National Association of Realtors Settlement Will Reverberate Throughout Real Estate Industry - 27 East

Real Estate News

Real Estate News / 2240123

National Association of Realtors Settlement Will Reverberate Throughout Real Estate Industry

icon 1 Photo
A National Association of Realtors court settlement will affect real estate commissions industry-wide. JEFFREY CZUM

A National Association of Realtors court settlement will affect real estate commissions industry-wide. JEFFREY CZUM

Joseph Finora on Mar 19, 2024

New rules — and a monster settlement — could start saving homebuyers and sellers thousands of dollars in lower commissions while increasing competition among brokers as soon as this summer.

While the changes work their way across the industry, the National Association of Realtors, the country’s largest trade group, has agreed to a $1.8 billion fine over four years to settle charges that the industry conspired to keep agent commissions among the world’s highest by requiring sellers to pay the selling and purchasing agent commissions, which nationally often was 5 to 6 percent. Some estimates call for an annual consumer savings of $20 billion to $50 billion due to the upcoming changes as the anti-trust case has the potential to change the way homes have been sold for generations. The early forecast is that these adjustments will provide significant changes in how real estate brokers are compensated, notably with lower commissions.

In October, a federal jury ruled that NAR had conspired to artificially inflate commissions. The ruling originated with a 2019 anti-trust suit brought by a group of Missouri homesellers arguing the industrywide practice violated anti-trust laws. Consequently, buyer brokers will no longer be able to select the listings they show clients based on compensation offers made via multiple listing services, the platform used by real estate agents and brokers to share information about properties for sale. Should a federal court uphold the settlement, which may take several months, sellers will no longer be required to make a compensation offer before marketing their homes to potential buyers. The agreement provides consumers with greater compensation leverage while resolving claims against NAR and its over 1 million members although the settlement is subject to court approval. The money is to be distributed to some 50 million homesellers nationwide. Those who sold a home within the last five years through a real estate agent may have overpaid broker commission and may be entitled to reimbursement. Home sales in contract should proceed without interruption.

The settlement, which aims to eradicate anti-competitive practices, only resolves claims against NAR, which has also agreed to institute a new MLS rule to prohibit broker-compensation offers on MLS, effectively stopping broker-compensation communication via the MLS. Consumers however, will be able to maintain off-MLS offers by direct negotiation with real estate professionals. These changes may encourage buyers to bypass agents.

Most MLS websites are controlled by local NAR associations. Access is conditioned on real estate agents and brokers following mandatory rules set forth in NAR’s Handbook on Multiple Listing Policy, including the Buyer Broker Commission Rule. While New York agents typically are not NAR members, the ruling is to have ramifications throughout the industry.

“NAR and MLS have settled to cut their losses,” said Judi Desiderio, the president of Town & Country Real Estate in East Hampton. “Sellers have been known to negotiate upfront and at the end of negotiations. This may actually cost buyers more money and impede agents’ ability to sell. The ripples are just beginning to circulate.”

“People are still sorting this out,” said another seasoned Hamptons real estate broker speaking on the condition of anonymity. Representatives from other area brokerages declined to comment for this article.

“This will be a time of adjustment, but the fundamentals will remain. Buyers and sellers will continue to have many choices when deciding to buy or sell a home,” said NAR President Kevin Sears in a statement. “The benefits it will provide to our industry are worth that cost.”

Ultimately, agents may become more transparent with their fee structures and/or devise more creative with compensation models.

“It will take 12 to 36 months until the dust settles on how this shakes out,” said Alan Schnurman, a litigation lawyer with Zalman Schnurman & Miner in New York City and a real estate broker in Bridgehampton. “The winners are the public — those listing and selling homes. Plus, every buyer is a potential future seller of the property.

“The brokerage industry is the true loser,” he continued. “The income of these companies will be reduced substantially. The experienced, longtime brokers who have most of the listings will do fine or even prosper. The newer brokers with few or no listings will be challenged.”

Some estimates call for broker commission to be reduced by 30 percent. It remains to be seen if this will cause a reduction in home prices. Renters are not impacted and will continue to pay commissions.

“It will not affect the amount of real estate bought and sold in upscale markets such as the Hamptons, Aspen, Palm Beach and Manhattan,” Schnurman said. “Buyers in these markets will follow the path to the listing broker. It will take time for the public to become accustomed to this new paradigm.”

You May Also Like:

Emergency Housing Assistance Training Offered for Advocates

Legal Services of Long Island’s Legal Support Center for Advocates presents “Emergency Housing Assistance on Long Island” on Friday, December 6, from 1 to 2 p.m. on Zoom to learn about Department of Social Services services and procedures, as well as resources, when assisting a client in need of emergency housing assistance. Legal Services of Long Island, which has an office on the East End in Riverhead, focuses on the survival needs of people with low incomes and is devoted to preserving housing on Long Island. “Public benefit programs and the preservation of housing are priority areas,” the group’s website ... 3 Dec 2024 by Staff Writer

Historic South Main Street Residence Sells for $10.35 Million

An updated and expanded shingle-style house — the former Foster family homestead — in Southampton ... by Staff Writer

Moving Into the Next Phase of Life: Senior Housing Professionals Guide Late-Life Relocations

For retired people planning their next move, perhaps from a long-held home to senior housing, ... 27 Nov 2024 by Brendan J. O’Reilly

Post-Election, One Reason for Homebuying Hesitancy Removed, But Rates Remain a Concern

Now that the election is over, will local real estate sales increase? There is understandably ... by Joseph Finora

Bates Masi + Architects Wins Project of the Year, Among Other Awards

East Hampton-based architecture and design firm Bates Masi + Architects recently took home multiple awards. ... 25 Nov 2024 by Staff Writer

Despont's Rosewood Farm Estate Sells for $17.8M

The Rosewood Farm Estate in Southampton, which had been owned by architect and designer Thierry ... by Staff Writer

Mediterranean-Style Dune Road Residence Sells for $7.25 Million

An oceanfront Mediterranean-style residence in East Quogue that was listed for $10.4 million back in ... by Staff Writer

Sotheby's and Town & Country Offices Host Coat Drives

Some South Fork real estate offices are serving as drop-off locations for coat donations to assist people in need. Sotheby’s International Realty is hosting a coat drive through the end of the year in partnership with Heart of the Hamptons in Southampton Village and the Sag Harbor Food Pantry. New and gently used winter clothes for all ages can be dropped off at the Sotheby’s offices located at 2446 Main Street, Bridgehampton; 6 Main Street, East Hampton; and 50 Nugent Street, Southampton. Town & Country Real Estate is accepting coats through December 1 at its offices: 46 Main Street, East ... 22 Nov 2024 by Staff Writer

In Sagaponack, 1.7-Acre Property Sells for $7.65 Million

A 1.7-acre Sagaponack property with an existing house but coveted for the land itself recently ... 20 Nov 2024 by Staff Writer

1930 Southampton Village Residence Sells for $6.75M

A south-of-the-highway Southampton Village shingled traditional recently sold for $6.75 million, having found a buyer ... by Staff Writer