logo logo logo logo

Sag Harbor Express

East Hampton Press / News / Business / Business / News / Southampton Press / News / Sag Harbor Express / 2287543

Reimagined Old Stove Pub Celebrates Its Past While Modernizing for the Future

icon 14 Photos
Old Stove Pub owner Joe DeCristofaro in the dining room. DANA SHAW

Old Stove Pub owner Joe DeCristofaro in the dining room. DANA SHAW

The wedge salad at the Old Stove Pub. DANA SHAW

The wedge salad at the Old Stove Pub. DANA SHAW

The burger at the Old Stove Pub. DANA SHAW

The burger at the Old Stove Pub. DANA SHAW

The dining room at the Old Stove Pub. DANA SHAW

The dining room at the Old Stove Pub. DANA SHAW

The Old Stove Pub in Sagaponack. DANA SHAW

The Old Stove Pub in Sagaponack. DANA SHAW

The white tuna tataki. DANA SHAW

The white tuna tataki. DANA SHAW

The firecracker special roll. DANA SHAW

The firecracker special roll. DANA SHAW

The white tuna tataki. DANA SHAW

The white tuna tataki. DANA SHAW

The porterhouse steak at the Old Stove Pub. DANA SHAW

The porterhouse steak at the Old Stove Pub. DANA SHAW

The Old Stove Pub in Sagaponack. DANA SHAW

The Old Stove Pub in Sagaponack. DANA SHAW

The iconic Old Stove Pub sign in Sagaponack. DANA SHAW

The iconic Old Stove Pub sign in Sagaponack. DANA SHAW

The porterhouse steak at the Old Stove Pub. DANA SHAW

The porterhouse steak at the Old Stove Pub. DANA SHAW

A framed photo of long-time owners the Johnides family at the pub's first menu. DANA SHAW

A framed photo of long-time owners the Johnides family at the pub's first menu. DANA SHAW

A porterhouse on the grill at the Old Stove Pub. DANA SHAW

A porterhouse on the grill at the Old Stove Pub. DANA SHAW

Georgia Kenny on Sep 10, 2024
Old Stove Pub, a historic dining staple in Sagaponack since 1969, nestled comfortably between East Hampton and Southampton, has undergone a major glow up as of 2020. The establishment, which... more

You May Also Like:

Infernal Gadgets

I am writing this letter to ask all of you to agree with me that the gasoline-powered leaf blower is, perhaps, one of the worst inventions of the past 75 years. It would be fitting if it was invented in Japan in 1947 as retribution for the U.S. atomic bombing of the Japanese cities of Hiroshima and Nagasaki. I don’t want to diminish those horrific acts, but it was invented in Japan around 1977. I do think the time has come to do something about the noise, pollution, and to free the poor operators from the health risks imposed by ... 10 Nov 2025 by Staff Writer

Time To Lead

According to The Southampton Press, more than a dozen federal officers arrived in a caravan of what appeared to be their personal cars and mustered at the Hampton Bays Fire Department on Montauk Highway, before setting out in a fleet of unmarked minivans [“Dozens of ICE Agents Sweep Through Hampton Bays and Westhampton Beach Wednesday,” 27east.com, November 5]. Putting aside the cruelty of it all, the elephant in the room is this: Did Southampton Town Supervisor Maria Moore and the police department she oversees know about this ICE raid in advance and, if so, to what extent? The fact that ... by Staff Writer

Big Parade Coming

The Fourth of July Parade Committee extends heartfelt thanks to all of our participants, underwriters, sponsors, Elks Lodge 1574, Kathleen Miller, and the Fundraising Committee for their hard work and dedication. Over 150 guests attended our fundraiser to support one of the largest parades on Long Island. Next year marks the 250th birthday of our grateful nation, and on Saturday, July 4, 2026, we will celebrate this historic milestone together. We are deeply appreciative of our donors and volunteers. As many know, the parade is funded solely by community donations, and every contribution truly makes a difference. Our parade began ... by Staff Writer

Baffling Decision

Southampton Town Democratic Chairman Gordon Herr picked the wrong election cycle to sit out. His baffling decision to not run a second Democrat Town Council candidate came amid a blue wave that swept across eastern Long Island, New Jersey and Virginia — a wave that carried all five Democratic Town Trustees candidates in Southampton Town and even ousted experienced and well-liked Trustee President Scott Horowitz. Town Democrats should have been prepared for a pendulum swing like this, yet they weren’t. Against that backdrop, Herr’s refusal — which he denies was part of any backroom deal — to field a second ... by Staff Writer

Scholarships Available for Young Equestrians

The Stony Hill Stables Foundation in Amagansett has opened its fall-winter scholarship program, offering young ... by Staff Writer

USGA Announces Daily Ticket Presale and Public Launch Date for 2026 U.S. Open at Shinnecock Hills Golf Club

The United States Golf Association (USGA) unveiled the daily ticket release schedule for the highly ... by Staff Writer

Sag Harbor Village Police Reports for the Week of November 6

SAG HARBOR VILLAGE — Two Sag Harbor men were arrested this past weekend on misdemeanor criminal contempt charges for, Village Police said, violating court orders of protection in two unrelated incidents. Quinn S. Mignott, 39, was arrested on the charge early Saturday morning after a dispute that apparently started in a Main Street bar before Mignott and the person he was with exited the bar, continuing their dispute on Main Street. Witnesses were concerned for the other party’s well-being and called police. Mignott and the other individual then got into a car, witnesses said, with Mignott sitting in the front ... by Staff Writer

Bonackers Run Through Islip To Set Up Playoff Showdown With Sayville

It’s been called the black-and-blue division of Suffolk County high school football, and the Bonackers ... 8 Nov 2025 by Gavin Menu

USA Warrior Stories, Created by Longtime Friends, Gives Veterans a Platform To Connect and Share

In 2017, Matt Hindra and Nick Kraus paid a visit to Martin Sylvester at his ... 7 Nov 2025 by Cailin Riley

East End Students Bring 'Alice by Heart' to Life at LTV Studios

South Fork Performing Arts, a local nonprofit with a mission to bring quality arts education ... by Cailin Riley