Sr. Margaret Smyth, a Fierce Advocate for Justice, Dies at Age 83 - 27 East

Sr. Margaret Smyth, a Fierce Advocate for Justice, Dies at Age 83

icon 3 Photos
Sr. Margaret Smyth at a rally for immigration reform in in Riverhead on Oct. 16, 2021. DENISE CIVILETTI

Sr. Margaret Smyth at a rally for immigration reform in in Riverhead on Oct. 16, 2021. DENISE CIVILETTI

Sr. Margaret Smyth speaking at a Riverhead Town Board public hearing in August 2021. DENISE CIVILETTI

Sr. Margaret Smyth speaking at a Riverhead Town Board public hearing in August 2021. DENISE CIVILETTI

Sr. Margaret in her office on Oct. 6, 2017. MARIA DEL MAR PIEDRABUENA

Sr. Margaret in her office on Oct. 6, 2017. MARIA DEL MAR PIEDRABUENA

Denise Civiletti and Maria del Mar Piedrabuena on Dec 20, 2022

The East End has lost a fierce advocate for justice and community.

Sister Margaret Rose Smyth, who ran the North Fork Spanish Apostolate for more than 20 years, died at her home in Riverhead. She was 83 years old.

Sr. Margaret, a member of the Sisters of St. Dominic of Amityville, was known for her passionate devotion to migrant workers and the immigrant communities of the East End.

At the helm of the North Fork Spanish Apostolate for all but three of its 26 years, Sr. Margaret was an icon of the Latino community, the person others turned to for help with everything from food to put on their table to advocacy in justice court when an employer failed to pay a worker’s wages.

She was, by all accounts, a force to be reckoned with.

“There’s nobody like her. The impression she made on this community will go on and on. Everybody around here is just broken-hearted,” said Eileen Mattausch, a volunteer who worked with Sr. Margaret for nearly 20 years.

“There’s going to be a tremendous hole. All along, you know, we will have always said, no one else, no one could ever fill the shoes that she wore,” Mattausch said.

In addition to running the North Fork Spanish Apostolate, Sr. Margaret has since September 2014, also run the social ministry at St. John the Evangelist Church in Riverhead. The North Fork Spanish Apostolate moved its offices to the former parish school that month, and the two organizations, under her tireless leadership, worked together to help community members in need.

When Sr. Margaret didn’t arrive at the parish center this morning to work on putting together Christmas gifts for distribution, and could not be reached by phone, a volunteer and a parish worker went to her apartment to look for her.

“We checked the living room and then we went to the bedroom and that’s when we found her like she was asleep,” said Liz Cardenas, religious formation coordinator at St. John the Evangelist. “The truth is that she went in peace. She had a face of peace, of tranquility. She went to rest in the arms of the Lord.”

Born on October 29, 1939, Margaret Rose Smyth was the daughter of Irish immigrants. She grew up in Woodside, Queens — “a very big Irish community,” she said in a 2018 RiverheadLOCAL interview. She was one of three children in a family she described as very religious.

“I was always doing something that was helping people,” she recalled.

She entered the convent at age 17.

“I always felt that the good Lord wanted me to be able to give most of my life to be able to help people. And they knew at that time, the way to do that was to be a nun,” she said. “There were less things that were open to women then. It’s different for women today. I certainly don’t regret the choices I’ve made.”

She trained to become a teacher and taught at Catholic elementary schools in Queens, and then went on to teach Spanish at a high school in Brooklyn. She then served as a principal at two Catholic elementary schools.

“I loved being in school,” Sr. Margaret said. She was still in touch with her students from decades ago. “I loved being a teacher,” she said.

She later became an associate pastor in East New York, Brooklyn, where she trained to be a community organizer. She already was no stranger to that kind of work. She marched with labor leader and civil rights activist Cesar Chavez in the 1960s.

“When people aren’t being paid or have terrible living conditions or things like that,” she said, “we’ve got to do something.”

Sr. Margaret held a bachelor’s degree in Spanish from St. John’s University and master’s degrees in urban education and spiritual studies from Fordham University.

“Sr. Margaret was a life-changer and a game-changer for me. In the late ’90s, when I first became an immigrant rights advocate, Sr. Margaret took me in what I still call a ‘justice caravan’ to visit an abandoned farmhouse near Briermere Farms on the North Fork,” recalled Richard Koubek, community outreach coordinator for Long Island Jobs with Justice.

“In that falling-down house lived about 40 young Mexican boys and men, all workers on the nearby vineyards. They were paying $250 a month each for rent and had no furniture or electricity,” he said. “What they did have was Sr. Margaret, who got them air mattresses, made sure they had food, and watched over them like a mother. This is why many called her ‘Mama’ instead of ‘Sister.’ She was a true champion of the poor,” Koubek said.

“It leaves a great void in me, my mother was far away, and Sister Margarita was like my mother here. I was in the youth group, and she always supported us so that we were on the right path, that we did the right thing,” said Iván Sacor, a parishioner at St. John the Evangelist Church in Riverhead.

“For us, the immigrant community, we are very devastated,” Sacor said. “She was a great leader.”

Sacor said he remembers her “as a mother, a person who was always there for others, as a religious, and also for moral support, financial support, whatever she could give, she gave it.”

He recalled how Sr. Margaret advocated for respect for the immigrant community on the East End.”She opened doors for many. She helped many people to become residents and citizens, too,” he said.

“We lost a great support. It is very hard. Thank God she was with us for a long time, but it hurts a lot,” Sacor said.

A Spanish language wake will be held on Wednesday, from 7:30 to 8:30 p.m., at St. John the Evangelist Church A wake will be held on Thursday, from 9:45 to 11 a.m., at the church, with a funeral service immediately following. It will be live-streamed on the church’s YouTube channel, stjohnriverhead.

This article was originally published on and Tu Prensa Local and is reprinted here with permission.

You May Also Like:

A Birthday Celebration

On Saturday, October 7, from 4 to 8 p.m. at East Hampton American Legion Post 419, we will be having a 100th birthday party for my dad, whom we call affectionately the “Fish Commander.” My dad is a retired cement mason foreman and the oldest living member of Local 780. In the early 1960s, the union assigned him a job to do, some finished concrete work for the Long Island Lighting Company, in Bridgehampton. With some spare time, he took a casual ride through Bridgehampton and East Hampton and marveled at how much the area resembled where he grew up ... 2 Oct 2023 by Staff Writer

Seeing Is Believing

The Press published a Letter to the Editor online under the headline “For the Trades” [, September 28]. It took note of a campaign sign that candidate Cyndi McNamara had that said she supports the trades, but the letter observed that it is supervisor candidate Maria Moore, as the mayor of Westhampton Beach, who completed the largest infrastructure project in years. The trades were fully employed and paid with grant money; taxes were not raised on the residents. Cyndi, never at a loss for words, responded to that letter and wrote a Facebook post warning people: “Don’t Listen to What ... by Staff Writer

Community News, October 5

MONTAUK Library To Give Back The Montauk Library is joining many libraries across the state ... by Staff Writer

Two Fundraisers To Benefit Maui Community Devastated by Fire

Will Ryan, an artist who lives half the year in Amagansett and the other half in Maui, has organized two fundraisers to help the people of Lahaina, devastated by a wildfire several months ago. The first fundraiser is a musical titled “Maui Strong,” which will be staged at the Stephen Talkhouse on Sunday, October 15, at 7 p.m., starting with a video blessing and chant from a revered Hawaiian Kumu. The music will start acoustic and by the end of the evening will be full rock. The lineup of musicians includes Klyph Black, Joe Delia, Inda Eaton, Mama Lee, Bosco ... by Staff Writer

‘Projections’ Series Continues at Sag Harbor Cinema

Sag Harbor Cinema continues its “Projections” series on Monday, October 9, from 1 to 3 p.m. with a free event featuring the Salvadorian-American artist J. Oscar Molina in conversation with Minerva Perez, executive director of OLA of Eastern Long Island; Esperanza León, head of education and community engagement at the LongHouse Reserve; Mago Martinez, Latinx artist, filmmaker, and diversity curator; and Cristina Cuomo, founder of Purist magazine, who will moderate the panel. The Cinema has partnered with OLA of Eastern Long Island, Inc. (Organización Latino Americana), a nonprofit Latino-focused advocacy organization working in the five East End towns of East ... by Staff Writer

Sag Harbor Sidewalk Sale Set for This Weekend

The Sag Harbor Chamber of Commerce retail members will take to the streets of the ... by Staff Writer

Spooky Walk To Benefit Special Needs Camp

Camp Paquatuck will stage its Spooky Walk for the 35th year at the camp on Chet Swezey Road in Center Moriches. All proceeds benefit the special needs camp. The immersive haunted walk will be available on Fridays and Saturdays, October 20, 21, 27 and 28, from 7 to 9 p.m. each night. Admission is $20 per person. A food and beer concession will be open. For more information, go to by Staff Writer

Greenbelt Celebration Is This Weekend

The 24th annual Long Pond Greenbelt Celebration will be held on Saturday, October 7, from 10 a.m. to 1 p.m. at Vineyard Field, behind the South Fork Natural History Museum. The day will begin with a “Migratory Bird Walk” at 10 a.m., led by SOFO Executive Director Frank Quevedo; a story time with a representative of John Jermain Library will follow at 10:30 a.m. At 10:45 a.m. the Hampton Library will host a music event; the Quogue Wildlife Refuge animals will be available to meet at 11 a.m. and a search for reptiles and amphibians with Chris Chapin will begin ... by Staff Writer

Board of Educatioin Meetings, October 5

Tuesday, October 10 Montauk School District, 4 p.m., 50 South Dorset Drive, Montauk. 631-668-2474 | Amagansett School District, 5 p.m. at the school, 320 Main Street, Amagansett. 631-267-3572 | East Hampton School District, 6:30 p.m., 4 Long Lane, East Hampton. 631-329-4100 | Tuckahoe School District, 6:30 p.m., 468 Magee Street, Southampton. 631-283-3550 | Hampton Bays Public Schools, 7 p.m., 88 Argonne Road East, Hampton Bays, 631-723-2100 | Springs School District work session, 7 p.m. at the school, 48 School Street, East Hampton. 631-324-0144 | Quogue School District, 7:15 p.m., 10 Edgewood Road, Quogue. 631-653-4285 ... by Staff Writer

Fall Fun in Westhampton Beach This Weekend

There will be plenty of opportunities to explore, shop and vacation, with events sponsored by the Greater Westhampton Chamber of Commerce in conjunction with I Love NY over Columbus Day weekend. The fall season in Westhampton kicks off on Main Street with the Greater Westhampton Chamber of Commerce’s annual Fall Festival on Saturday, October 7, from 10 a.m. to 5 p.m., with a rain date of Sunday, October 8. Main Street will be closed to traffic from Library Avenue to Moniebogue Lane. The festival will have food trucks, food and beverage vendors, live music, crafts, aerial artists’ performances, a petting ... by Staff Writer