Reimagined Old Stove Pub Celebrates Its Past While Modernizing for the Future - 27 East
logo logo logo logo

Sag Harbor Express

East Hampton Press / News / Business / Business / News / Southampton Press / News / Sag Harbor Express / 2287543

Reimagined Old Stove Pub Celebrates Its Past While Modernizing for the Future

icon 14 Photos
Old Stove Pub owner Joe DeCristofaro in the dining room. DANA SHAW

Old Stove Pub owner Joe DeCristofaro in the dining room. DANA SHAW

The wedge salad at the Old Stove Pub. DANA SHAW

The wedge salad at the Old Stove Pub. DANA SHAW

The burger at the Old Stove Pub. DANA SHAW

The burger at the Old Stove Pub. DANA SHAW

The dining room at the Old Stove Pub. DANA SHAW

The dining room at the Old Stove Pub. DANA SHAW

The Old Stove Pub in Sagaponack. DANA SHAW

The Old Stove Pub in Sagaponack. DANA SHAW

The white tuna tataki. DANA SHAW

The white tuna tataki. DANA SHAW

The firecracker special roll. DANA SHAW

The firecracker special roll. DANA SHAW

The white tuna tataki. DANA SHAW

The white tuna tataki. DANA SHAW

The porterhouse steak at the Old Stove Pub. DANA SHAW

The porterhouse steak at the Old Stove Pub. DANA SHAW

The Old Stove Pub in Sagaponack. DANA SHAW

The Old Stove Pub in Sagaponack. DANA SHAW

The iconic Old Stove Pub sign in Sagaponack. DANA SHAW

The iconic Old Stove Pub sign in Sagaponack. DANA SHAW

The porterhouse steak at the Old Stove Pub. DANA SHAW

The porterhouse steak at the Old Stove Pub. DANA SHAW

A framed photo of long-time owners the Johnides family at the pub's first menu. DANA SHAW

A framed photo of long-time owners the Johnides family at the pub's first menu. DANA SHAW

A porterhouse on the grill at the Old Stove Pub. DANA SHAW

A porterhouse on the grill at the Old Stove Pub. DANA SHAW

Georgia Kenny on Sep 10, 2024
Old Stove Pub, a historic dining staple in Sagaponack since 1969, nestled comfortably between East Hampton and Southampton, has undergone a major glow up as of 2020. The establishment, which... more

You May Also Like:

Food Pantry Launches New Website

The Sag Harbor Community Food Pantry has launched a new website at sagharborfoodpantry.org. The site is designed to improve communication with Sag Harbor families seeking food assistance, as well as with donors wishing to contribute financially or through food donations.
The pantry currently serves approximately 100 families — more than 400 individuals — each week, year-round. It operates on Tuesdays from 10 a.m. to noon at the Old Whalers’ Church.
As the fall and winter months approach, the pantry anticipates increased demand for assistance, particularly in light of the federal government shutdown and the upcoming cessation of SNAP benefits. According to a ... 3 Nov 2025 by Staff Writer

Community News, November 6

YOUTH CORNER Toddler & Teeny Tumbling Project Most at the Community Learning Center, 44 Meadow ... by Staff Writer

CMEE To Host Art Opening

The Children’s Museum of the East End (CMEE) will host an art opening reception with CITYarts on Saturday, November 15, from 10 a.m. to noon. The event celebrates CITYarts’ Pieces for Peace project, which invites young people from around the world to create art reflecting their vision of peace.
To date, more than 12,000 artworks have been collected from 126 countries across six continents, and a selection will be on display at CMEE during the opening and throughout the fall exhibition.
Children ages 4 to 12 are also invited to create their own “Piece for Peace” during the event and contribute to ... by Staff Writer

Passing Through Town in a Rare Rolls-Royce

When Mary Narvell stepped out of the pale yellow and black Rolls-Royce Wraith that her ... by Stephen J. Kotz

School News, November 6, Sag Harbor & East Hampton Town

by Staff Writer

A Collaborative Effort To Retrace the Steps of the Amistad Story Involves Local Women

The story of the Amistad entered broad public consciousness in the late 1990s, thanks in ... 2 Nov 2025 by Cailin Riley

All Went Right on a Dark’n Stormy Night

It was a dark and stormy night, but, undaunted, the East Hampton/Pierson/Bridgehampton football team blew away its host, Rocky Point, 35-0 on Thursday, October 30, an impressive shutout that assured the 5-3 Bonackers of a berth in the Suffolk County Division III playoffs. Directly following a pivotal Islip/Westhampton Beach matchup on Saturday afternoon, which Islip won, 21-7, the playoff brackets were quickly set. East Hampton was seeded sixth and will play at No. 3 Islip this Friday, November 7, at 6 p.m. Chris Carney, who was at the game, and whose son, Jackson, plays for East Hampton, said this past ... 1 Nov 2025 by Jack Graves

Beyond the Jack-o'-Lantern: Sen Chef Showcases Culinary Mastery With Fruit and Vegetable Carvings

When Fidel Sanchez was a child, sitting by his father’s side in his native Ecuador ... by Cailin Riley

UPDATED: Lane Restrictions on Sunrise Highway Will Last At Least Through Next Week

UPDATE: Friday 5 p.m. The New York State Department of Transportation says that the westbound ... 31 Oct 2025 by Michael Wright

Shinnecock Hills Man Celebrates 81st Birthday, Thanks Officers Who Saved Him From Roof of Burning House

Harry Fullum said that spending his 81st birthday at the Southampton Center for Rehabilitation would ... by Michael Wright