Sag Harbor Architectural Review Board Balks At Plans For 6,500-Square-Foot Houses - 27 East

Sag Harbor Architectural Review Board Balks At Plans For 6,500-Square-Foot Houses

icon 3 Photos
A rendering of a house proposed on Marsden Street in Sag Harbor.
Images Courtesy of NoTriangle Studio

A rendering of a house proposed on Marsden Street in Sag Harbor. Images Courtesy of NoTriangle Studio

A rendering of a house proposed on Marsden Street in Sag Harbor.
Images Courtesy of NoTriangle Studio

A rendering of a house proposed on Marsden Street in Sag Harbor. Images Courtesy of NoTriangle Studio

A rendering of a house proposed on Marsden Street in Sag Harbor.
Images Courtesy of NoTriangle Studio

A rendering of a house proposed on Marsden Street in Sag Harbor. Images Courtesy of NoTriangle Studio

Brendan J. OReilly on Jan 20, 2021

Members of the Sag Harbor Village Historic Preservation & Architectural Review Board are unified in their opposition to approving a plan for three new houses in excess of 6,500 square feet each on Marsden Street.

The scale of the houses was the sticking point during the board’s Thursday, January 14, virtual meeting, and the builder pushed back on the idea that they would be overly large.

The application put forth by Pat Trunzo of Trunzo Building Contractors in Wainscott concerns a five-lot subdivision. The board first heard the plan in November 2019, and much has changed since then. Originally, the houses were designed to replicate historic Sag Harbor homes. The revised plan calls for contemporary houses that could not be mistaken for historic.

The largest of the three proposed houses is 6,611 square feet where zoning would permit up to 7,000 square feet, and that square footage does not include any finished space on the lower level. The smallest is 6,525 square feet, where up to 6,621 is allowed.

Mr. Trunzo reminded the board that four possible designs pitched in 2019 were not well received. He said the new designs take into account the board’s comments that new houses in the historic district should not mimic the old, should face the street, and should look different from each other.

Mr. Trunzo’s architect, Namita Modi, said each house will have a detached garage linked by a breezeway. Evergreens will screen the homes from neighboring Pierson High School, and street trees will be planted as well. New sidewalks with granite curbing will be installed on the north side of Marsden Street and will wrap around to Division Street.

Board Chairman Dean Gomolka polled the board members for their thoughts on the plan, and each made the same remark: The houses are too large.

Board member Steven Williams also said that while he appreciates that Mr. Trunzo looked upon the board’s previous comments favorably, he wants to know why the plan is to build homes on spec rather than designing homes to meet the needs of the purchasers. Mr. Trunzo did not offer an explanation of why he chose to go the spec building route.

“I find the number, 6,000 square feet, overwhelming — just the thought of something that large in Sag Harbor,” board member Judith Long said. “I don’t think there are any houses in Sag Harbor that are 6,000 square feet, and in that neighborhood particularly.”

Ms. Long said that while 6,000 square feet may be allowed, a way to reduce the scale or make the houses seem less overwhelming should be found.

Mr. Gomolka said the project has moved in the right direction — he called the old design “contrived” — but the massing is huge and not contextual.

Mr. Trunzo made the case that the houses are appropriate considering the size of the lots. “They range from three-quarters of an acre up to almost nine-tenths of an acre,” he noted. “So they are relatively large lots for Sag Harbor. Earlier in the meeting tonight, the board was fine with 3,000-square-foot houses on a third of an acre. Well, the ratio of these houses to their lot area is better than two-to-one.”

He added that the proposed houses will be away from others, without any neighbors, and argued that the size of other houses on other streets is not pertinent.

“In my world, if you will, as a builder in the Hamptons, the size of these houses is not large,” Mr. Trunzo said. “Most of the houses I’ve built are larger than these, some of them extremely much larger than these. And I don’t think size alone is the criteria. I agree these houses need to fit into the properties that they sit on, and I think they need to integrate into the neighborhood that they are a part of, but that can be done without having to reduce their sizes.”

Mr. Gomolka requested Mr. Trunzo come back with more information on the size of houses nearby. “You don’t really see developments like this in Sag Harbor, so I think it’s thrown us a little bit of a curveball,” he said, “and volume — I think you’ve heard it five or six times here tonight from the members — this is sort of a bit of an issue.”

Mr. Trunzo said he will endeavor to find out that information but does not see how the size of those houses is relevant to his proposed houses. “These houses are by themselves, pretty much, on Marsden Street,” he said. “So the context is going to be each other rather than houses on Madison or other houses on Division.”

He pointed out that last summer the board approved a house on Madison Street very close to the size of these houses and on a similar size lot. “The board has seen fit to approve relatively larger homes on an appropriately sized lot not too distant from this location,” he said.

Mr. Gomolka agreed that information will be pertinent to this application.

“Maybe it’s not a large house for south of the highway, but this is in a historic village where I think the median home size is averaging closer to 3,000 square feet,” board member Val Florio said. “It might be allowed by code, but I think the New York State guidelines for this are such that we look at things in terms of if it’s harmonious.”

Gas Lantern Nixed
 

A majority of the Historic Preservation & Architectural Review Board gave a final thumbs down to a plan to install a gas lantern beside an entry to 47 Howard Street, finding that gas lanterns are inappropriate additions to homes listed as contributing to the historic district.

“Whether the board feels that this is a major issue or not, it’s up to you,” said the board’s historic preservation consultant, Zachary Studenroth. “It’s just not appropriate to the house, any more than introducing any other architectural detail that wouldn’t be authentic. I know it’s charming. It doesn’t seem like it’s such a big deal, but when you begin to add these sort of pseudo-historic elements to a listed building in the village, to me, it’s just not appropriate.”

Ms. Long said she agrees: “Since there would not have been a gas lamp on this house when it was built, why are we putting a gas lamp on now that it’s 2021? To me, it sets a bad precedent for people running around putting little, quote, historic touches on their houses that are not historic. … It’s a little bit of the Disney-fication of Sag Harbor.”

The only board member who did not oppose gas was Vice Chairperson Bethany Deyermond.

Architect Anthony Vermandois said his client, the homeowner, would be willing to install an electric lamp instead so the project could proceed and the entry could be lighted. That board was amenable.

50 Harrison Street
 

The board unanimously approved the demolition of a 2,000-square-foot cape at 50 Harrison Street and the construction of a 3,000-square-foot-plus, four-bedroom residence with a standing seam metal roof to replace it.

The former house was not a contributing structure to the historic district. Still, board member Robert Adams said he is sad to see the old house demolished.

Ms. Long agreed, saying, “It’s too bad to destroy a perfectly good house.” However, she added: “Harrison Street is changing and there are many large houses. There used to be lots of little houses, and now it’s going to have lots of big houses.”

 

Images Courtesy of NoTriangle Studio

You May Also Like:

Southampton Animal Shelter Working To Make Life Better for Bunnies

Over the years, common knowledge and accepted ideas about the best ways to care for ... 12 Jul 2025 by Cailin Riley

Scuttlehole Road Closed After Crash Friday

Scuttlehole Road in Bridgehampton has been closed following a car accident. Southampton Town Police and emergency responders are on the scene. The road is expected to be closed for a significant period of time Friday afternoon. 11 Jul 2025 by Staff Writer

A Trailblazer: Professor Karl Grossman Retires, but the Work Continues

Inside The Cleveland Press newsroom of the 1960s, one word sent Karl Grossman running: “Copy!” ... by Michelle Trauring

Federal Funding for Public Media Is Close to Becoming a Thing of the Past | 27Speaks Podcast

President Donald Trump issued an executive order on May 1 instructing the Corporation for Public ... 10 Jul 2025 by 27Speaks

Developer Proposes 40 Affordable Apartments, Retail Stores in Riverside, Seeks $2.4M Grant From Southampton

An affordable housing developer who has worked with Southampton and East Hampton towns on several ... by Michael Wright

Korey Williams, Longtime Teacher and Lifetime Westhampton Beach Hurricane, Retires After 32 Years

Some teachers spend their entire career at one school. For a select few, they spend ... 9 Jul 2025 by Dan Stark

Let's Make a Deal

Since his swearing-in in January 2023, U.S. Representative Nick LaLota hasn’t faced a series of votes that rivaled the recent domestic spending package, which he played a significant role in pushing through Congress and onto President Donald Trump’s desk. It gave him a notable win: He proudly says he delivered on his promise to 1st District voters that he would get a reprieve on the federal government’s cap on the state and local tax deduction, or SALT. Ultimately, that’s true, with an asterisk. But it’s fair for voters to ask: At what price? Did a single-minded focus on this goal ... by Editorial Board

Stony Brook Medicine, UnitedHealthcare Reach New 3-Year Deal To Maintain Coverage

Stony Brook Medicine and UnitedHealthcare have inked a new three-year contract that will maintain coverage of visits to Stony Brook Southampton Hospital and Meetinghouse Lane Medical physicians for those with UnitedHealthcare or Oxford insurance plans. The agreement was announced just a day before the expiration of a temporary extension of the previous agreements announced in June, when the state’s largest insurer began notifying its customers that Stony Brook’s hospitals and doctors would be out of network coverage soon. “There will be no interruption in coverage for any of our United/Oxford patients,” Stony Brook announced in a statement this week. “We ... by Michael Wright

GOP-Backed Candidates Knock Democrats Off Working Families Party Line in Primary Shake-Up

Absentee ballots that came in after last month’s primary voting bumped Democratic Party candidate Tom Neely from the Working Families Party line for the November ballot. Even though Neely had a one-vote lead after ballots from early voting and the June 17 primary day were tallied, 11 additional absentee ballots, which all went to challengers Ieshia Galicia and Andrew Smith, put the two first-time political candidates over the top for the tiny party’s line with 23 and 21 votes, respectively. A Working Families Party challenger to the Working Families Party’s official endorsement for town clerk, Mark Bernardo, had trailed his ... by Michael Wright

PSEG 'Storm Hardening' Power Lines in East Quogue This Summer

Crews from PSEG-Long Island will be conducting “storm-hardening” work on electrical transmission lines and circuits in East Quogue throughout the remainder of the summer as part of the company’s Power On initiative to improve reliability and resiliency in the face of severe storms. Crews will be replacing and upgrading mainline circuits along Spinney Road between Lewis Road and Serenity Place, along Lewis Road between Old Country Road and Quogue-Riverhead Road and on Damascus Road. The work is expected to take about two months to complete, PSEG said. “PSEG Long Island is committed to strengthening the electric infrastructure and improving reliability ... by Staff Writer