Two In Contention For Southampton Town Justice

icon 3 Photos
Patrick Gunn is running for Southampton Town Justice on the Republican line. COURTESY PAT GUNN

Patrick Gunn is running for Southampton Town Justice on the Republican line. COURTESY PAT GUNN

Incumbent Southampton Town Justice Karen Sartain is running to retain her seat on the bench. COURTESY KAREN SARTAIN

Incumbent Southampton Town Justice Karen Sartain is running to retain her seat on the bench. COURTESY KAREN SARTAIN

Karen Sartain and Patrick Gunn

Karen Sartain and Patrick Gunn

Kitty Merrill on Oct 28, 2020

Two candidates are in contention for a seat on the bench in Southampton Town Justice Court — Patrick Gunn and Karen Sartain.

Mr. Gunn is running on the Republican, Conservative, Working Families, and Independence party lines. A Town of Southampton resident for the last 27 years, he’s practiced law in the Southampton Town Justice Court for the last 17 as both a prosecutor and defense attorney. He currently has a private practice and is the prosecutor for the Village of Quogue.

A veteran of the U.S. Navy, magna cum laude graduate of Southampton College with an MBA from C.W. Post and a law degree from Touro Law School, he served in the Suffolk County District Attorney’s office from 2003 to 2010. He was the assistant town attorney for the Town of East Hampton from 2010 to 2013, as well as its public safety division administrator. In that role, he oversaw departments involved in code enforcement.

“I’m seeking this position because I love this community and would be honored to serve in this capacity,” Mr. Gunn said this week. Working in Southampton Justice Court in dual capacities — sometimes as prosecutor and sometimes for the defense — he said, “Handling all types of cases, I have gained a unique perspective and appreciation of all positions and opinions, as well as insight into the unique qualities that make the Town of Southampton a special place.”

Karen Sartain is running on the Democratic Party line. She was appointed to fill out the term of Andrea Schiavoni, who was elected to Suffolk County Family Court in 2019.

“Little did I know that soon after my appointment, the COVID-19 pandemic would significantly change the daily operations of the Southampton Town Justice Court,” she said this week. “My role suddenly became a leadership position in addition to my responsibilities as town justice.”

Confronted with the need to pivot, Judge Sartain helped streamline the transition to virtual/remote hearings, assisted with designing the courtroom’s layout to meet state COVID-19 guidelines, and was instrumental in getting town approval for a walk-up window on the exterior of the courtroom.

“I run an efficient and respectful courtroom and wish to be elected town justice to continue the hard work I’ve done this year,” she said.

A Westhampton attorney, Ms. Sartain graduated from the University of Pennsylvania in 1990 and earned her law degree from the University of Miami in Coral Gables in 1993. During law school, she interned at the office of the public defender in Miami and was a volunteer guardian through the Florida Department of Children and Families.

Ms. Sartain represented the city’s indigent clients as an assistant public defender in Miami. In 2016, she became a staff attorney with the Legal Aid Society of Suffolk County. Two years later, she began her own practice and continued defending clients who lacked resources. She also worked as a volunteer for the East End Regional Intervention Court, commonly known as drug court.

The New York State League of Women Voters has created an online voters guide at www.Vote411.org with non-partisan information on the candidates, as well as pro and con information on the two Suffolk County propositions on the ballot for the November 3 election.

For the East End, this includes information, supplied by the candidates, on the races for president, U.S. Congress, New York State Senate, State Assembly, State Supreme Court, Suffolk County Family Court, Suffolk County Court, and other local judgeships.

All voters have to do is go to the Vote411.org website and enter their address. The ballot information for that address, as well as other election information, will appear.

You May Also Like:

Southampton Wants To Streamline Review for Locally Subsidized Housing Projects

Southampton Town plans to create a new zoning overlay district specifically for affordable housing projects ... 2 Dec 2025 by Michael Wright

Gathering Facts

Bob Giuffra is undoubtedly one of the country’s most accomplished litigators. He is also the chair of the Lake Agawam Conservancy and in that capacity wrote an unfortunate and misleading letter last week [“Playing Politics,” Letters, November 27] accusing me of staging a “political ambush” for raising concerns over the village’s review and supposed “approval” of recent plantings along Gin Lane. He further claimed that I pressured the village attorney, an allegation that would be laughable if it were not so recklessly untrue. One would expect a greater regard for facts from an attorney of Mr. Giuffra’s stature before attaching ... by Staff Writer

Long Island State Parks Dashboard Permits for 2026 Season

The New York State Office of Parks, Recreation and Historic Preservation announced that the following dashboard permits will be available for purchase beginning Tuesday, December 2, and through Tuesday, March 31, for the upcoming 2026 season: Fishing 4-Wheel Drive Access Permit, Surfing 4-Wheel Drive Access Permit, Stargazing, Night/Sport Fishing, Camp Hero Fishing, Nighttime Photography and Regional SCUBA-Diving. Permits can be purchased online or by phone. There will be no in-person sales. All permits will be mailed to the applicant once processed. Purchase online or by phone through New York State Parks Reserve America: Visit the New York State Parks Reserve ... by Staff Writer

Payroll Case Against Riverhead Contractor Thrown Out

The December 2024 indictment of Southampton contractor Robert Terry and his Riverhead-based company, Terry Contracting ... by Denise Civiletti

Jon Alan Baer of Sag Harbor Dies November 30

Jon Alan Baer, a lifelong resident of Sag Harbor, died on November 30. He was 80. Born on June 25, 1945, in Southampton, he was the son of Kosty Joseph Baer and Mary Olive Klingler. His life was marked by commitment to education and the arts. After graduating from Pierson High School, he earned two master’s degrees from the State University of New York at Albany in 1977 and 1978, followed by a doctorate in philosophy in 1993. His academic accomplishments reflected his love of learning and his dedication to understanding the world around him. From 1969 to 2000, he ... by Staff Writer

Joy and Happiness

To the members of our community near and far: We would like to thank everyone who came out to enjoy the Parade of Lights and tree lighting in Agawam Park this past Saturday evening. It was another fantastic experience for Southampton. We are grateful to our fire and EMS departments that participated in the parade, decorating their trucks and vehicles and bringing so much joy and happiness to all those who lined the streets. Thank you to the Voices of Southampton, under the direction of James Tartaglia, for their beautiful singing, and special thanks to the Southampton Fire Department chiefs ... by Staff Writer

Meaningful Recognition

On behalf of Southampton Village Ocean Rescue (SVOR), we are deeply grateful to Mayor Bill Manger and the Southampton Village Board, including Trustee Roy Stevenson, our liaison, for formally adopting the local law authorizing up to a 10 percent property tax exemption for SVOR members. A heartfelt thank you to Eileen Powers, village attorney, for her diligent work in facilitating this resolution, guiding it smoothly to completion in a timely manner. We also value Scott Russell, village administrator, for his important input and we sincerely appreciate the continued support of the village we proudly serve. Thanks to the efforts of ... by Staff Writer

Connecting to History

David Rung’s recent letter regarding the proposed Southampton Village Historical Walking Tours [“Wasted Dollars,” Letters, November 20] seems to misunderstand the intent of this initiative. The idea is not to recreate Google Maps or offer a generic navigation tool. Rather, this project envisions self-guided historic walking tours of Southampton Village — particularly within the village business district — designed to celebrate and share our community’s rich history. Southampton has many remarkable stories to tell, from its founding to the many historic landmarks that define our identity today. Many visitors and even some residents are unaware of the depth of that ... 1 Dec 2025 by Staff Writer

Lack of Ethics

The November 25 Southampton Village Board work session delivered yet another reminder of our village’s lack of ethics. There were many cringeworthy moments, but none more uncomfortable than watching Trustee Roy Stevenson forced to read a prepared statement recusing himself because the matter involved his golf buddy and major campaign donor. That donor received a reduction in his taxable assessed value through the settlement of an Article 7 tax grievance. What made the moment even more troubling was that Mayor Bill Manger also came into the meeting with a prepared statement expressing his intention to vote in favor of the ... by Staff Writer

Santa Coming to Westhampton Beach

The Village of Westhampton Beach will host its annual Christmas Tree and Menorah Lighting Celebration on the Village Green on Saturday, December 6, from 5:30 to 6:30 p.m. At 6 p.m., the Westhampton Beach Fire Department will escort Santa to the Green, joining decorated fire trucks from neighboring departments in a festive parade of lights down Main Street. The trucks will leave the Westhampton Beach firehouse at 5:45 p.m., travel south on Sunset Avenue to Hansen Place and then left onto Potunk Lane before proceeding to Main Street toward the Village Green, where Santa will greet children of all ages. by Staff Writer