North Haven ZBA Rejects Variances For Baum's 'Lighthouse' Rebuild - 27 East

Real Estate News

Real Estate News / 1722947

North Haven ZBA Rejects Variances For Baum’s ‘Lighthouse’ Rebuild

icon 3 Photos
The September 8 North Haven Village Zoning Board of Appeals meeting.

The September 8 North Haven Village Zoning Board of Appeals meeting.

The white arrow points to 59 Mashomack,

The white arrow points to 59 Mashomack, "Lighthouse." Dusenberry house is to the east.

Lighthouse proposal.

Lighthouse proposal.

Peter Boody on Sep 14, 2020

By Peter Boody

In a rare split vote, the North Haven Village Zoning Board of Appeals on September 8 voted 3-2 to reject local businessman Larry Baum’s controversial application for front and side yard variances to allow him to build a new house overlooking wetlands at 59 Mashomack Drive that would have a footprint 225 square feet larger than the house on the site now.

“I’m very disappointed,” Mr. Baum commented during the Zoom session during which the vote was conducted. “I don’t think the asks were that great.”

The North Haven resident, who lives two doors north of the site and testified he plans to move with his family to the new house, said the environmental benefits of the project would have far outweighed the impact of the variances.

In a related development, Mr. Baum on Friday withdrew his application to the North Haven Village Board for permission to build a dock off the property’s bay beach access point, which neighbor Susan Dusenberry and others opposed.

During the hearing on that case, Ms. Dusenberry’s attorney, Dennis Downes, presented a recent survey prepared by Michael Hemmer showing that the depth at the end of the proposed structure would not have met the village’s required 2.5 feet at mean low tide.

Mr. Baum’s own survey, prepared in 2018 by Village Trustee David Saskas, who recused himself from the case, showed adequate depth. The board delayed making a decision in order to conduct its own survey, prepared this summer by Robert Fox, which agreed with the Hemmer survey.

In the zoning case last week, Zoning Board of Appeals chairman Mark Poitras and member Scott Brooks voted against the denial resolution, which found that Mr. Baum had rejected the option of building “a slightly smaller structure needing no variances”; the resolution concluded that any zoning difficulty he faced was self-created. Voting in favor of denying the application were members John Fitzpatrick, Steve Hatfield and Steve Cox.

The board majority also found that the environmental benefits of the project, including a nitrogen-reducing septic system and improved drainage to prevent runoff from reaching nearby wetlands, were now mandated by village code and will be required for any new construction on the site. The existing house has a conventional, passive septic system close to the wetlands side of the property and no rainwater runoff control.

Mr. Baum’s application for variances to build the house, and its proposed dock, touched off an avalanche of emailed letters of opposition earlier this year, citing a threat to the adjacent wetlands.

During a hearing on the dock this spring, Mayor Jeff Sander called the site “a very unique property” because it bends sharply eastward after descending from its street frontage at 59 Mashomack Drive — where Mr. Baum plans to tear down the existing house and build a new structure — to run adjacent to the 60-acre Loveridge Preserve, a marsh and pond system protected by a conservation easement given by the Loveridge family in 1993 to the Peconic Land Trust.

Seemingly cutting off the bay frontage from the upland, the property’s bend puts the proposed dock “in front of the neighbor’s property,” the mayor said, on a now empty beach separating Shelter Island Sound from the Loveridge wetlands. Because of the conflicting survey depths, Mr. Sander called for the village to conduct its own survey, a move that Mr. Baum opposed.

After the results came in, Mr. Baum by email withdrew his dock application without explanation on September 11.

In the zoning case, Mr. Baum’s 404A Bay Partners LLC sought a front-yard setback variance from the required 50 feet to 45.9 feet and three side-yard variances from the required 30 feet at three points 21, 23.4 and 24.8 feet from the east property line with Ms. Dusenberry. The property contains 75,524 square feet or between 1.5 and 2 acres, some of it constrained by the marsh.

The proposed house was to have a footprint covering 2,440 feet; the existing structure, known locally as “the Lighthouse” because of its turret — which dates back to an earlier structure built in the early 1970s — covers 2,215 square feet.

The new structure, as originally proposed, would have required a variance from the village’s “sky plane” rules controlling height. It was redesigned during the application review process to eliminate any height intrusions.

The Zoning Board of Appeals majority found that the front-yard setback request was “de minimis” but called the side-yard variance requests “substantial,” averaging 30 percent of the required distance.

The majority noted that a slightly smaller house could be built on the site that satisfied all zoning requirements but “the applicant refuses to consider” that alternative, saying it would be impractical for him, his wife and four children. The requested variances, therefore, are the result of “a self-created difficulty,” the majority agreed.

You May Also Like:

Community Preservation Fund Revenue Up 46 Percent In First Three Quarters Of 2020

Community Preservation Fund revenue across the East End for the first nine months of 2020 has already surpassed the revenue total for all 12 months of 2019. The CPF, which is funded through a 2 percent tax on real estate transactions in the five East End towns, has collected $84.68 million through September this year, compared to just $58.2 million during the same period a year prior. That’s a 46 percent increase. The office of New York State Assemblyman Fred W. Thiele Jr. reports that the CPF added $12.42 million to its coffers this September. “CPF revenues for September 2020 ... 27 Oct 2020 by Staff Writer

Sag Harbor Architectural Review Board Confronts Conflict Between Preservation, Fire Safety

A request to replace a protected home’s inoperable windows with working replicas sparked a debate ... 26 Oct 2020 by Brendan J. OReilly

Former Manse To Old Whalers’ Church Is On The Market

A historic former manse to Sag Harbor’s iconic Old Whalers’ Church has hit the market. ... by Staff Writer

East Hampton Oceanfront Estate Next To Golf Course Sells For $67 Million

An East Hampton estate that went on the market just before Labor Day for $75 ... 25 Oct 2020 by Staff Writer

Suffolk County Enlists L.I. Housing Partnership, ERASE Racism For Fair Housing Education

Suffolk County is partnering with the Long Island Housing Partnership and ERASE Racism to provide fair housing training, education and outreach services in an effort to combat housing discrimination on Long Island. The two Long Island-based nonprofit organizations will reach out to housing consumers, providers, minorities and protected classes to ensure that rights are being protected and that fair housing laws are being adhered to, according to the county’s Thursday, October 22, announcement of their selection. The initiative is in response to the results of a Newsday investigation into discriminatory practices in real estate sales, such as racial steering — ... 23 Oct 2020 by Staff Writer

New Suffolk County Law Requires Advanced Septic Systems For Newly Built Homes

New houses built in Suffolk County that are not serviced by sewers are now required ... 20 Oct 2020 by Brendan J. OReilly

Rechlers’ New Hampton Boathouses On Shinnecock Canal Offered For Rent

The developers of the long-in-the-making Hampton Boathouses, a 37-unit development on the Shinnecock Canal, are ... by Brendan J. OReilly

East Quogue Oceanfront Compound Listed For $14 Million Enters Contract

An oceanfront residence on Dune Road entered contract this week with a last asking price ... 19 Oct 2020 by Staff Writer

New 10-Acre East Hampton Estate With Indoor Pool Sells For $9.25 Million

A newly built East Hampton estate on the village fringe with both an outdoor and ... 17 Oct 2020 by Staff Writer

EXPRESS SESSIONS: Industry Experts And Officials Talk About Struggles To Offer Affordable Housing In A Changing Environment

The scramble of people fleeing to the East End from New York City and other ... 15 Oct 2020 by Bill Sutton

Welcome to our new website!

To see what’s new, click “Start the Tour” to take a tour.

We welcome your feedback. Please click the
“contact/advertise” link in the menu bar to email us.

Start the Tour
Landscape view not supported