after spending the night at police headquarters in Riverhead following her arrest.

She reportedly told the police officer who pulled her over that she had taken one or two oxycodone pills for back pain, according to media reports from Newsday, News 12 Long Island and the local Riverhead press. Oxycodone is an opioid used to treat pain.

Stark’s attorney, Steven Losquadro, told the court, and reporters in attendance at the arraignment, that Stark had taken the drugs because of what he said was a “previously undisclosed” cancer diagnosis, though Stark’s campaign website notes that she is a cancer survivor.

In a statement, he said she had taken the drugs “hours” before she was arrested, according to Newsday’s report on the arraignment. Stark’s oncologist prescribed her drugs to help treat her cancer, he told the court, and he suggested that she ultimately would be released from the charge.

Stark was charged with DWAI following a 911 call to Riverhead Town Police at around 2:30 p.m. on December 3 that reported an erratic driver around Pondview Road, according to the initial police report.

The DWAI charge includes possible fines and penalties of up to one year in jail.

According to federal Food and Drug Administration guidance to physicians, “patients should be advised” that oxycodone-based pharmaceutical products “may impair mental and/or physical ability required for the performance of potentially hazardous tasks (e.g., driving, operating heavy machinery).”

Under state law, a person can be convicted of DWAI if they take prescribed medication but don’t follow warning-label instructions regarding the dangers of driving while under their influence, or if they take prescribed medication but don’t follow a doctor’s orders regarding driving or other activities while they are taking the drug.

You May Also Like:

Westhampton Beach Appoints Assistant Principal for Elementary Curriculum

Jessica Weinberg has been appointed the assistant principal for elementary curriculum at Westhampton Beach Elementary ... 21 Oct 2025 by Desirée Keegan

More State Aid for Farm to School Programs Will Be Celebrated at East End Food Institute

While cuts to a large number of programs aimed at helping public schools continue at ... by Cailin Riley

PHOTOS: 'No Kings' Rally Held In East Hampton

“No Kings” rallies were held all over the United States on Saturday, East Hampton was ... 20 Oct 2025 by Staff Writer

Yes, MAGA

Cyndi McNamara is, too, a MAGA — if MAGA means “McNamara Against Government Asininity.” Since coming our way, she has done her homework, sought out the public’s concerns, and been available and open and conscientious throughout. Most important, she actually plows her way through the slippery mountain of paper and dross data generated by planners, consultants, engineers, experts and other know-it-alls who generate hackneyed ideas and big bills. And whom do they work for? She is clear-sighted, informed and measured — a necessary asset and corrective on an often clueless, self-serving, brain-dead board. And her cards are on the table, ... by Staff Writer

Deep Commitment

I have lived in Westhampton since 2011 and have followed Maria Moore’s work closely, first as mayor of Westhampton Beach and now as Southampton Town supervisor. Over the years, I’ve had several opportunities to listen to her and speak with her directly. She has always impressed me as a calm, straightforward and genuinely caring leader who values dialogue and treats everyone with respect. As supervisor, Maria has continued to show that same steady and thoughtful approach. She has focused on the practical issues that truly matter: protecting water quality, promoting renewable energy, improving waste management, and keeping our town government ... by Staff Writer

Driving Around

As Suffolk County residents will say, should we take the ferries between Suffolk and New England, or should we “drive around”? The “drive around” involves navigating the web of roads and bridges to our far west. And that can be quite a trip, as I learned last week, with that ferocious nor’easter hitting us and causing cancellations of service on both the Cross Sound Ferry between Orient Point and New London, and the Port Jefferson-Bridgeport ferry. We were taking a little vacation in southern Vermont — in the lovely town of Landgrove, a kind of Brigadoon in Vermont — and ... by Karl Grossman

High-Stakes Hotline

Some readers might be old enough to have experienced the Cuban Missile Crisis. It began 63 years ago this week, when President John F. Kennedy announced a blockade of Cuba in response to the Soviet Union building ballistic missile sites on the island. One would think such a close brush with nuclear war would have been the inspiration for the hotline between Washington, D.C., and Moscow. Yes, sort of. Such a system was used for the first time only 10 months after the crisis, on August 30, 1963, a call between Kennedy and the Soviet leader Nikita Khrushchev. With Presidents ... by Tom Clavin

Broken Southampton

What was once a charming park, alive with birds, butterflies and bunnies, is now a dust bowl of holes, trash and construction debris. The bird feeders at Moses Park are flat on the ground, flies have replaced the wildlife, and village trucks sit idle there all weekend long, as if they’re on permanent display. The new “playground” is another head-scratcher: flimsy, uneven and destined to make personal-injury lawyers very happy. And, of course, the village sends in weekend crews on overtime pay to fix the mess they created. The result? Taxpayers are paying more for less, a trademark of Mayor ... by Staff Writer

Save the Village

I met with Mayor Bill Manger and the head of the Building Department, Chris Talbot. We agreed to explore a plan to help reduce the number of cars on our roads. Now, it’s a matter of following through on this concept. This plan would require any construction permit to have a transportation calculation. The developers and contractors would have to control their sites and the number of cars that would be there on a daily basis. We must save the village. I’ll keep you posted. Gerald Rosengarten Southampton Village by Staff Writer

Job Well Done

Sundy Schermeyer first ran for Southampton Town clerk in 2006 and beat her opponent. She ran a second time unopposed, and when she ran for third, fourth and fifth terms, she was cross-endorsed by both the Republican and Democratic parties. Why? She does a spectacular job. As town clerk, she oversees the record-keeping and filing system of the Town Board, in addition to overseeing the records for over 37 other departments. She brought the town clerk’s office into the digital age. She implemented an online BID/RFD portal for vendors to bid on town projects and upgraded the process of making ... by Staff Writer