Patricia Lynch, Fearless Journalist Who Took Down Cult Leaders, Dies At 82 - 27 East

Patricia Lynch, Fearless Journalist Who Took Down Cult Leaders, Dies At 82

icon 4 Photos
Pat Lynch with her dog, Mr. Ben, at Southampton Town Hall.   DANA SHAW

Pat Lynch with her dog, Mr. Ben, at Southampton Town Hall. DANA SHAW

Pat Lynch in 2010.

Pat Lynch in 2010.

Pat Lynch

Pat Lynch

Former NBC investigative journalist Pat Lynch was undaunted by threats made against her in May 1978,while filming Synanon cult's property from a deserted public road in Marshall, California. She and her crew were confronted by armed men and women who held the journalists captive at gunpoint for three hours.

Former NBC investigative journalist Pat Lynch was undaunted by threats made against her in May 1978,while filming Synanon cult's property from a deserted public road in Marshall, California. She and her crew were confronted by armed men and women who held the journalists captive at gunpoint for three hours.

authorMichelle Trauring on Feb 23, 2021

If not by face, Patricia Lynch was known by name — and reputation.

She was a force, a fearless investigative journalist who exposed cults and their leaders for “NBC Nightly News.” As one of the first women in her field, the two-time Emmy Award-winning producer blazed a path for women in male-dominated television news, splitting her time between New York and Southampton, and drawing ire as a hotly contested local figure here.

She owned who she was, through and through.

Ms. Lynch died on February 3 from complications of Alzheimer’s disease at her home in Manhattan, according to the New York Times, and left no immediate survivors. She was 82.

“I thought her story was so interesting. I thought she was very interesting,” said Sag Harbor-based author Tom Clavin, who helped Ms. Lynch pen a book proposal about 13 years ago. “She was rather a formidable person and the idea of her being a pioneer in her field was intriguing.”

Patricia Kathleen Lynch was born on March 5, 1938, in Floral Park to Harold and Violet Lynch, who were teachers in the New York City school system. She graduated from the now defunct College of New Rochelle with a bachelor’s degree in English in 1959, followed by a master’s from Boston College in the same subject two years later.

First a reporter for a Gannett newspaper in Mount Vernon, Ms. Lynch moved to CBS News, where she worked on the “Twenty-First Century” science series with Walter Cronkite, as well as news specials with Mike Wallace and Harry Reasoner. One of them led to her first book, “The National Environment Test,” followed by “What’s It All About, Charlie Brown?” before she joined the investigative unit of “NBC Nightly News.”

It was 1977, and she was one of the first women to be named an investigative producer on the team.

“Her world of broadcast news in the 1960s and 1970s, and even into the ’80s, on one hand, at best, you could probably count the number of female journalists who played a prominent role,” Mr. Clavin said. “And she was constantly butting up against that. She had to develop a pretty tough hide.”

Ms. Lynch quickly sharpened her focus on fringe groups run by charming, charismatic leaders, starting with a series on the Synanon cult in California — a story that she broke and, as a result, faced multiple death threats. While filming, cult members held the journalist and her crew hostage for three hours while they blocked the roads in and out of the compound.

But even that experience didn’t stop her from taking on another cult leader: the Reverend Jim Jones, who had created Jonestown in Guyana in November 1976. The series was set to premiere in October 1978, following at least 20 hours of interviews with Jones, his followers, his detractors and former cult members, when NBC executives yanked it — spooked by letters promising violence if it aired — and pulled Ms. Lynch off the story.

“She was the one who was on the very cutting edge of alerting people to the impact of cults and what was out there,” Mr. Clavin said. “Jonestown was her story, and she was not allowed to go there because she was a woman — and one that was a pain in the neck for the male bosses. If it was a man, it would have been called ‘assertive’ or ‘bold.’ But because it was a woman, it was a negative.”

In her place, NBC sent reporter Don Harris and a camera crew to Jonestown, to cover U.S. Representative Leo Ryan’s visit to the compound. Ms. Lynch desperately tried to reach Mr. Harris by phone, to warn him about the mental deterioration of Rev. Jones and his followers, but he never picked up, she wrote in her book proposal.

Three weeks later, Mr. Harris, Mr. Ryan, members of his delegation, cameraman Bob Brown, other innocent bystanders and over 900 residents of Jonestown — including 300 children — were dead, following a mass murder and suicide.

“I knew I could have made a difference had my series aired when it should have a month before the massacre,” Ms. Lynch wrote in her proposal.

She jumped ship to “ABC News Closeup” in protest, before rejoining NBC News after its leadership changed. She turned her attention toward Lyndon LaRouche, a perennial presidential candidate who ran eight times and led a “violence-prone, anti-Semitic cult that smeared its opponents and sued its critics,” the New York Times said Ms. Lynch recounted in a 1985 article in The Columbia Journalism Review.

When her reporting went mainstream, LaRouche fanatics picketed her apartment building, where Paul Pamias had recently started working as a doorman. They carried signs that read, “Lynch Pat Lynch,” and the then 28-year-old said he thought to himself, “Oh, I’ve gotta meet this woman.”

A fast, and 38-year-long friendship, was born. Mr. Pamias described her as revered by the building staff and an, overall, sweet woman, “until you mess with her.”

“She was totally, totally unafraid of anyone or anything,” he said. “The running joke at her Manhattan apartment building was, ‘You know why Jim Jones drank the Kool-Aid? He heard Pat Lynch was coming after him!’”

Ms. Lynch would go on to win two Emmy Awards — one for her investigation of Mr. LaRouche, which led to his indictment and conviction — and was nominated for 10 in total. Her work on the LaRouche story also earned her the prestigious Dupont Columbia Award.

She left NBC in the early 1990s and became a freelance writer, her articles appearing in Family Circle, The Wall Street Journal, Mademoiselle, New York Magazine and The Southampton Press, where she penned a column, “Shelter Stories.”

Much of her material was sourced from her experiences volunteering at the Southampton Animal Shelter and the Riverhead Animal Shelter, which both later banned her after she publicly criticized their euthanasia policies. She sued the former in 2007, three years after her termination, for violating her First Amendment rights and the court ruled in her favor, initially awarding her $251,000 and later reducing it to $50,000.

“Pat was a pistol,” recalled Joseph Shaw, executive editor of the Express News Group, which publishes The Southampton Press. “She and I spoke a lot, and it wasn’t always pleasant — she never held back when she had a complaint. But I had so much respect for her as a journalist, and we really developed a great friendship over the years. Her passion for animals was unmatched. She’ll be missed.”

You May Also Like:

Hahn Hits Career-High 34 in Westhampton’s Playoff Loss to Deer Park

It may have been Truman Hahn’s first playoff appearance, but you wouldn’t know it. The ... 26 Feb 2024 by Desirée Keegan

Hideous Glow

Regarding “Will State Allow Access?” [“Officials Offer Details About Proposed Shinnecock Gas Station and Travel Plaza,” 27east.com, February 14]: As a 70-plus-year visitor to and resident of eastern Long Island, I have regularly traveled Sunrise Highway/Route 27 over those years. My initial reaction to the two large electronic billboards erected by the Shinnecock Nation was first of shock, and, second, of disgust. For anyone traveling down Route 27, lined with green trees and the smattering of informative road signs, to see these hideous glowing structures that are totally out of character with their surroundings, I was stunned. Yes, I am ... by Staff Writer

Crickets

When the previous Southampton Town Board held its special meeting on December 27, 2023, the featured vote was held regarding Liberty Gardens. Before the board met, I had emailed Councilman Tommy John Schiavoni, reminding him how I strongly supported him in the past, because I felt he would always do the right thing for the people of Southampton and listen to the voters. I encouraged him to vote “no” regarding Liberty Gardens — to be his own person, and not follow the “Jay way.” Guess what? I never received a reply. He totally ignored me — no email, no phone ... by Staff Writer

True Champion

I want to wish Assemblyman Fred Thiele Jr. a happy and healthy upcoming retirement [“State Assemblyman Fred W. Thiele Jr. Will Not Seek Reelection This Fall,” 27east.com, February 12]. Unlike some other local politicians who falsely touted themselves as champions of “clean water,” Fred consistently stood up against big-money interests (especially those behind the disgrace that is The Hills) when it came to the pollution of our fragile local environment. His integrity will be greatly missed. Alex Burton East Quogue by Staff Writer

No Representation

December 16, 2023, marked the 250th anniversary of the Boston Tea Party. This was a protest by colonists against a tax on imported tea being imposed on the colonies by the British Parliament. The colonist argument against the tax was based on, among other factors, their lack of representation in the British Parliament. The chant of “no taxation without representation” was the rallying cry of the protest. Two hundred and fifty years later, residents of the hamlets of Hampton Bays and Flanders are faced with the same lack of representation in their local government. The two hamlets, even with a ... by Staff Writer

Bravo, Cyndi!

Bravo to Cyndi McNamara on her proposed resolution that reforms and streamlines the process by which stop-work orders are administered and issued by the town [“McNamara Proposes Resolution To Extend Stop-Work Order Powers to Code Enforcement and Fire Marshal Offices,” 27east.com, February 20]. It is long overdue and finally empowers the town’s Code Enforcement officers to act quickly and effectively without having to circle back and wait on the Building Department when they see work undertaken without a permit or in contravention of town code. Bravo! Meredith Berkowitz Secretary and Director Bridgehampton Civic Association by Staff Writer

No Credibility

Reader Thomas Jones responded to my letter regarding the scuttling of the bipartisan immigration reform bill by calling it “blatant politics,” adding, “to blame Republicans and Donald Trump for the current border crisis is beyond ridiculous” [“Trojan Horse,” Letters, February 22]. Reading this, I have to wonder if Mr. Jones even read my letter. I did not assign blame for the current border crisis — but I did criticize former President Trump for scuttling a bill that would have improved the border situation immensely. Mr. Jones referred to the bill as a “trojan horse.” But that term implies that the ... by Staff Writer

Fool Me Once

When Tommy John Schiavoni announced that he would be a candidate for the Southampton Town Board in 2017, my wife, Barbara, and I, after researching his background and his stated plans if elected, began an intensive letter writing and online blog campaign for his election. Mea culpa. Instead of being a progressive voice for the environment and the citizens of Southampton Town, Tommy John showed himself to be just another party hack, at the call of the developers. The great American horror story writer Stephen King (i.e. King not Ring) wrote, “Fool me once, shame on you. Fool me twice, ... by Staff Writer

Steinbeck House NY Holds First Student Workshop

Steinbeck House NY held the first High School Students Writers Workshop on February 15. Bret ... by Staff Writer

Water Protection From Indigenous Perspective

The Church in Sag Harbor is hosting a talk with Shinnecock Native Chenae Bullock titled “Idigenous Wisdom: A Connection and Responsibility to Water” on Friday, April 19, at 6 p.m. Tickets are free for members and $10 for nonmembers. Bullock will present a talk about humanity’s needed participation and awareness in the call to action to protect, honor, and cleanse our waterways. A water protector, community leader, cultural preservationist, Indigenous perspective historian, humanitarian, and traditional Shinnecock woman, Bullock will focus her presentation on waterways on the East End. A question and answer session will follow. Go to thechurchsagharbor.org to reserve ... by Staff Writer