Judge Dismisses 'Truck Beach' Lawsuit, Denies Amagansett Homeowners' Claims Of Ownership - 27 East

Real Estate News

Real Estate News / 1404635

Judge Dismisses ‘Truck Beach’ Lawsuit, Denies Amagansett Homeowners’ Claims Of Ownership

icon 3 Photos

author on Nov 14, 2016

A state court judge issued a resounding dismissal of claims by more than 100 Amagansett property owners that they are the rightful owners of some 5,500 feet of ocean beach on Napeague, and can restrict access by 4x4 vehicles if they see fit.

The judge also threw out claims by the property owners that the use of the beaches in front of their homes, or hotel in the case of one plaintiff, is an unreasonable nuisance that the town should not allow.

Supreme Court Justice Ralph T. Gazillo, said in his decision that the case presented by attorneys for a group of homeowners associations in eastern Amagansett and Napeague failed to provide convincing proof that the chain of title presented by the homeowners, dating back to the sale of the several large swaths of Napeague to developer Arthur Benson by the East Hampton Town Trustees in the late 1800s, includes the beachfront and would allow the new owners to restrict public usage.

“The undersigned is not at all persuaded that the plaintiffs have established their ownership of the beach,” Judge Gazillo wrote in his 40-page decision. “Taken one step further, the absence of ownership severely undermines the support for the balance of their ‘nuisance’ claims. Even if … that were not the case and ownership had been demonstrated to the law and the court’s satisfaction, however, the court is also unpersuaded that those claims have been sufficiently proven and would otherwise survive objective scrutiny.”

The homeowners are expected to appeal Judge Gazillo’s decision, but for the time being, town officials are celebrating.

“This is really good news,” said East Hampton Town Supervisor Larry Cantwell on Monday. “I’m really excited about this. The court has solidly rejected the plaintiffs’ arguments, in every case. It’s a very strong decision.”

We think it is fantastic that the court saw the facts as we did and backed up what we believed to be true all along, and that the use of the beach doesn't rise to the level of a nuisance by any means," said Tim Taylor, president of the 4x4 advocates group Citizens for Access Rights. "Hopefully, the plaintiffs and homeowners will not continue to waste taxpayers' money. The facts aren't going to change."

The homeowners, and White Sands Motel owner Bernard Kiembock, have argued, since filing the first of two parallel lawsuits in 2009, that the parcels of land that eventually became their subdivisions included the ribbons of sand along the shoreline and that the titles to that land had been transferred with each subsequent division and resale of the original parcels.

They had claimed ownership to about 4,000 linear feet of beach between Napeague Lane and the boundary of Napeague State Park, an area commonly referred to as “Truck Beach” for the lineup of vehicles that park there on summer weekends. The second lawsuit, filed by the owners of the White Sands Motel and merged with the Amagansett homeowners’ lawsuit, claims ownership of another approximately 1,500 linear feet east of the state park, which was also part of the original Benson deed. Both parties sought to block the town from allowing the use of the beach by 4x4 vehicles.

Judge Gazillo was at times highly critical of the plaintiffs case and, in particular, the expert witnesses they called on to support their claims during the 5-day trial in June.

The judge, in somewhat odd form, leveled direct criticisms of many of the witnesses who testified at the trial, painting some of the plaintiffs themselves who took the witness stand in September as “evasive” and “dogmatic” and some of the testimony as “confusing, confounding, contradictory … and too slender a reed to strengthen the persuasiveness of the plaintiffs’ arguments,” he wrote. The judge even seemed to ridicule one of the plaintiff’s witnesses, engineer Charles Voorhis, for his confusion over tide cycles, which he said wholly discounted his testimony about the physical impacts of vehicles driving on the beach.

He also cast aside claims of particular impacts caused by the use of the beach by vehicles. He noted that there is no evidence of any unusual illnesses or injuries suffered along that particular stretch of beach and dismissed the claim by Mr. Kiembock that vehicles are a nuisance to his business by noting the motel owner’s own subsequent admission that his motel rarely has vacancies.

One of the plaintiffs is Cindy Crain, who formed a citizens group dubbed SAFE that collected signatures opposing the use of the beach by 4x4s. She said on Monday that the group is disappointed in the ruling, which she called “flawed,” but is confident that she and her fellow plaintiffs would ultimately prevail.

“On behalf of the thousands of East Hampton families who support SAFE’s goals to eliminate beach driving on densely crowded beaches … we will continue to work diligently,” Ms. Crain said in a statement.

In response to the lawsuit, the town started condemnation proceedings to force the sale of the beachfront if it were found by the courts to be owned privately, a costly process that will now be put on the shelf to await any appeals that may come.

At the conclusion of the trial, Judge Gazillo, who is retiring at the end of the year, appealed to the attorneys for both sides to find a settlement solution to avoid years of appeals. In his ruling, he reiterated his pleading as a coda to his career.

“These cases have already assumed a life of their own and have the potential to outlive some of the participants,” he wrote. “Sadly, even after this opinion is issued, after the years of litigation, all of the efforts of a collection of very fine, respected, and capable trial attorneys, as well as all of my efforts and those of all the judges assigned to this case before me, nothing has resolved these controversies. It was and remains my earnest hope, however that the parties will resolve their differences, avoid further litigation and move forward. Life is too short.”


You May Also Like:

Turn Of The Century Further Lane Residence Fetches $11 Million

A 2.4-acre East Hampton compound featuring a renovated turn of the 20th century home recently ... 10 Aug 2020 by Staff Writer

Attorney General Announces $10 Million In Housing Counseling Funds To Stave Off Foreclosure

New York State’s Homeowner Protection Program, or HOPP, now has $10 million in grant funding available for housing counseling and legal services to help protect homeowners from foreclosure in the COVID-19 pandemic. Attorney General Letitia James said in a statement Friday that HOPP connects homeowners to free, qualified mortgage-assistance relief services across New York. Ms. James noted that the Federal Housing Finance Agency reported that 170,000 homeowners asked for mortgage forbearance in the first quarter of 2020 compared to 7,000 requests in the fourth quarter of 2019. The funding supports a network of more than 80 housing counselors and legal ... 3 Aug 2020 by Staff Writer

State Legislature Passes Bill To Deter Discrimination Among Real Estate Agents

The New York State Legislature has passed legislation protecting state residents from discrimination by real estate agents, and now the bill heads to Governor Andrew Cuomo’s desk to be signed into law. Assemblyman Fred W. Thiele Jr. of Sag Harbor said in a statement this week that the bill is designed to help end discriminatory practices in the real estate industry that disproportionately affect minority homebuyers. The legislation makes clear that real estate brokers and salespersons may be fined and their licenses suspended or revoked for subjecting prospective homebuyers to discriminatory practices. Mr. Thiele’s office noted in press release that ... by Staff Writer

Rachael Ray, John Cusimano Sell Southampton Home And Land

Quick-and-easy-cooking television personality Rachael Ray and her husband, attorney and musician John Cusimano, have sold ... 31 Jul 2020 by Staff Writer

Parking Variance Request Ignites Debates Over Residential-To-Office Conversions In Sag Harbor

A request for a parking variance to convert a third-floor Main Street apartment into office ... 28 Jul 2020 by Brendan J. OReilly

Sag Harbor Architectural Review Board Sends ‘Imposing’ Madison Street Proposal Back To The Drawing Board

The Sag Harbor Village Board of Historic Preservation and Architectural Review sent plans for a ... 27 Jul 2020 by Brendan J. OReilly

Manhattan Broker Lisa Maysonet Now Working In The Hamptons

Lisa Maysonet, a top Manhattan real estate broker with Sotheby’s International Realty, is now working ... 25 Jul 2020 by Staff Writer

Officials: Updated Southampton Housing Plan Will Go Beyond Affordable Housing

Southampton Town’s updated housing plan will go beyond addressing the need for affordable housing and ... 24 Jul 2020 by Brendan J. OReilly

Second-Quarter Hamptons Home Sales Dip 13 Percent

Amid the height of the coronavirus pandemic in New York and the state mandates that ... by Brendan J. OReilly

Community Preservation Fund Revenue Up 39 Percent In First Half Of 2020

The Peconic Bay Region Community Preservation Fund collected 39 percent more revenue in the first ... 21 Jul 2020 by Staff Writer

Welcome to our new website!

To see what’s new, click “Start the Tour” to take a tour.

We welcome your feedback. Please click the
“contact/advertise” link in the menu bar to email us.

Start the Tour
Landscape view not supported