UPDATE: Victim Of Shooting On Shinnecock Indian Nation Territory Identified Along With Person Of Interest

icon 3 Photos
State Police identified Michael Gaines, 42, as a person of interest in the shooting that took place on the Shinnecock territory on Friday morning. COURTESY STATE POLICE

State Police identified Michael Gaines, 42, as a person of interest in the shooting that took place on the Shinnecock territory on Friday morning. COURTESY STATE POLICE

Cars were seen entering the Shinnecock Indian Nation territory Friday, while a shooting was being investigated from earlier that morning. JENNIFER CORR

Cars were seen entering the Shinnecock Indian Nation territory Friday, while a shooting was being investigated from earlier that morning. JENNIFER CORR

A public safety vehicle blocks the west entrance of the Shinnecock territory on Friday morning. GREG WEHNER

A public safety vehicle blocks the west entrance of the Shinnecock territory on Friday morning. GREG WEHNER

authorAnisah Abdullah on Aug 16, 2019

UPDATE: Saturday, 11:50 a.m.
 

On Saturday, State Police identified the victim of the shooting as Mtundo Vanterpool, 43, who was not a member of the Shinnecock tribe, although he lived on the territory.

In a press release issued on Saturday morning, police said they are looking for Michael Gaines, 42, adding they believe he has information regarding the investigation.

Mr. Gaines also resided on the Shinnecock territory as a non-member of the tribe, according to police.

The press release noted that Suffolk County Crime Stoppers has a fast cash reward of $1,000 for anyone with information that leads to an arrest connected to the shooting — the reward will be issued within 72 hours.

UPDATE: 4:45 p.m.
 

State Police are still at the scene and the shooter has not yet been apprehended, according to Tribal Council Chairman Bryan Polite and Vice Chairman Lance A. Gumbs, who were both unsure of the perpetrator's whereabouts.

"The Council of Trustees is still cautioning everybody just to stay vigilant," Mr. Polite said Friday afternoon.

"The bottom line is, just shock," Mr. Gumbs said. "Nothing like this has ever happened in our community, so it’s basically shock and just trying to deal with that right now amongst our tribal members."

Earlier in the day, the Nation went into "lockdown mode" and community buildings were shut down, Mr. Gumbs said. Law enforcement officials had blocked off entry roads but were gone around lunch time.

The two tribal officials said that the victim and shooter were both non-Shinnecock men, but could not provide further identifying information.

"We just want to make clear that this was a non-Shinnecock-related incident," Mr. Gumbs said.

State Police noted earlier in the day that it was not an "active shooter" situation.

UPDATE: 12:40 p.m.
 

State Police received a call of a shooting on the Shinnecock territory at around 5:35 a.m. Friday morning, according to a press release. One person was pronounced dead with a gunshot wound and State Police is actively investigating the homicide, the release stated.

Anyone with information on the incident can call State Police Farmingdale at 631-756-3300 and all calls will remain confidential, the release stated.

UPDATE: 11:45 a.m.
 

The Council of Trustees informed community members via e-blast and social media that the shooter was a 6-foot-1-inch African American man, heavy-set, between 30 and 40 years old, according to a member of the tribe.

ORIGINAL STORY:
 

A person was shot and killed during an incident on the Shinnecock Indian Nation territory on Friday, several Shinnecock members confirmed. Neither the shooter or the victim are Shinnecock members and the shooter has not yet been apprehended, they said.

New York State Police declined to immediately comment.

You May Also Like:

Plungers Take Frosty Dip for Heart of the Hamptons

Over 100 people turned out for Heart of the Hamptons’ annual Polar Bear Plunge, where ... 15 Dec 2025 by Staff Writer

Community News, December 18

HOLIDAY HAPPENINGS Holiday Movie Marathon The Hampton Bays Public Library, 52 Ponquogue Avenue in Hampton ... by Staff Writer

Southampton History Museum To Host 'Hearthside Cheer' Event

The Southampton History Museum will welcome the community to Rogers Mansion on Saturday, December 20 for “Hearthside Cheer,” an annual holiday gathering that blends historic tradition, music, and culinary heritage within the 19th-century home. The event will take place from 5 to 8 p.m. and invites guests to join museum staff, board members, and neighbors for an evening of seasonal warmth. The mansion will be adorned with vintage holiday décor, including handmade ornaments from the 1960s through the 1980s, each reflecting stories of craft and celebration. Traditional musicians Maria Fairchild on banjo and Adam Becherer on fiddle will perform historic ... by Staff Writer

Antique Holiday Toy Exhibit Opens in Westhampton Beach

The Westhampton Beach Historical Society is inviting the community to its annual Antique Holiday Toy Exhibit, running Saturdays and Sundays from noon to 3 p.m. through Janury 4. The society’s museum is at 101 Mill Road in Westhampton Beach. The exhibit features more than 100 years of holiday toys, including games, dolls, trains and gadgets. Visitors can explore the evolution of play and experience a dazzling display of toys that shaped holidays past. For more information, visit whbhistorical.org. by Staff Writer

School News, December 18, Southampton Town

Hampton Bays Students Inducted Into Math, Science Honor Societies Hampton Bays High School recently inducted ... by Staff Writer

Community Cooperative Project Plants Beach Grass

Southampton Town’s ongoing effort to restore and protect the shoreline at Foster Memorial Long Beach ... by Staff Writer

Daryn Elizabeth Sidor of East Quogue Dies December 13

Daryn Elizabeth Sidor of East Quogue died peacefully on December 13, after a courageous battle ... by Staff Writer

Southampton Elks Hold Successful Food Drive

The Southampton Elks Lodge 1574 held a community food drive to support Heart of the ... by Staff Writer

CMEE To Host Family New Year's Eve Event

The Children’s Museum of the East End in Bridgehampton will ring in 2026 with a daytime New Year’s Eve celebration designed especially for young families. The museum will host its annual New Year’s Eve Bash on Wednesday, December 31, from 10 a.m. to noon. During the event, children will make noisemakers, share resolutions for the coming year and enjoy open play, crafts and dancing with CMEE’s resident DJ. Admission is $5 for museum members and $25 for nonmembers. Registration is available online at cmee.org. by Staff Writer

Gift-Wrapping Event Set At Publick House

A gift-wrapping event hosted by the Flying Point Foundation for Autism will be held on Sunday, December 21, from noon to 4 p.m. at the Southampton Publick House on Jobs Lane in Southampton. During those hours, volunteers will be available to wrap holiday gifts in exchange for a donation in any amount. As part of the event, the Southampton Publick House is offering a complimentary glass of wine or draft beer for those who bring gifts to be wrapped. For more information, text 631-255-5664. by Staff Writer