Big Basements Require Major Water Removal - 27 East

Real Estate News

Real Estate News / 1413748

Big Basements Require Major Water Removal

icon 4 Photos

author on Aug 11, 2014

The construction of some very large residences in the last couple of years has required extensive dewatering of the land—actually removing the water from the underground water table—to make way for deep, sprawling basements beneath.

The process is not new, though it has rarely been done for residential structures, anywhere, until recently.

On most of the South Fork the water table is 30 to 40 feet below the surface or deeper. In some areas, though, it can be as little as a few feet down to hit water, especially nearer the ocean, where saltwater also intrudes and pushes the water table higher—the freshwater table floating above the more dense saltwater layer.

For most of the 20th century, homes built in such areas were simple beach cottages, usually without foundations, never mind basements. But in the last few years, a new trend in house design has arisen: cavernous underground “lower levels” that often rival, equal or even exceed the total square footage of the visible house itself. These levels can require foundations that extend as much as 20 feet below the surface, and well below where the ground is saturated with water.

So, to make way for what will, by necessity, be submerged foundations, contractors must remove the water from the ground beneath the house, and keep it at bay while the concrete foundation is formed.

“It’s a relatively simple idea, but many times can be hard to implement,” said engineer Paul Grosser, whose firm, P.W. Grosser Consultants, has overseen dewatering projects locally. “It’s a little more art than science sometimes.”

The complicating factors can be many. First, the water, tens of millions of gallons worth, must be drawn from the ground. But because the water table is essentially an underground lake, more will want to rush in to take the place of whatever is removed. Thus, the water removal must be constant until the foundation is completed and can hold up to being inundated.

Also, all that water pumped out of the ground must be put someplace, and environmental controls will rarely allow it to just be spit out somewhere else.

Water removal may be the easiest step. Most projects employ small wells, about 2 inches in diameter and extending slightly deeper than bottom of the foundation. The well heads are placed every 5 feet or so and are connected to a single pipe that directs the water away.

A large system can withdraw hundreds of thousands of gallons a day. In a proposal for a new mansion in Sagaponack recently, engineers said they planned to pull 850,000 gallons a day out of the ground, for two months.

As the water is pumped, the water table near the well-point system lowers gradually. The draw-down creates a basin in the water table—the surrounding water table remains at its natural level but dips downward toward the well pumps as it reaches the edge of the well system’s suction effect, which engineers call the “depression pit.” If the suction of the wells were to stop, the depression pit would immediately begin leveling off as the water table tried to level itself off.

“The biggest issue is keeping it dry while everything is going on,” said Southampton Village Engineer Aldo Andrioli. “It’s a hole, that water wants to pour in. If there’s a power shortage, it will start coming back in very quickly.”

The work can take many weeks and cost somewhere well into six figures, depending on the project. The deep hole must be dug, the foundation laid out in forms and then filled with concrete. Once poured, the foundation can take weeks to cure and harden to watertightness.

In the upcoming Sagaponack project the engineers have said they will have to keep pumping for 60 days while the more than 12,000-square-foot foundation is created. Over that period, the well system will have drawn out more than 51 million gallons of water, enough to fill more than 1,500 standard swimming pools.

All that water has to be put somewhere. Mr. Grosser said that the easiest solution is to simply discharge it into a nearby water body, if one exists. In the case of Sagaponack, one can gaze over the dunes at the Atlantic, where tens of millions gallons of fresh water would be absorbed easily. But the State Department of Environmental Conservation has not typically allowed that easy out, or any other out that would carry the water off the property.

So engineers typically have to put the water back into the ground, within the boundaries of the lot. On two other projects in Sagaponack in the last year, one on Gibson Lane the other on Bridge Lane, this was achieved by creating a large recharging area, essentially a sump, into which the water was pumped and allowed to simply percolate back into the ground not very far, but just far enough, from where it was removed. The trick is to make the recharge area large enough so that the discharge of the dewatering pumps does not overwhelm the rate at which the water was filtering back into the ground, yet not so large that the recharge starts flowing back into the depression pit.

“You have to get an equilibrium,” Mr. Grosser said.

Engineers have said the risks of negative impacts from dewatering are minor.

At the project on Gibson Lane, torrential rains from Hurricane Arthur on July 4 overfilled the property’s recharge basin and caused part of its retaining wall to collapse, sending a flood of water cascading out across the property and across an adjacent roadway.

Sagaponack Village Engineer Drew Bennett said recently that there are minor concerns about causing shortages of water in a neighboring property’s well if the well is very close to the property being dewatered and sufficiently shallow that the depression pit could draw it dry. He suggested that project managers should make sure that neighbors are connected to Suffolk County Water Authority mains.

Southampton Town Environmental Analyst Marty Shea said that the greater concern of such projects may fall to the homeowner, for the soundness of their home’s foundation. In any place that is potentially subject to flooding, as from a hurricane’s storm surge, or simply even prone to rising water tables during intense rainfall, Mr. Shea said he would be concerned about the foundation’s structural integrity.

“What happens in a severe storm event, whether it’s intense rainfall or a coastal storm, the groundwater table rises and falls, and can crack a structure that is built in groundwater,” Mr. Shea said. “I’m sure the engineers are going to town designing these foundations ... but I never recommend building foundations into groundwater, even if there are no FEMA restrictions.”

Beyond such concerns, though, engineers say the dewatering itself is a drop in, or from, the bucket.

“It’s all temporary—when it’s done, you stop,” Mr. Grosser said, “and it will go back to the way it was before in a hurry.”

You May Also Like:

Hamptons Real Estate Pros Identify Changing Buyer Priorities

Not only have pandemic shutdowns and social distancing measures changed how the real estate business ... 19 Apr 2021 by Brendan J. O’Reilly

Norman Jaffe-Designed Contemporary Fronting Sams Creeks Sells For Nearly $10 Million

A Bridgehampton residence that the late renowned architect Norman Jaffe designed and once called home ... 17 Apr 2021 by Staff Writer

Fordune Villa Sells For $9.45 Million

A 12,000-square-foot villa on 2.5 acres that had belonged to Henry Ford II’s former 250-acre ... 13 Apr 2021 by Staff Writer

Number Of New Signed Contracts For Hamptons Single-Family Homes Up 263 Percent In March

Signed contracts for single-family homes in the Hamptons dwindled in March 2020 to just 48 as the COVID-19 pandemic emerged in New York State and shutdowns began, but one year later sales have not only bounced back, they have exceeded prepandemic numbers. The number of newly inked deals was up 263 percent in March, year-over year, to 174, according to The Elliman Report. The price point that showed the most improvement was between $5 million and $9.99 million, where sales shot up 600 percent from four to 28. The busiest segment of the market was between $1 million and $1.99 ... by Brendan J. O’Reilly

Fronting Kellis Pond, 11.5 Acres Sells For $18 Million

The 11.5-acre property at 9 Morgan Hill Way in Bridgehampton has 770 feet of frontage on Kellis Pond on its west side and a preserved farm field to its south — and it recently sold for $18 million. According to The Real Estate Report Inc., 9 Morgan Hill Way last changed hands in July 2018 for $14.95 million with a residence standing on it, but this time around, the property is vacant. A wetlands permit from November 2018 reveals that the then-owner, T Bridge Farm LLC, received permission to demolish the two-story dwelling, including the indoor pool and garage. However, ... 12 Apr 2021 by Staff Writer

Meadow Lane Property Sells For $20 Million Months After Selling For $16 Million

In October of last year, a Southampton Village oceanfront property at 1384 Meadow Lane changed hands for $16 million, and just last month, it traded again, this time for an even $20 million — a 25 percent increase in less than six months. The 3-acre property with 150 feet of shoreline to the south and views of Shinnecock Bay to the north was clearly purchased for the land when it found a buyer last year. The existing contemporary residence had just three bedrooms and three bathrooms, and the listing pitched the site as a redevelopment opportunity “with ample room for ... by Staff Writer

Veteran Can’t Move Into Home Meant For Him As Nonpaying Tenant Cites Eviction Moratorium

For the past 10 months, veteran Louis DiPasquale III should have been living in a ... 6 Apr 2021 by Brendan J. O'Reilly

New Modern Home In Amagansett Dunes Sells For $11 Million

A new Amagansett modern south of Montauk Highway with a waterview roof deck and deeded ... by Staff Writer

New Sagaponack Compound Sells For $7.73 Million

A newly built modern compound in Sagaponack Village on an ocean access road has sold ... by Staff Writer

Meadow Lane Estate Asking $37 Million Enters Contract

After just a few short months on the market, an oceanfront Southampton Village residence at ... by Staff Writer
logo

Welcome to our new website!

To see what’s new, click “Start the Tour” to take a tour.

We welcome your feedback. Please click the
“contact/advertise” link in the menu bar to email us.

Start the Tour
Landscape view not supported
Send this to a friend