Pierson Falls In Suffolk County Class C Championship-Deciding Game - 27 East

Pierson Falls In Suffolk County Class C Championship-Deciding Game

icon 19 Photos
Brendan Burke celebrates stealing third base. DESIRÉE KEEGAN

Brendan Burke celebrates stealing third base. DESIRÉE KEEGAN

Christian Pantina rounds third base and heads home. DESIRÉE KEEGAN

Christian Pantina rounds third base and heads home. DESIRÉE KEEGAN

Gavin Gilbride catches a Reed Kelsey pitch. DESIRÉE KEEGAN

Gavin Gilbride catches a Reed Kelsey pitch. DESIRÉE KEEGAN

Gavin Gilbride passes the ball back to his battery mate. DESIRÉE KEEGAN

Gavin Gilbride passes the ball back to his battery mate. DESIRÉE KEEGAN

Lucas Iulo fires a shot from the mound. DESIRÉE KEEGAN

Lucas Iulo fires a shot from the mound. DESIRÉE KEEGAN

Max Krotman keeps his eye on thee ball. DESIRÉE KEEGAN

Max Krotman keeps his eye on thee ball. DESIRÉE KEEGAN

Max Krotman slides into second base. DESIRÉE KEEGAN

Max Krotman slides into second base. DESIRÉE KEEGAN

Paul Rosel winds up. DESIRÉE KEEGAN

Paul Rosel winds up. DESIRÉE KEEGAN

Paul Rosel sends a pitch to the plate. DESIRÉE KEEGAN

Paul Rosel sends a pitch to the plate. DESIRÉE KEEGAN

Reed Kelsey winds up. DESIRÉE KEEGAN

Reed Kelsey winds up. DESIRÉE KEEGAN

Reed Kelsey hurls a pitch. DESIRÉE KEEGAN

Reed Kelsey hurls a pitch. DESIRÉE KEEGAN

Reed Kelsey connects with the ball. DESIRÉE KEEGAN

Reed Kelsey connects with the ball. DESIRÉE KEEGAN

Reed Kelsey heads to first base. DESIRÉE KEEGAN

Reed Kelsey heads to first base. DESIRÉE KEEGAN

Pierson baseball players celebrate Vinny Cavaniola's go-ahead run. DESIRÉE KEEGAN

Pierson baseball players celebrate Vinny Cavaniola's go-ahead run. DESIRÉE KEEGAN

Pierson baseball players celebrate Vinny Cavaniola's go-ahead run. DESIRÉE KEEGAN

Pierson baseball players celebrate Vinny Cavaniola's go-ahead run. DESIRÉE KEEGAN

Vinny Cavaniola points to his teammates after hitting a game-tying double. DESIRÉE KEEGAN

Vinny Cavaniola points to his teammates after hitting a game-tying double. DESIRÉE KEEGAN

Pierson baseball players celebrate Vinny Cavaniola's go-ahead run. DESIRÉE KEEGAN

Pierson baseball players celebrate Vinny Cavaniola's go-ahead run. DESIRÉE KEEGAN

Pierson baseball players celebrate Vinny Cavaniola's go-ahead run. DESIRÉE KEEGAN

Pierson baseball players celebrate Vinny Cavaniola's go-ahead run. DESIRÉE KEEGAN

Max Krotman follows through with a hit to deep center field. DESIRÉE KEEGAN

Max Krotman follows through with a hit to deep center field. DESIRÉE KEEGAN

Desirée Keegan on Jun 1, 2022

Despite more comebacks after forcing a Suffolk County Class C championship-deciding game three Friday, the Pierson baseball team’s season came to an end with a walkoff loss to Port Jefferson, 7-6.

“We kept fighting until the last pitch — we just came up a little short,” head coach Jonathan Schwartz said. “But this team knows how to win. They fight till the end, and it showed today.”

There was plenty of back-and-forth action to be had in the title-earning contest, and early action came in the third after a long bottom of the first ended with the Royals (20-3) up 1-0. Junior Christian Pantina was brought home on senior shortstop Dan Labrozzi’s hit after the third baseman’s single to right field and steal of second base. Then, Pierson (15-9) took a one-run lead when, after Labrozzi stole third, the ball was thrown over the third baseman’s head and into shallow left field for the senior to score standing up.

Port Jeff responded, though, tying the game on a wild pitch with runners on first and third. Senior starting right hand pitcher Reed Kelsey earned his third strikeout to end the inning and strand runners on first and third.

In the bottom of the fourth, after Kelsey’s next strikeout, he hit a batter, and after an intentional walk, a double over the center fielder cleared the bases for a 4-2 Royals lead. Junior catcher Gavin Gilbride’s sacrifice brought home senior Vinny Cavaniola to make it a one-run game in the top of the next inning, and freshman outfielder Max Krotman’s hit down the first base line that was tipped over the infielder’s glove brought home Pantina to retie things.

“There’s just no quit. No quit in this team. There’s a lot of experience, so it doesn’t faze them,” Schwartz said. “They were obviously upset every time Port Jeff took the lead, but they just battled back every time.”

Port Jeff went up 5-4 at the end of the fifth inning, but Cavaniola’s RBI-double to deep left field with two outs helped senior outfielder Brendan Burke cross home plate, and an overthrow after Cavaniola’s steal of third helped the Whalers retake the lead, 6-5.

“Every team knows we keep on coming,” Schwartz said. “Some of these guys have been with me since middle school, so it’s been fun, interesting, challenging, exciting.”

The Royals tied the game with a no-outs hit to center field after a wild pitch moved the runner to third, but Gilbride slid into the fence to catch a foul tip, and freshman reliever Paul Rosel’s strikeout ended the inning. But it was Rosel’s last pitch in the dirt that skipped past Gilbride, also with no outs, after Port Jeff runner Frank Andriani stole third, that ended the game in walkoff fashion for the Royals.

“It feels like we were supposed to be here, even though, I don’t think anyone thought we would be,” Schwartz said. “So, we kind of defied some expectations.”

You May Also Like:

Another HBCL Season Begins

The Westhampton Aviators and South Shore Clippers got the Hamptons Collegiate Baseball League season started ... 18 Jun 2025 by Drew Budd

Will Tucker Named Manager of Sag Harbor Whalers, Who Eye Playoff Return

The Sag Harbor Whalers were primed to defend their first-ever Hampton Collegiate Baseball League Championship ... 10 Jun 2025 by Drew Budd

Bridgehampton/Ross Baseball Can't Hold On to Early Lead, Falls to Burke Catholic in Regional Semifinal

After two and a half innings of play, the Bridgehampton/Ross baseball team had just put ... 9 Jun 2025 by Drew Budd

Pierson Baseball Falls to Babylon in Class C Championship

The Pierson baseball team lost the second game of the best-of-three Suffolk County Class B ... 2 Jun 2025 by Drew Budd

Pierson Loses 6-0 in First Game of Suffolk 'B' Championship Series

Max Krotman said the series isn’t over for the Pierson baseball team. And while the ... 27 May 2025 by Desirée Keegan

With County Title Officially Wrapped Up, Bees Prepare for June 5 Regional Semifinal

The Bridgehampton/Ross baseball team is officially the Suffolk County Class C Champions after finishing the ... 21 May 2025 by Drew Budd

Weekly Roundup: Westhampton Beach Girls Lacrosse Earns Three Seed; Fromm’s Buzzer-Beater Leads Bonac Girls Lacrosse; Chekijian Walk-Off Helps Baymen Avoid Sweep

Fromm’s Buzzer-Beater
Leads Bonac Girls Lacrosse Carly Fromm scored the winning goal at the buzzer to lead the East Hampton/Pierson girls lacrosse team (5-10) to an 11-10 overtime win at Walt Whitman on May 14. Ava Tintle scored four goals, Cali Wilson scored twice and had two assists, Katie Grande scored two goals, and Lola Eldridge added two goals and three assists. The Bonackers finished their first Division I season with a 4-10 division record, 5-11 overall, with 75.05 power points. Southampton Softball
Wins Finale The Mariners defeated host Pierson/Bridgehampton, 13-8, at Mashashimuet Park in Sag Harbor on Thursday, May 15, to ... 20 May 2025 by Staff Writer

Pierson Baseball Not Worried About Being Swept by Babylon Heading Into Upcoming County Championship Series

The Pierson baseball team may be coming off of being swept by Babylon, its opponent ... 14 May 2025 by Drew Budd

Weekly Roundup: Corwin Scores Game-Winner for South Fork Boys Lacrosse; Meyers Scores 100th Career Goal in Big Nine-Point Performance

Corwin Tallies
Late Game-Winner James Corwin scored the game-winning goal with 20 seconds remaining in regulation to lead the South Fork boys lacrosse team (6-6 in Division I, 7-7 overall, 96.03 power points) to a 9-8 victory at Walt Whitman Thursday, May 8. He finished with a hat trick and an assist. Slate Glick contributed two goals and two assists and Oliver Edson made eight saves in goal. Martin’s Six RBIs
Lead Whalers Softball Fiona Martin went 3 for 3 with a double and a triple, drove in six runs and scored three times to lead the Pierson/Bridgehampton softball team (2-14 in ... by Staff Writer

Weekly Roundup: Meehan Pitches No-Hitter for Bonac Baseball; Bonac Girls Lacrosse Shuts Out North Babylon; McDonnell Records 200th Career Strikeout; Baymen Girls Lacrosse Earns First Win

Meehan No-Hits Hills West,
Leads East Hampton Baseball After losing the series opener, 11-6, on April ... 7 May 2025 by Staff Writer