Provisional Chief Steven McManus Appointed Westhampton Beach’s Next Top Cop

icon 2 Photos
Steven J. McManus, pictured here with his father, was appointed as Westhampton Beach's chief of police on Oct. 7. COURTESY MARIA MOORE

Steven J. McManus, pictured here with his father, was appointed as Westhampton Beach's chief of police on Oct. 7. COURTESY MARIA MOORE

Steven J. McManus was appointed chief of police on Oct. 7 COURTESY MARIA MOORE

Steven J. McManus was appointed chief of police on Oct. 7 COURTESY MARIA MOORE

authorAlec Giufurta on Oct 13, 2021

Steven McManus was formally tapped to lead the Westhampton Beach Police Department by the Village Board at an October 7 meeting. He joined the department in 2003, and served as interim chief for nearly a year.

At the meeting, McManus recounted a trip he took with his grandparents out east to Westhampton Beach when he was young. His grandfather, a retired New York City Police Department officer, told him that the area was one he would want to work in as an officer.

“I guess grandpa knew what he was talking about, especially as I stand here today,” McManus said after being sworn in.

Now, McManus will have the opportunity to shape the department after working in it for 18 years — and after a year filled with historic and sweeping calls for police reform and racial justice.

“Being provisional, I didn’t want to institute any changes that would have had a major effect upon the department until it became a permanent position,” McManus said October 12 during a phone interview. “Now I’ll be able to start to implement some of those changes.”

McManus said he was looking to make “major” changes to the department’s leadership by adding positions to increase supervision.

“I currently have only one sergeant, I don’t have an executive officer, and I need more supervision,” he said. “You need to have a strong command structure in the department just to have the place run smoothly.”

In response to a question on policing in the aftermath of both local and national movements for racial justice and police reform in 2020, McManus said he worked with Mayor Maria Moore on the state-mandated reforms, and that “one of the major things there was having our department involved more with the public at special events.”

Moore said she was not available to be interviewed for this story. In an emailed statement, she said McManus’s tenure as acting chief was “excellent.”

“McManus has evaluated the needs of the Village in terms of police staffing and training, effectively communicated with the village’s Law Enforcement Review Committee in the creation of their recommendations, and is in the process of upgrading the department’s policies and procedures,” Moore said in the statement.

As previously reported by The Press, the village’s Law Enforcement Review Committee’s plan called for upgraded body cameras, community outreach and the replacement of the department’s records management system with one that is more easily searchable.

McManus said he upgraded the body cameras worn by the department’s officers.

“It’s better for the officers, it’s better for the public, it’s better for us when we try to release videos over to the [District Attorney’s] office,” he said.

When he was slated as interim chief, Mcmanus was a sergeant in the department. Before that, he served as both a patrol officer and a detective.

“This is a great community to work in,” McManus said. “We have a great relationship with our residents.”

McManus succeeded Trevor Gonce, who retired suddenly in November 2020. At the time, McManus remarked how his ascension to the top of the department occurred unexpectedly and quickly.

“I thought [Gonce] was going to be here a long time,” McManus told The Press in December 2020. “This is a jump.”

According to the village’s website, the department has nine officers, one detective, one sergeant, one public safety dispatcher and one police operations aide.

After his swearing in on October 7, McManus thanked the board members for their “unwavering support” throughout his 11 months as interim chief.

Before joining the Westhampton Village Police Department in 2003, McManus served as a campus police officer at the State University of New York College at Old Westbury. He was raised in Suffolk County.

You May Also Like:

Benjamin ‘Shonowe’ Kellis Haile of the Shinnecock Nation Dies November 12

Benjamin “Shonowe” Kellis Haile of the Shinnecock Nation died on November 12 in Southampton. He was 60. A complete obituary will appear in a future edition of The Press. 14 Nov 2025 by Staff Writer

Westhampton Beach Fire Department Extinguishes Car Fire

The Westhampton Beach Fire Department was paged out for a car fire just north of ... by Staff Writer

Growing Wellness: New Community Garden at Stony Brook Southampton To Offer 'Produce Prescriptions'

Since its creation, the Food Lab at Stony Brook Southampton has been committed to studying ... by Cailin Riley

In Wake of Immigration Detentions, Advocacy Group Is Left With Many Holes To Plug

While the ICE sweep last week that ensnared a dozen immigrants has sparked outrage and ... 13 Nov 2025 by Michael Wright

Bars Over Southampton Village Hall Windows, Former Jail Cells, Will Be Removed

For some unlucky people, the workplace can feel like a prison. There’s no reason to ... by Cailin Riley

Cleaning Out

There is no setting on binoculars that works in the fog — everything in the distance remains indistinct, and that is fine. Here, the low place, called Sagg Swamp, begins a nearly uninterrupted corridor of unbuilt-upon land: wetlands, ponds and kettleholes; the Long Pond Greenbelt runs for miles to the old harbor. Today, contained, the only fog is there. It rises up from the dark muck to smudge the damp foliage with its dreamy, silver light. So, above, as the crow flies, the air is tinted between gold and pink. Fog is a reoccurring theme, because it reveals a sense ... by Marilee Foster

'Novembrance'

Gaudy October is gone. The November landscape is muted colors, falling leaves and skeletal branches. The month opens with reminders of death. In the Catholic Church, November first is All Saints’ Day. On November 2, All Souls Day is dedicated to praying for the souls of the departed. The Mexican tradition of the Day of the Dead is celebrated on the same days but has a more festive air. It’s also observed across the United States. The All-Souls Procession has been an annual event since 1990 in Tucson, Arizona. San Antonio, Texas, is known for its Muertos Fest and river ... by Denise Gray Meehan

A Bright Spot

There were strong Democratic victories nationally in last week’s election, led by Mikie Sherrill winning the governorship of New Jersey, and Abigail Spanberger winning the governorship of Virginia, and other Democratic wins seen as involving clear anti-President Donald Trump viewpoints. In Suffolk County, we were in the viewing area in which a torrent of TV commercials were broadcast in the race between Sherrill and Republican Jack Ciattarelli, who in most of them stressed his staunch support for Trump. Although the race was predicted to be tight, Sherrill won by a large margin. This and other successful Democratic contests are being ... by Karl Grossman

Southampton Police Reports for the Week of November 13

QUOGUE — Mark Magness, 55, of Rockville Center was arrested by Quogue Police on November 6 and charged with aggravated DWI, a misdemeanor. Police pulled Magness over at 7:51 p.m. after receiving a report of a reckless and erratic driver traveling east on Montauk Highway. They located the vehicle in question, and observed the vehicle failing to maintain the lane of travel, as well as no rear marker lights on. A traffic stop was conducted; the operator was found to be intoxicated. He was arrested for DWI, with a blood alcohol level over .18, police said. He was arraigned the ... 12 Nov 2025 by Staff Writer

Assemblyman Shiavoni To Talk About Critical Issues on 'East End Live'

New York State Assemblyman Tommy John Schiavoni will engage in a conversation about critical issues ... by Staff Writer