After More Than a Year, Unwanted Occupants Evicted - 27 East

Real Estate News

Real Estate News / 2299241

After More Than a Year, Unwanted Occupants Evicted

icon 19 Photos
Workers in protective clothing began removing items from the home on October 10.  DANA SHAW

Workers in protective clothing began removing items from the home on October 10. DANA SHAW

Homeowner Arnold Dormer surveys the damage to to a piece of antique furniture.  DANA SHAW

Homeowner Arnold Dormer surveys the damage to to a piece of antique furniture. DANA SHAW

Arnold Dormer looks for items belonging to he and his wife to salvage.  DANA SHAW

Arnold Dormer looks for items belonging to he and his wife to salvage. DANA SHAW

Homeowner Arnold Dormer looks for items belonging to he and his wife to salvage.  DANA SHAW

Homeowner Arnold Dormer looks for items belonging to he and his wife to salvage. DANA SHAW

Occupants of the house created a huge trash heap off of the side of the house.  DANA SHAW

Occupants of the house created a huge trash heap off of the side of the house. DANA SHAW

The living room was littered with garbage as well as a child's car seat and playpen.  DANA SHAW

The living room was littered with garbage as well as a child's car seat and playpen. DANA SHAW

The living room of the home.  DANA SHAW

The living room of the home. DANA SHAW

The Suffolk County Sheriff's Office placed a notice of eviction on the home on October 10.  DANA SHAW

The Suffolk County Sheriff's Office placed a notice of eviction on the home on October 10. DANA SHAW

A hall way to the kitchen was blocked with furniture and debris.   DANA  SHAW

A hall way to the kitchen was blocked with furniture and debris. DANA SHAW

Children's toys and garbage cover one of the bedroom's floors.  DANA SHAW

Children's toys and garbage cover one of the bedroom's floors. DANA SHAW

Homeowner Arnold Dormer surveys the damage to his property.  DANA SHAW

Homeowner Arnold Dormer surveys the damage to his property. DANA SHAW

The washer and dryer in the kitchen.  DANA SHAW

The washer and dryer in the kitchen. DANA SHAW

An upstairs bedroom of the home is strewn with garbage and furniture is damaged.  DANA SHAW

An upstairs bedroom of the home is strewn with garbage and furniture is damaged. DANA SHAW

An upstairs bedroom of the home is strewn with garbage and furniture is damaged.  DANA SHAW

An upstairs bedroom of the home is strewn with garbage and furniture is damaged. DANA SHAW

An upstairs bedroom of the home is strewn with garbage and furniture is damaged.  DANA SHAW

An upstairs bedroom of the home is strewn with garbage and furniture is damaged. DANA SHAW

An upstairs bedroom of the home is strewn with garbage and furniture is damaged.  DANA SHAW

An upstairs bedroom of the home is strewn with garbage and furniture is damaged. DANA SHAW

Workers in protective clothing began removing items from the home on October 10.  DANA SHAW

Workers in protective clothing began removing items from the home on October 10. DANA SHAW

Workers in protective clothing began removing items from the home on October 10.  DANA SHAW

Workers in protective clothing began removing items from the home on October 10. DANA SHAW

Workers in protective clothing began removing items from the home on October 10.  DANA SHAW

Workers in protective clothing began removing items from the home on October 10. DANA SHAW

Brendan J. O’Reilly on Oct 15, 2024

Thirteen months after he and his wife allowed a couple with four young children to use their Water Mill house for a few weeks, Arnold Dormer was finally permitted to reenter the house last Thursday. He walked into a house that had been trashed, with damaged furniture, handprints and filth all over the walls and furniture, rodent-holes left in a custom silk couch, and loose garbage on the floor of every room — as well as piled out the back door.

His, wife, Dr. Anita Dormer, explained during interviews last week that the family had been kicked out of a shelter, and she was led to believe the father was dying of cancer and unable to get the family into another shelter due to his diagnosis. The Dormers’ house was for sale, but they offered it to the family to stay in while the father underwent chemotherapy treatment in Southampton. They didn’t charge rent.

She had stayed in the house with the family a couple of times that first month. She noticed the children had written on the walls, and she said that was the first time she suggested they move. Then the Dormers’ gardener went to the house to take the plants indoors for the wintertime. The gardener found that the occupants had barred the doors and said, “It’s 30 days. You’re not going to come in here anymore.”

Thirty days is a minimum number of days someone must lawfully occupy a home in New York State to establish tenancy without a lease. Removal of a tenant requires the property owner to bring a court proceeding for eviction and obtain a judgment of possession from the court. Evicting an occupant without a court order is a class A misdemeanor in New York State.

The Dormers contacted a lawyer right away.

Anita Dormer said the house was not a rental property and they never had a lease. She had expected the family to be there for weeks, and never got the chance to remove her belongings before the occupants asserted tenant’s rights. When last Thanksgiving came, she didn’t have access to her pots and pans because they were still in the house. When winter came, she didn’t have access to her cold-weather clothes.

Despite receiving cash offers for the 4-acre property, which could potentially be subdivided for two new houses in place of the existing one, the Dormers were unable to sell it successfully while it was occupied by the unwanted tenants. It is the same property that the Village of Southampton had eyed for the site of a sewage treatment plant last year, but that plan fell apart for other reasons — including fervent opposition from neighbors.

The house did not have working heat as it was not intended for winter occupancy, but the Dormers’ attorney advised them they must fix the heat and insulate the windows.

Anita Dormer said the man who went there to fix the heat felt so badly for the children, living in squalor, that he bought 10 electric heaters.

The Dormers’ attorney advised them they must continue to pay the electricity bills or risk derailing the eviction process.

Anita Dormer reported that police were there three months ago and told her there were feces and garbage around the house. She lamented that children were living in those conditions for as long as they had been and that the authorities did not do more for the children’s welfare. The conditions were the same on eviction day last week.

When the father finally showed up to court — he did not show for the first two court dates — he agreed to clean up the property, pay the bills and move out, according to Anita Dormer.

“He showed up in court and tried to say he was dying. He wasn’t. They found out all this was a lie,” she said.

She explained that while it was true he had cancer, it was treatable, not terminal.

The agreed upon move-out date was August 1. They didn’t move out.

Anita Dormer said they called and asked for money before leaving.

“We just blocked them. We’re like, this is crazy,” she recalled.

She said she learned from Child Protective Services, which visited the house frequently but was never granted access, that with days to go before the eviction scheduled for October 10, the family left. When the occupants vacated, they left the doors open, and the television and lights on.

“We asked the sheriff if we could at least go shut the door so that people wouldn’t come in and take our things, because that’s our house and our clothing and our beds and our blankets and all kinds of things,” Anita Dormer said. “And we were told that if we step foot on that property, that it would stop the eviction, and they could move right back in.”

The Dormers were also advised that they could not remove the former occupants’ possessions themselves. They needed to hire a team to enter the house, using hazmat suits, to remove the possessions and put them by the curb.

Arnold Dormer said last Thursday that the sheriffs ultimately determined that the possessions, based on the state they were in, could be deemed trash.

Anita Dormer said they have spent more than $20,000 due to the occupants refusing to leave and trashing the house, and now the house may be condemned. She called their experience “a failure of a system that doesn’t know what to do with a situation like this.” She called for legal changes and a more aggressive approach by police and Child Protective Services.

You May Also Like:

REI Hosts Fall Luncheon November 19: Communities Before and After Multifamily Development — Exploring Empirical Data

The Real Estate Institute at Stony Brook University College of Business will explore the evolving landscape of solutions to Long Island’s housing crisis during its fall luncheon, titled, “Communities Before and After Multifamily Development — Exploring Empirical Data.” Taking place on November 19 at Heritage Club at Bethpage, in Farmingdale, the event aims to bring together industry experts and thought leaders to share their perspectives on the future of multifamily development on Long Island and bring insight into the intricacies of Long Island’s success stories with multifamily development. “As housing paradigms shift, this event will dissect the emerging trends, technological ... 28 Oct 2024 by Staff Writer

Southampton Village Gambrel With Pool, Tennis Sells for $13.3 million

A gambrel-style residence in the Southampton Village estate section recently sold for $13.28 million. At ... 22 Oct 2024 by Staff Writer

East Hampton Home of Former WABC Reporter Doug Johnson and Late Lobbyist Liz Robbins Is for Sale

Former WABC Eyewitness News reporter Doug Johnson has put his East Hampton home on the ... by Staff Writer

East Hampton Village Residence Sells for $5 Million

An East Hampton Village residence named the “Seaglass House” that recently went through a gut ... 14 Oct 2024 by Staff Writer

Sagaponack, Water Mill Have Two of the Top Three Most Expensive Zip Codes in the U.S.

Sagaponack’s 11962 and Water Mill’s 11976 are the No. 2 and No. 3 most expensive ... by Staff Writer

Agency News: Sierra Hope Joins Town & Country

Sierra Hope, who began her career in the real estate industry in 2015, has joined ... by Staff Writer

New Build Overlooking Noyac Golf Club Sells for $5.3 Million

A new build in Sag Harbor with views of the Noyac Golf Club and deeded ... 10 Oct 2024 by Staff Writer

Fed Rate Cut May Bolster Real Estate Market

The Federal Reserve’s move last week that lowered interest rates by 50 basis points was ... 3 Oct 2024 by Joseph Finora

New Build With Interior Design by James Michael Howard Enters Contract in East Hampton

A new build in East Hampton Village, with interior design by James Michael Howard, has ... 1 Oct 2024 by Staff Writer

Agency News: Industry Veteran Jan Jaeger Joins Christie’s International Real Estate Group

Christie’s International Real Estate Group, the exclusive affiliate of Christie’s International Real Estate serving New ... 26 Sep 2024 by Staff Writer