Two In Contention For Southampton Town Justice

icon 3 Photos
Patrick Gunn is running for Southampton Town Justice on the Republican line. COURTESY PAT GUNN

Patrick Gunn is running for Southampton Town Justice on the Republican line. COURTESY PAT GUNN

Incumbent Southampton Town Justice Karen Sartain is running to retain her seat on the bench. COURTESY KAREN SARTAIN

Incumbent Southampton Town Justice Karen Sartain is running to retain her seat on the bench. COURTESY KAREN SARTAIN

Karen Sartain and Patrick Gunn

Karen Sartain and Patrick Gunn

Kitty Merrill on Oct 28, 2020

Two candidates are in contention for a seat on the bench in Southampton Town Justice Court — Patrick Gunn and Karen Sartain.

Mr. Gunn is running on the Republican, Conservative, Working Families, and Independence party lines. A Town of Southampton resident for the last 27 years, he’s practiced law in the Southampton Town Justice Court for the last 17 as both a prosecutor and defense attorney. He currently has a private practice and is the prosecutor for the Village of Quogue.

A veteran of the U.S. Navy, magna cum laude graduate of Southampton College with an MBA from C.W. Post and a law degree from Touro Law School, he served in the Suffolk County District Attorney’s office from 2003 to 2010. He was the assistant town attorney for the Town of East Hampton from 2010 to 2013, as well as its public safety division administrator. In that role, he oversaw departments involved in code enforcement.

“I’m seeking this position because I love this community and would be honored to serve in this capacity,” Mr. Gunn said this week. Working in Southampton Justice Court in dual capacities — sometimes as prosecutor and sometimes for the defense — he said, “Handling all types of cases, I have gained a unique perspective and appreciation of all positions and opinions, as well as insight into the unique qualities that make the Town of Southampton a special place.”

Karen Sartain is running on the Democratic Party line. She was appointed to fill out the term of Andrea Schiavoni, who was elected to Suffolk County Family Court in 2019.

“Little did I know that soon after my appointment, the COVID-19 pandemic would significantly change the daily operations of the Southampton Town Justice Court,” she said this week. “My role suddenly became a leadership position in addition to my responsibilities as town justice.”

Confronted with the need to pivot, Judge Sartain helped streamline the transition to virtual/remote hearings, assisted with designing the courtroom’s layout to meet state COVID-19 guidelines, and was instrumental in getting town approval for a walk-up window on the exterior of the courtroom.

“I run an efficient and respectful courtroom and wish to be elected town justice to continue the hard work I’ve done this year,” she said.

A Westhampton attorney, Ms. Sartain graduated from the University of Pennsylvania in 1990 and earned her law degree from the University of Miami in Coral Gables in 1993. During law school, she interned at the office of the public defender in Miami and was a volunteer guardian through the Florida Department of Children and Families.

Ms. Sartain represented the city’s indigent clients as an assistant public defender in Miami. In 2016, she became a staff attorney with the Legal Aid Society of Suffolk County. Two years later, she began her own practice and continued defending clients who lacked resources. She also worked as a volunteer for the East End Regional Intervention Court, commonly known as drug court.

The New York State League of Women Voters has created an online voters guide at www.Vote411.org with non-partisan information on the candidates, as well as pro and con information on the two Suffolk County propositions on the ballot for the November 3 election.

For the East End, this includes information, supplied by the candidates, on the races for president, U.S. Congress, New York State Senate, State Assembly, State Supreme Court, Suffolk County Family Court, Suffolk County Court, and other local judgeships.

All voters have to do is go to the Vote411.org website and enter their address. The ballot information for that address, as well as other election information, will appear.

You May Also Like:

Patricia C. Farrell of Sag Harbor Dies November 17

Patricia C. Farrell of Sag Harbor died on November 17 on Quioque. She was 92. A visitation will take place on Friday, November 21, from 3-7 p.m. at the Brockett Funeral Home in Southampton. A funeral Mass will be celebrated on Saturday, November 22, at 10 a.m. at St. Andrew’s Catholic Church in Sag Harbor. Memorial donations to East End Hospice (eeh.org) and Sag Harbor Food Pantry (sagharborfoodpantry.org). A complete obituary will appear in a future edition of The Press. 18 Nov 2025 by Staff Writer

Early Momentum Fades as Bonac Football Drops County Semifinal to Sayville

Following his team’s 28-14 loss at Sayville in the Suffolk County Division III semifinal on ... by Drew Budd

Great Place To Be

I read with deep attention to detail the almost full-page story on the lack of parking during the busy summer months in Westhampton Beach [“Westhampton Beach Village Board Exploring Paid Parking Options,” 27east.com, November 10]. I did note, happily, that Mayor Ralph Urban hedged his bets a number of times in the article as to whether or not paid parking for Main Street spots, or spots in the lot behind the shops on the south side of Main Street, was really a solution. Mr. Mayor, it’s not. (The silliest idea floated was to consider the East Hampton plan, which is ... by Staff Writer

Define the Problem

To solve a problem, the critical step is defining it. What are the root causes of our immigration crisis? 1) Lack of economic opportunity, especially in Central and South America and Mexico, but all over the world, in reality. 2) Political unrest fueled by authoritarian regimes, or by religious fanaticism, or any combination thereof. 3) Destruction caused by repeated and worsening climate issues: floods, typhoons, hurricanes, fires, drought. 4) Global connection via internet to all corners of the world. The have-nots can see what others do have. 5) The illegal drug trade, closely related to item 1 but also just ... by Staff Writer

Sounds Familiar

Southampton Village has its own Donald Trump and Pam Bondi: Mayor Bill Manger and Village Attorney Eileen Powers. Manger, an aspiring Trump (and a former employee), and Powers, an aspiring Bondi, both relying on the same familiar trio of secrecy, spin and self-preservation. The latest example is the architectural review study, a report paid for with public grant money to evaluate which homes could face more onerous restrictions if included in a new historic district. Instead of sharing it, Manger and Powers locked it away like it’s the Epstein files. Note that Leon Black, a known Epstein associate who made ... by Staff Writer

Amazing Day

On behalf of the Village of Southampton Commission on Veterans Patriotic Events, I would like to express my sincere gratitude to the following individuals and groups who helped make this year’s Veterans Day celebration a success: Our veterans, volunteers and donors; Emily Paccasassi, for singing the national anthem; the Southampton High School Chorus and Band and James Tartaglia, its director; our guest speaker, Vietnam veteran nurse Joan Furey, who earned a Bronze Star for her service in Vietnam in 1968; the Southampton Village Police Department, EMTs, the Village Department of Public Works, and the fire department for their presence and ... 17 Nov 2025 by Staff Writer

Need To Adapt

I’m not typically keen on dueling Letters to the Editor, but in my best Inigo Montoya voice, my response to Highway Superintendent Charles McArdle is: “I did not say what you think I said” [“Oversight Failure,” Letters, November 13]. Let me try again by melding our two points of view: If governments at all levels continue to ignore necessary infrastructure maintenance while our planet continues to warm, expect the kinds of things that happened at Sunrise Highway to happen with more frequency. The combination of more intense storms with shoddy maintenance programs will cause more damage and impact on our ... by Staff Writer

WordHampton Picks Up Awards

WordHampton Wins Awards WordHampton Public Relations was recently the recipient of several MarCom awards acknowledging ... by Staff Writer

Peconic Bay Medical Center Earns Top Safety Award

Peconic Bay Medical Center Earns Top Safety Grade Peconic Bay Medical Center has earned an “A” Hospital Safety Grade from The Leapfrog Group for fall 2025, recognizing the hospital’s consistent excellence in patient safety. “This recognition affirms the exceptional work of our entire PBMC team in maintaining a culture of safety, compassion and clinical excellence,” said Amy Loeb, president of PBMC. “Every member of our staff, from physicians and nurses to support teams, plays a vital role in delivering care that our patients can trust. As our hospital continues to expand to meet the growing needs of the residents on ... by Staff Writer

Police Ask for Help Locating Missing Man Last Seen in Hampton Bays

Southampton Town Police are asking for the public’s help to locate a missing man last ... by Staff Writer