A Montauk 'Summer House' That's Not In Montauk - 27 East

Real Estate News

Real Estate News / 1404303

A Montauk 'Summer House' That's Not In Montauk

icon 2 Photos

Adonis Hutchings is one of three captains for the Mariners this season. DREW BUDD

Adonis Hutchings is one of three captains for the Mariners this season. DREW BUDD

authorJon Winkler on Dec 19, 2016

A trailer for the upcoming show sets the mood:

When a group of beautiful and successful New Yorkers leaves the comforts of the Big Apple behind to party the summer away in their home away from home, nothing is off limits," it declares as the characters blow off steam in the swimming pool, the jacuzzi, on the kitchen table and in the four bedrooms ("Weiners are out!" one exclaims).
"Bravo's new series 'Summer House' takes the beach town of Montauk, New York, by storm, while following a group of nine friends who make the exclusive enclave their go-to party spot between Memorial Day and Labor Day," the trailer continues.

The truth is that the house isn’t in Montauk, and share houses are not permitted in East Hampton Town. And there’s no wild and raucous partying going on at the moment.

Two Christmas wreaths quietly adorn the gate to the 4,500-square-foot homestead set in a remote and somewhat desolate spot on Napeague Harbor Road in Amagansett. Instead of being filled with intoxicated frolickers, the swimming pool in all likelihood has been drained for months.

Welcome to Winter House—the late-December version of the home that stars in “Summer House,” a Bravo reality show set to premiere on January 16. Much of the series was filmed at the rental home, given that the show follows nine sexually energetic young New Yorkers who rent a share house for the summer, ostensibly in Montauk.

"So, what makes Montauk so special?" the trailer posits. "Everyone's heard of the Hamptons. That's like your mom's friend who wears pearls," explains one young male character. "Montauk is like your mom's friend's daughter — who's a little promiscuous. And by a little, I mean a lot."

This “Jersey Shore” vibe is precisely what Montauk locals and merchants, as well as East Hampton Town officials, hope not to broadcast to potential visitors. After Bravo's trailer was released early this month, Laraine Creegan, executive director of the Montauk Chamber of Commerce, told The Press that the show does not represent the chamber’s efforts to encourage families, rather than party animals, to vacation in Montauk.

“We did not embrace that particular show for a couple of reasons,” she said. “Number one, share houses are illegal anywhere in East Hampton, including Montauk,” she said.

Given the premise of the series, the filming of the show over the summer was not without its own controversy, and the town turned the filmmakers down when they wanted to use town-owned Kirk Park Beach in Montauk, saying July was busy enough without the disruption of a film crew on public property.

Paul Monte, president of the Montauk Chamber of Commerce, expressed his dismay on Facebook as well back in July, asking residents to make it known to town officials that the show’s images of drunken debauchery were “not the image of Montauk we want to promote.”

This week East Hampton Town Supervisor Larry Cantwell said that he, like Ms. Creegan, has seen the trailer for the Bravo series.

“I despise the message,” the supervisor said. “From the trailer that I saw and given the issue we’ve been dealing with in Montauk, the message is contrary to what Montauk is about.”

"

You May Also Like:

Quail Ridge Residents Scramble After Apartments Are Purchased for Redevelopment | 27Speaks Podcast

The tenants of Quail Ridge — the two dozen studio and one-bedroom apartments spread over ... 3 Jul 2025 by 27Speaks

Water Mill Property Where Hal Buckner and Dorothy Lichtenstein Left Their Marks Is for Sale

A Water Mill property that hosts a former dairy barn turned artist’s studio and a ... 30 Jun 2025 by Brendan J. O’Reilly

Sundays on the Bay Hits the Market

Sundays on the Bay restaurant and marina on Dune Road in Hampton Bays has hit ... 29 Jun 2025 by Staff Writer

Hamptons Rental Market Remains Alive and Well

To paraphrase Mark Twain, reports of the demise of the Hamptons summer-rental market are greatly exaggerated. “Any hint that the Hamptons rental market is anything but robust is completely wrong,” said Corcoran associate broker Gary DePersia in East Hampton. An interesting dynamic is stirring in the Hamptons vacation-rental market. Although there has been an unprecedented rise in short-term rentals and the aftershocks of the COVID-19 pandemic linger, it has been a bumper crop year for Wall Street, interest rates have remained steady and a new breed of demanding customer is emerging. Despite it all, the Hamptons vacation-rental market remains as ... 19 Jun 2025 by Joseph Finora

Jon Vaccari Joins Noble Black & Partners at Douglas Elliman

Jon Vaccari, a longtime resident of Sag Harbor, has joined Noble Black & Partners at ... 18 Jun 2025 by Staff Writer

Appeals Court Sides With Landowner Over Southampton Village ZBA

Southampton Village has lost an appeal that sought to reinstate a Zoning Board of Appeals ... 12 Jun 2025 by Brendan J. O’Reilly

Last Parcel of Startop Ranch in Montauk Sells

The last plot of land at Startop Ranch in Montauk, 107 Startop Drive, has sold ... by Staff Writer

Hamptons Real Estate Roundtable, Memorial Day Weekend 2025 Edition

With Memorial Day weekend about to kick the Hamptons into high season, The Express News ... 22 May 2025 by Moderated by Brendan J. O’Reilly

Au-Delà Real Estate Vows To Go 'Beyond'

Au-Delà Real Estate, a new boutique real estate firm based in East Hampton, is now ... 20 May 2025 by Brendan J. O’Reilly

AI Helps Rental Seekers Find Homes That Match Their Aesthetic Preferences

Consumers increasingly have an expectation of superior, more personalized service based on their own particular ... by Steven Loeb