Southampton Village Board Changes Code To Allow For Food Pantries - 27 East

Southampton Village Board Changes Code To Allow For Food Pantries

icon 1 Photo
The former Southampton Village Ambulance barn.  DANA SHAW

The former Southampton Village Ambulance barn. DANA SHAW

authorCailin Riley on Feb 9, 2022

The Southampton Village Board unanimously approved a resolution on Tuesday night that will ultimately allow a special exception use giving Heart of the Hamptons permission to operate a stand-alone food pantry within the village.

It was a victory for the longtime organization. Heart of the Hamptons was officially established as a nonprofit organization in 2003, but has been providing assistance to families in need in Southampton for more than 40 years, offering food and other support.

For the past two years, the organization has had its eye on the former village ambulance barn at 44 Meetinghouse Lane. The board has been supportive of the organization’s desire to move into that space and also has a long-term lease with the organization to operate out of the barn, an arrangement that Mayor Jesse Warren pointed out was made by the prior administration but which he supports.

After discovering that the village code did not contain a designation for a stand-alone food pantry in residential zones, the board drafted a local law that would allow for it.

But several neighbors have opposed the plan, saying they don’t object to a food pantry in the village, but do not want it operating in that neighborhood, a residential area.

After the board adopted the local law for the first time, back in September 2021, neighbors filed a lawsuit claiming that the board members had not done their due diligence in commissioning an environmental impact study and planning analysis prior to adopting the law, as required under the State Environmental Quality Review Act.

Rather than get tied up in a court battle that could have dragged on for a long period of time over what members saw as a technicality, the board was advised to rescind the law, conduct the study, and try again — which they did.

John Ellsworth of Nelson, Pope and Voorhis, the consultants that conducted the study, was at the meeting Tuesday night to present the findings. He said amending the code to allow the pantry to operate in the village “would not entail significant environmental impacts,” and went so far as to suggest that a negative declaration be adopted, meaning a more comprehensive environmental study would not be required.

Southampton Village Attorney Ken Gray also pointed out that the board had sent the local law to the Suffolk County Planning Commission, and that it sent a letter back saying it was “not interested” in taking up the issue, leaving it up to the local determination.

The study did list several other locations within the village that would be suitable for use as a center of operations for the food pantry, including the organization’s desired location of the ambulance barn, as well as the Southampton Elementary School, the First Presbyterian Church, Southampton Town Hall, the parking lot at the Southampton train station, and an open space parcel at the northeast corner of Wickapogue and Old Town roads.

There was, as expected, robust participation during the public comment portion of the hearing, with several people coming out to express either opposition or support of the law and the organization’s plan to operate in the village, specifically at the old ambulance barn.

Toward the end of the meeting, Village Board member Joe McLoughlin made a point of asking Gray to clarify that, while much of the commentary was focused on the relative merits or drawbacks of the old ambulance barn as the location, the passage of the law did not necessarily pertain to that exact issue.

“This public discussion has more to do with the code than the location,” he said. “I do believe this board should encourage and expand the scope to allow these venues in addition to the current location to make sure we’re not singling out any one location.”

Board member Roy Stevenson weighed in on that issue as well, pointing out that the law does not require Heart of the Hamptons to occupy that space. “We’re not approving the application for Meetinghouse Lane,” he said. “We’re just setting up the mechanism that will allow an application to be brought.”

Despite that explanation, several members of the public accused the board of favoring the ambulance barn location.

Former Village Board Kimberly Allen accused the board of being “choppy and sketchy” in terms of doing its due diligence in amending the code, and described the process as a “charade.” She added that she submitted Freedom of Information Law requests to analyze all the documentation related to the process, but because she was initially denied and then had to submit an appeal, she did not have those documents in her hands until 5:30 p.m. on Monday night, just 24 hours before the meeting.

Jim McFarlane, a former Village Board member who has been one of the most vocal opponents, said the site was “not even minimally acceptable” for a food pantry, and said the update to the code was a “sham law.” He also derided Nelson, Pope and Voorhis during his impassioned diatribe.

“If I was looking for a planning company to obfuscate the real elements with verbiage, Nelson, Pope and Voorhis comes at the top of the ladder,” he said. “Thanks, you bleep artists.”

While there was plenty of opposition expressed, there was also an outpouring of support at the hearing.

Mike Lieberman is the co-chair of the Village Planning Commission but specified that he was commenting at the meeting not in that capacity but as someone who lives close to the former ambulance barn. He also is the chief of the village’s volunteer ocean rescue squad. He expressed his support for allowing Heart of the Hamptons to operate out of the former ambulance barn, and added that he hoped there would be a way in the future for the squad to share space with the organization there.

Father Patrick Edwards of St. John’s Episcopal Church, who is on the board of trustees of Heart of the Hamptons, and the Reverend Sarah Bigwood of the First Presbyterian Church also expressed their support. Bigwood said that “our village zoning code should reflect our values and commitment to compassion and care, and a food pantry is part of that safety net.”

Molly Bishop, the executive director of Heart of the Hamptons, spoke about what the organization has done over the years for residents in the village and greater Southampton Town, pointing out the they operate the only food pantry within the larger Southampton community, providing nearly $1 million in food support annually.

In response to a question about why the organization was being “kicked out” of the church, Bishop clarified that Basilica of the Sacred Hearts of Jesus and Mary Roman Catholic Church, where the pantry has operated for several years, has asked the organization to find a new home but has told her the pantry can stay as long as it needs to. The church needs the space to conduct its own charitable operations and services that have expanded over the years.

“I’m truly disheartened by the fear mongering of people trying to block this,” she said.

Sean Hattrick, who is also on the board of trustees of Heart of the Hamptons, echoed those sentiments, saying that the organization’s mission is to be a good neighbor, something it has demonstrated in the years it has operated out of Sacred Hearts.

At the conclusion of the meeting, the board addressed some of the concerns and complaints brought by opponents. Deputy Mayor Gina Arresta pointed out that the facility at 44 Meetinghouse Lane was built “many years ago” with a certain vision in mind. “The purpose was to serve the community, and that building has always done that,” she said.

Warren pushed back against claims that the board did not conduct the process that led to the new law properly. “Everything was conducted in accordance with state law,” he said. “No one was denied anything. It was done appropriately.”

Attorney Linda Riley pointed out that the organization would still need to go before the Planning Board before getting site plan approval to move into 44 Meetinghouse Lane, adding that any plans to do exterior changes to the building would likely also require Heart of the Hamptons to go before the village Architectural Review Board, as well.

Warren thanked her for pointing that out, adding that opposing neighbors could take their concerns to those boards at that time.

“It’s been a very long process, and we’re happy to get behind this,” Warren said in conclusion. “It’s the job of the Board of Trustees to make decisions on what is best for the village.”

Attorney Anton Borovina, who has been representing the neighbors opposed to the plan, said they intended, once again, to file suit against the village.

You May Also Like:

Bringing Art to Life: Esly Escobar’s Mission to Inspire Young Creatives in Guatemala

Standing in front of a group of curious students, Esly Escobar held up a potato ... 15 Feb 2025 by Michelle Trauring

Candidates To Debate On February 25

The Hampton Bays Civic Association will host a debate/forum for candidates running in the special election for the open seat on the Southampton Town Board. The debate/forum will be held on Monday, February 24, at Hampton Bays Middle School, 70 Ponquogue Avenue in Hampton Bays, from 7 to 8:45 p.m. Former Southampton Town Councilman Rick Martel will face John Leonard in the March 18 special election for the open seat on the Southampton Town Board. The winner will serve until the end of this year, completing the term vacated by Tommy John Schiavoni, who was elected to the New York ... by Staff Writer

Construction Career Scholarship Applications Being Accepted

The Construction Career Charitable Fund has opened applications for its 2025 scholarship program. High school seniors from Westhampton to Montauk, who are planning careers in the construction trades industry immediately after graduation, may apply. With awards of up to $10,000, the CCCF is dedicated to supporting local students with a passion for the trades, providing both financial assistance and career resources. In addition to scholarships, CCCF offers mentorship and job placement assistance, connecting students with leading area contractors in fields such as carpentry, electrical work, plumbing, and more. By partnering with local school districts and top-tier trades professionals, CCCF ensures ... by Staff Writer

Hurdles To Clear

It was a culinary and historic disaster: bird flu striking the Crescent Duck Farm, the last duck farm on Long Island. Some 99,000 ducks, the farm’s entire flock, had to be euthanized because of bird flu. The future of the Crescent Duck Farm involves several thousand eggs. Not only is Crescent Farm the last of what had been many duck farms on Long Island, it has produced — and I think many would agree — the finest ducks to eat, certainly in the nation and probably in the world. “Crescent Duck was started by Henry Corwin in 1908 in Aquebogue ... by Karl Grossman

No Good Reason

Donald Trump always begins with a big lie, which becomes viral through X and Fox News. His newest big lie: The federal workforce is the Deep State, bloated, filled with waste and fraud, pushing useless regulations, with employees sitting home not working. It needs to be dismantled. None of this is true. But Trump and Elon Musk want the public to believe their lie and turn a blind eye to the destruction of the federal government. America needs to wake up before Trump/Musk gut the regulations and federal agencies that keep us safe. It should be noted, many of the ... by Staff Writer

Constant Churn

Kevin Menard said he would like to solicit help from a business school to undertake a study of business conditions [“Sag Harbor Businesses Say They See More Visitors, but Fewer Customers,” 27east.com, February 5]. May I suggest a simple way to evaluate the problem? Buy a Jenga game. The tower of blocks where play is simply pulling one block out, turn by turn, until one is pulled out and the entire tower collapses. Label the bottom four blocks “poverty.” Label the top four blocks the “20 percent.” Everything else is the middle class. Need I make further explanation? The tower ... by Staff Writer

Enforce Zoning

People purchasing property have the expectation that the Town of Southampton’s zoning laws protect the area’s scenic beauty and rural charm. These laws aren’t just promises, they’re commitments to preserving the character and identity of this cherished community. When my wife and I bought our house in Water Mill almost 20 years ago, we paid a premium for the beautiful, unrestricted views and felt reassured that the property next door came encumbered with an easement whose purpose is to “protect the scenic, open space and rural character of the town and to protect the town’s resort and agricultural economy.” The ... by Staff Writer

Meets the Criteria

I am writing to recommend John Leonard for the Southampton Town Council, for the opening to be voted on in the special election on March 18, for the position Tommy John Schiavoni vacated when elected to the New York State Assembly. We all know it is hard to decide on whom to support for leadership in our democracy, especially after watching the selection of the cabinet for our president. What do we look for in a candidate? I think the best criteria should include intelligence, career choices and relevant experience in government. These are the best predictors of success — ... by Staff Writer

The Perfect Place

On behalf of our mother, Dorothy Brown, we would like to thank the staff at Kanas East End Hospice for the lovely care she received over the past few weeks. The Kanas Center, located in Westhampton, is situated on a creek in a beautifully wooded area. The facility is bathed in light, and the doctors, nurses, aides and volunteers were so caring and loving, making sure that Mom was comfortable and not in pain. It was the perfect place for our mom as she transitioned from this world to join our father and be greeted by the Lord. We will ... by Staff Writer

Falsehoods

John Leonard’s rebuttal [“No Bullying,” Letters, February 13] contains numerous falsehoods and further demonstrates his retaliatory and unhinged behavior. The National Labor Relations Board, after hearing both sides, found that two employees of the Evelyn Alexander Wildlife Rescue Center were fired in retaliation for an email they sent to the board of directors. This email brought up, among other things, issues that related to John Leonard. The timing of the firings, right after the email was sent, debunks his preposterous claim that they were carried out for any other reason. Additionally, these firings were done without the consent or knowledge ... by Staff Writer