Beach Bakery Grand Cafe In Westhampton Beach Switches Hands, As Longtime Owner Bids Farewell - 27 East

Real Estate News

Real Estate News / 1391165

Beach Bakery Grand Cafe In Westhampton Beach Switches Hands, As Longtime Owner Bids Farewell

icon 4 Photos

Hampton Bays Superintendent Lars Clemensen talks about the new speed zone display units that were installed on Ponquogue Avenue in Hampton Bays. AMANDA BERNOCCO

Hampton Bays Superintendent Lars Clemensen talks about the new speed zone display units that were installed on Ponquogue Avenue in Hampton Bays. AMANDA BERNOCCO

Simon Jorna sampling a flavor of gelato. ANISAH ABDULLAH

Simon Jorna sampling a flavor of gelato. ANISAH ABDULLAH

Patricia Tuzzolo, president of the East Quogue Board of Education, during a special meeting on Tuesday afternoon. AMANDA BERNOCCO

Patricia Tuzzolo, president of the East Quogue Board of Education, during a special meeting on Tuesday afternoon. AMANDA BERNOCCO

author on Jul 1, 2019

Concerns about the future of the Beach Bakery Grand Cafe, which has been on the market for three years and has been described by many in the village as the “heart of Westhampton Beach,” can now be quelled: The bakery has a new owner, but its character and products will remain the same.

Simon Jorna, one of the most recognizable faces in Westhampton Beach, is saying goodbye to the village and the Main Street business he ran and grew for three decades. He sold the bakery on April 26 to Rashid Sulehri, a Lake Grove resident who also owns Montauk Bake Shoppe and Villa Italian Specialties, a deli in East Hampton.

“I never expected to own it for so long. I just bought a small, little bakery,” said Mr. Jorna, who plans to leave the village by September. “I just stayed and stayed, made it bigger and bigger. It became more popular, and I hear every day that we are the center of Westhampton Beach.”

A representative for Mr. Sulehri, Sammy Awan, was at the bakery last Thursday, June 27. He said that Mr. Sulehri decided to buy the Beach Bakery because it is similar in nature to his two other locations and has comparable sales.

“Simon worked very hard for 30 years, and it’s hard to fill his shoes, but with [Mr. Sulehri’s] experience, he’s very, very confident,” Mr. Awan said, noting that the new owner has 20 years of experience in the food industry and has previously owned several fast-food franchises.

Mr. Sulehri wants to increase the efficiency of the management of the bakery to shorten wait times during busy hours and focus more on catering, while keeping products and ingredients the same, Mr. Awan said.

“Things will change—they always do. And that’s a good thing,” Mr. Jorna said. “The problem is, if I own it, things will not change anymore, and that will be the bad thing.”

Mr. Jorna would not disclose the selling price of the business and shared only that it was originally listed at $5.6 million, but that he lowered the price due to a lack of interested buyers.

The Beach Bakery is a kosher, vegetarian cafe and restaurant in the center of Main Street that sells fresh bread, pastries and gelato in the front bakery area, and meals for lunch and dinner in the rear restaurant, where people order at the counter and wait for a buzzer to ring.

It has become a popular destination spot for both year-round residents and summer visitors alike. Aside from the food, people go there to enjoy live music on weekend evenings and to play board games, but also to study, conduct business meetings and get tutoring lessons.

Quogue residents Suri Harris and Alfred Schreiber considered the Beach Bakery their “go-to spot” for 20 years. While waiting for their lunch to be prepared, the couple said that they visit the bakery at least once a week and has made it part of their Saturday night routine—eat dinner nearby and then visit the bakery for dessert.

“I just couldn’t imagine being out here without this place. It’s just interesting how a place of business can become so much a part of your experience,” Mr. Schreiber said. “The whole experience is special and unique, and we’re just really hoping—and I think everybody in the community is—that it will stay like that.”

By the end of summer, Mr. Jorna, 54, will embark on his retirement vacation plans with his husband, Da Zhi, to Miami and Berlin, where he has a house, and later to countries in Asia and South America.

On Thursday, he sold his other Main Street property, the former Books & Books property at 128 Main Street, to the current owners of the former Magic’s Pub at 115 Main Street, Lance Farlow and his two partners under a limited liability company. He also recently sold two residences he owned in Westhampton Beach and Flanders.

Although he is no longer the owner and officially retired two weeks ago, customers can still find him behind the pastry cases and making repairs throughout the cafe. He said he was always a hands-on owner who preferred to be on the floor with other employees and socializing with guests.

Word of him selling the bakery quickly spread among locals who have frequented the bakery for years. He said that customers have been approaching him every day recently to bid him a fond farewell.

Debra Martin, a longtime village resident, came up to Mr. Jorna on her way out of the bakery last Thursday.

“He is wonderful. This man has done so much for so many people, you have no idea,” Ms. Martin said. “He never says anything about what he does for everybody. It’s been an honor for me to know him.”

Mr. Jorna is originally from the Netherlands and has lived on the East End for 33 years. His first American job was at Montauk Bake Shoppe, where he was promoted to manager within his second year. He left that job after two years and partnered with his friend Hubert Venneman to own and operate the Beach Bakery in 1988. He bought out his partner’s share for full ownership two years later.

The bakery underwent a $2 million renovation in 2013 that doubled the square footage and nearly tripled the seating capacity to 32 seats. In hindsight, Mr. Jorna said he should not have done the renovation, because it ultimately cost him much more than he would have liked.

The former bakery owner was also heavily involved in the development of the village. He became a familiar face at Village Board meetings and was never afraid to voice his opinion. Mr. Jorna also sat on the board of directors for the Greater Westhampton Chamber of Commerce as of last year, and was a member for 29 years before that.

“I’m not sad to leave. I’m excited to leave—I’m excited to let it go,” Mr. Jorna said. “But that’s the one thing I’ll actually miss most: the hugs from the customers.”

You May Also Like:

Real Estate Showings Head Online as Industry is Reclassified Essential

When New York Governor Andrew Cuomo shuttered all nonessential businesses on March 22, the Hamptons ... 7 Apr 2020 by Alec Giufurta

Real Estate Industry Faces A New Reality

The current health crisis and the ensuing economic fallout have shaken every industry, and the ... 25 Mar 2020 by Gavin Menu

Sandcastle In Bridgehampton Available To Rent … For The Right Price

Want to ride out the coronavirus pandemic in the Hamptons, and have an extra $2 ... 24 Mar 2020 by Bill Sutton

Michael Davis-Designed Sagaponack Home Sells For $16.5M

A new home in Sagaponack Village by Michael Davis Design & Construction has sold for ... 15 Mar 2020 by Staff Writer

House: Greenlawns on the Rock

The “Greenlawns” may now be known as a popular fishing hotspot along the west side ... by Michelle Trauring

COVID-19 Concerns Stir Demand For Hamptons Home Rentals

In response to the spread of COVID-19 and a growing hesitancy to travel, there has ... 13 Mar 2020 by Brendan J. O’Reilly

Late Choreographer Jerome Robbins’s Water Mill Beach House Sells For $12.5M

The Water Mill beach house that belonged to the late choreographer Jerome Robbins has sold ... by Staff Writer

Tech Attorney’s Ox Pasture Road Estate Fetches $10.23M

In Southampton Village’s estate section, a French modern home at 355 Ox Pasture Road recently ... by Staff Writer

Chateau In Murray Compound Sells For $35 Million

A Southampton Village estate in the Murray compound has sold for $35 million, less than half its original asking price. At 317 Murray Place, the chateau-style residence elevated on 300 steel pilings sits on 2.8 acres with more than 200 feet of oceanfront. The 9,200-square-foot house has French country imported stone archways throughout, four imported Old World hearths, and custom imported wood from a French chateau seen in the exposed wooden beams and hardwood floors. There are four bedrooms and 5.5 bathrooms, with an elevator serving three levels, so it’s effortless to visit the wine cellar. Among the living spaces ... 10 Mar 2020 by Staff Writer

Sagaponack Mansion Goes For $10.86 Million In Foreclosure Sale

Years in the making, the foreclosure sale of a developed property in Sagaponack Village — complete with a home, pool, pool house and tennis court — has finally come to pass. According to The Real Estate Report Inc., 219 Sagaponack Main Street has been sold to a limited liability company for $10.86 million. The property, also known as 219 Sagg Main Street, was the subject of a foreclosure auction scheduled to take place on the steps of Southampton Town Hall in 2012. It was to be the second foreclosure in the history of the Village of Sagaponack, which incorporated in ... 6 Mar 2020 by Staff Writer

Welcome to our new website!

To see what’s new, click “Start the Tour” to take a tour.

We welcome your feedback. Please click the
“contact/advertise” link in the menu bar to email us.

Start the Tour
Landscape view not supported