Timothy M. Gilmartin of Southampton Dies January 15

authorStaff Writer on Jan 21, 2025

Timothy Gilmartin, beloved husband, father, son, brother, and friend, passed away on January 15th, 2025, at 51.

Timmy, as he was affectionately known, lived a life full of service, faith, and passion. He is deeply mourned by his family, friends, and all who had the privilege of knowing him.

Born to David and Linda Gilmartin, Timmy grew up in Southampton, NY, and was a proud 1991 graduate of Mercy High School in Riverhead, NY. He earned his undergraduate degree from The College of the Holy Cross in 1995 and his law degree from Hofstra Law School in 1999, where he met the love of his life, Kathleen Murray. They were married in September 2003 and shared a life full of love, laughter, and adventure.

Timmy was a committed member of the Southampton community. He served on the Tuckahoe School Board, giving his time and energy to the education of future generations. He was also an active and dedicated member of Sacred Hearts Church, where he and Kathleen participated in the Pre-Cana program for many years, helping couples prepare for marriage in their faith.

For the last several years, Timmy worked in the New York State Unified Court System, serving as a Principal Law Clerk. He took great pride in his work, always striving to uphold justice with integrity and fairness.

Timmy’s enthusiasm for life was reflected in his many passions. He was a diehard fan of Notre Dame football—Go Irish—and North Carolina basketball—Go Tarheels. He was an effortlessly good golfer. In his later years, Timmy discovered a newfound love for metal detecting at Coopers Beach, which he often referred to as “hunting.” This hobby brought him immense joy and became a cherished part of his daily routine.

Timmy is survived by his loving wife, Kathleen, and their two beautiful daughters, Marin and Reagan, who were the light of his life. He is also survived by his parents, David and Linda, his mother-in-law, Helen Murray, and his siblings: Rooney (Cherish), Billy, Patty (Shawn), Alicia (Russell), Danny (Megan), Brendan (Jennifer), Mike (Shaye), his sister-in-law, Kerrie Murray-Santare (Dennis), and brother-in-law, Michael Murray (Fiona). Timmy is also survived by a loving group of nieces and nephews: Hayden, Devin, Liam, Ryan, Anna, Kevin, Megan, Timmy, Paddy, Jack, Maddie, Declan, Aidan, Ryan, Gavin, Kieran, Gigi, Sean, Grace, and Connor.

Timmy’s family and friends will always remember him for his quick wit, infectious sense of humor, and unwavering kindness. He brought light and laughter to every room he entered, and his legacy of love, joy, and service will continue to inspire those who knew him.

A funeral Mass will be held at Sacred Hearts Church in Southampton, NY, with details to follow. In lieu of flowers, the family requests donations to Caron Treatment Center, Seafield Center, and the Southampton Volunteer Ambulance.

Timmy’s family takes comfort in knowing he is now at peace, and his memory will live on in the hearts of all who loved him.

You May Also Like:

Fundraiser for Food Pantries Set in Sag Harbor

With stubbornly high food prices and cuts in federal food aid programs, food pantries on the East End are feeling the pinch. This Sunday, a group of Sag Harbor residents, led by Shawn Sachs, Laney Crowell, Fitzhugh Karol and Lyndsay Caleo Karol, have organized a fundraiser for the Sag Harbor and Springs food pantries at Kidd Squid Brewing Company on Spring Street in Sag Harbor. The free event will run from noon to 5 p.m.; attendees have been asked to drop off nonperishable foods, make a donation or help collect and deliver donated food to the two food pantries. “This ... 11 Nov 2025 by Stephen J. Kotz

Sag Harbor Cinema Executive Director To Leave Post

The Sag Harbor Cinema announced on Tuesday that Genevieve Villaflor, who has served as executive ... by Stephen J. Kotz

Sag Harbor Partnership Cancels Firehouse Museum Fundraising Event

​An open house scheduled for Friday, November 14, to kick off the fundraising effort to restore the Sag Harbor Firehouse Museum has been canceled. The Sag Harbor Partnership announced that it had learned “there is some remediation to be done” that prevents allowing guests inside the building, which has sat unattended for five years and saw little regular upkeep in the years before. The Partnership has estimated that it will cost approximately $1.2 million to restore the building plus an additional $300,000 to create modern displays. The board said it would reschedule the event as soon as possible. by Staff Writer

Scallop Season Opens, but Scant Few Scallops To Be Found

The bay scallop harvest on the South Fork opened in Southampton and East Hampton waters ... by Michael Wright

School News, November 13, Sag Harbor and East Hampton Town

Former Ross School Head Chef Joins EWECC Liz Dobbs has joined the Eleanor Whitmore Early ... by Staff Writer

Community News, November 13

YOUTH CORNER Toddler & Teeny Tumbling Project Most at the Community Learning Center, 44 Meadow ... by Staff Writer

Bonac Swimmers Compete at Counties; Relay Team, Daniels Set To Compete at States

The East Hampton/Pierson/Bridgehampton girls swim team finished seventh out of 19 schools at the Section ... by Drew Budd

Interfaith Service Celebrates Connections

An interfaith community Thanksgiving celebration will take place at the Old Whalers’ Church in Sag Harbor on Thursday, November 20, at 7 p.m. Local ministers from a range of faith traditions will come together for a service of gratitude and unity. The program will include song, prayer, storytelling and reflection, honoring the shared blessings that connect the community. All proceeds from the evening’s collection will be given to the Sag Harbor and Bridgehampton food pantries. Following the service, attendees are invited to stay for a “Pie Extravaganza,” featuring dessert, conversation and fellowship. For more information, visit oldwhalerschurch.org. by Staff Writer

Stronger Future

I am deeply honored and humbled by the trust the residents of our town have placed in me by electing me to the Town Council. Winning this election is not just a personal milestone; it is a collective achievement made possible by the dedication, energy and belief of so many in our community. To my wife, Cynthia, whose love and support carried me through every challenge, thank you for standing by me. To our committee members and volunteers who knocked on doors, made calls, wrote letters and postcards, your tireless efforts made this victory possible. To every supporter who offered ... by Staff Writer

Mere Stewards

With the conclusion of the 2025 election, I want to take an opportunity to thank the members of my team and all those who came out to vote. To those who support me and voted for me, I would not be able to do it without you, and I thank you for your trust. To those whose vote I didn’t win, I say: I am glad you came out to voice your opinion, and I look forward to earning your respect in the future. During my time on the board, it has also been a great pleasure working alongside Trustees ... by Staff Writer