Proposed $5.8 M Purchase In Water Mill Could Create Scenic Gateway To The Hamlet - 27 East

Proposed $5.8 M Purchase In Water Mill Could Create Scenic Gateway To The Hamlet

icon 3 Photos
Two waterfront parcels could be added to the existing preserved triangle in Water Mill to create a park.

Two waterfront parcels could be added to the existing preserved triangle in Water Mill to create a park.

A concept plan of the park, drawn for the Water Mill Citizens Advisory Committee.

A concept plan of the park, drawn for the Water Mill Citizens Advisory Committee.

An aerial view of the property.

An aerial view of the property.

Kitty Merrill on Dec 21, 2021

Water Mill Citizens Advisory Committee member Steve Abramson’s vision of “a gorgeous gateway” to the eastern end of Southampton Town is moving closer to fruition.

The Southampton Town Board recently held a public hearing on the $5.8 million purchase, through the Community Preservation Fund, of almost 6 acres of land located just west of Water Mill’s main drag. Last year, online real estate sites valued the property, nestled on the north side of Montauk Highway and bordered by Old Country Road, at between $6.5 million and $6.9 million.

At a hearing held during the board’s December 14 meeting, CPF Manager Lisa Kombrink explained that the acquisition would comprise two parcels just east of the Settlers Field triangle at the entrance to Water Mill’s downtown. They’re across Montauk Highway at the curve between Cobb Road and the Little Cobb Road merge.

“These pieces are very familiar to everyone who is headed east on Montauk Highway,” she pointed out. She acknowledged, however, that a dilapidated stockade fence along Montauk Highway, and the vegetation growing along and through it, obscures the view.

The fence, along with all structures on the property, will be demolished. There are three buildings on the two parcels.

Once the acquisition is completed, she said, town officials will begin the process of planning the creation of “a very lovely park.” It will provide access to Mill Creek for kayaks and similar passive activities.

A concept map crafted for the Water Mill Citizens Advisory Committee depicts a canoe/kayak launch, walking trails and a recreation lawn.

During the hearing, Supervisor Jay Schneiderman noted the abundance of vegetation alongside the dilapidated fence, which is a little over a quarter mile long, and asked whether it would be removed. Kombrink noted that some would require regulatory approvals. Her department will work with a landscape architect to see what can be removed to open up the views to passersby.

“It’s going to be a magnificent gateway,” Abramson said, predicting the Southampton Town scene will be just as gorgeous as East Hampton’s Town Pond at the entrance to its village.

The essence of the acquisition goes beyond the CPF imperative to retain open space, the Water Mill Citizens Advisory Committee member reasoned. “The purchase of this 7-acre property adjacent to the 1.5 acres of open space (Settlers Field) will create both … an extraordinary scenic gateway to the east end of the town … and a large recreational park with 944 feet of waterfront on Mill Creek that joins Mill Pond and Mecox Bay,” he said.

Both Abramson and Schneiderman made mention of removing the road that separates the proposed purchase from the Settlers Field triangle. Kombrink affirmed the concept is under consideration. It would make sense to combine the three properties, she reasoned.

In 2006, the 1.5-acre triangular piece on Old Country Road was dedicated and named Settlers Field. Before the Settlers Field partnership, the community purchased and maintained many of its own historic resources such as the Water Mill Community House. The Settlers Field triangle was cleared and landscaped with private funds from local families.

Offering comments on behalf of the CAC, Abramson suggested that, including a reclaimed road, the joined 9 acres could be known as Mill Creek Park and have a one-third-mile walking track and canoe passage into Mecox Bay. Within walking distance of the Parrish Art Museum, Mill Creek Park could provide an additional way for families to spend a full recreational day on the East End, he said.

“It is a rare thing for CPF to be used to create a public park, let alone a unique public waterfront park with over a one-quarter-mile vista along [Route] 27,” he said. “Drivers in both directions through Water Mill will enjoy a panorama of the natural beauty embodied in our bountiful waters and landscapes.”

The purchase would also protect sensitive waters from pollution that would have been unavoidable were the property to have been developed instead, the CAC member reasoned.

“On behalf of Water Mill Citizens Advisory Committee, we would like to commend the CPF and Town Board for their foresight in seizing the opportunity to create Mill Creek Park. We would also like to thank ex-Water Mill resident Tim Maran, now a resident of Southampton Village, for bringing this concept to our attention and for his advocacy in support of the park within the community at large,” Abramson concluded.

As the public hearing drew to a close, Councilman Tommy John Schiavoni noted that the triangular Settlers Field was once a baseball field for the children of Water Mill. He predicted that if the new plan comes to fruition, it will be “one of the nicest parks on the East End of Long Island.”

According to the history detailed on the its website, “The Water Mill Community Club first began in 1952, when Little League baseball came to Water Mill. Volunteers sponsored a team and built a baseball field on Foster land adjacent to Old County Road. Sons of the community started with hats as uniforms and, eventually, with the help of the community, upgraded to real uniforms. Mothers baked cakes and cookies for bake sales to raise money for the Little League.”

At the hearing, the supervisor speculated that baseball Hall of Famer and local son Carl Yastrzemski likely played on that field.

You May Also Like:

Elizabeth Spitz, Formerly of East Hampton, Dies October 15

Elizabeth Spitz, affectionately known to her close friends and family as “Betty,” peacefully passed away ... 29 Oct 2025 by Staff Writer

Southampton Police Reports for the Week of October 30

HAMPTON BAYS — A local resident told Southampton Town Police on October 20 that she had been the target of an attempted fraud scheme. She said she had received a call informing her that she was among nine winners of a multimillion-dollar lottery pool, but that she needed to send in a check for $3,400 to earn her portion of the much greater winnings. She mailed the check and was then told by the fraudsters that it had not arrived and that she should send another, which she did. But after discussing the matter with a family member, she realized ... by Staff Writer

A Sneak Peek at the Election Day Ballot in Southampton Town

The Election Day ballot for Southampton Town voters contains the races for Suffolk County legislator, Southampton Town supervisor and two council seats, the Southampton Town clerk, all five members of the Southampton Town Trustees, the highway superintendent and one of the four town justice seats, as well as uncontested elections for Suffolk County district attorney and Suffolk County sheriff, and two ballot propositions. Early voting polls remain open daily at Windmill Village in East Hampton, Stony Brook Southampton campus in Southampton and at St. Mark’s Episcopal Church in Westhampton Beach until this Sunday, November 2. On Election Day, polls will ... by Michael Wright

We Mark Our Ballots: The Propositions

There are two propositions on the ballot — as always, don’t forget to flip your ballot over! — that deserve attention. The first is a state measure that would clear the way for an Olympic skiing and trail facility on preserved land upstate. We recommend a yes vote, simply because it seems like a sensible use of valuable real estate for the benefit of that region and the entire state. However, the Suffolk County proposition, the second on the ballot, is a clear no. The measure would extend county legislators’ terms from two to four years, something voters have overwhelmingly ... by Editorial Board

We Mark Our Ballot: County Legislature

In an age punctuated by extreme political party divisions and acrimony, it was refreshing to hear from two Suffolk County legislators representing the East End — one a Democrat and one a Republican — about how well they worked together to represent the interests of their varied constituents and pass legislation to benefit all residents, regardless of political affiliation. It was downright astonishing to hear them heap praise upon each other, both personally and politically, during separate interviews with The Express News Group Editorial Board. This at a time when each is facing an active challenger. It became crystal clear ... by Editorial Board

Southampton School Board Approves Second $5 Million Loan To Cover Cash Flow Gap

Projecting a shortfall in critical funding, the Southampton Board of Education approved a second tax ... by Michelle Trauring

We Mark Our Ballot: Southampton Town

There are precious few choices for Southampton Town voters to make between now and November 4, a sad state of affairs based on well-documented horse trading that took place behind the scenes. The key swap made sure Maria Moore did not face a challenger for a second term as supervisor; in exchange, Charles McArdle, likewise, will cruise to a second term as highway superintendent. That both are doing a terrific job and deserve reelection is some consolation, but local government is always better when voters have choices. That was taken away from them, largely, this year by party leaders — ... by Editorial Board

Southampton's DeLalio Sinks Hole-in-One in Playoff Victory Over Kings Park

Colin DeLalio shined in the Southampton boys golf opener of the Section XI Team Tournament ... by Drew Budd

Flanders Road Affordable Housing Proposal Earns $2.4 Million Grant From Southampton Town; Residents Plead for Town To Derail 7-Eleven Plans

A proposal for a 40-unit affordable housing development that would be one of the first ... by Michael Wright

Southampton Town Directs $5 Million To Preserving Marshlands in Western Shinnecock Bay

The Town of Southampton will dedicate nearly $5 million from the Community Preservation Fund to ... by Michael Wright