Opponents Question Legality Of Golf Course Proposed For East Quogue Community - 27 East

Real Estate News

Real Estate News / 1397612

Opponents Question Legality Of Golf Course Proposed For East Quogue Community

author on Mar 28, 2018

Opponents of a golf course resort community proposed along Spinney Road in East Quogue are questioning whether the developer has the right to construct the 18-hole golf course under current zoning, as its new application maintains.

Discovery Land Company—the same firm behind the defeated proposal for a development at the same site called “The Hills at Southampton”—is pitching a new plan to the Southampton Town Planning Board that calls for the construction of 118 homes, the same number of units included in the earlier application, along with a private 18-hole golf course on nearly 600 acres. All of the land is in a 5-acre residential zone, the most restrictive in the municipality.

This time, the developer is insisting that it can build its golf course development—called the Lewis Road Planned Residential Development—without securing a change of zone. The company points to a little-used portion of the town code that permits the addition of certain recreational amenities, such as tennis courts, in residential neighborhoods, and argues that a golf course to be used by the development’s residents is a comparable amenity allowed by zoning.

The pre-application also has an alternate plan that calls for 137 units—including some workforce housing—and no golf course. The golf course resort is the preferred option by the developer.

Planning Board Chairman Dennis Finnerty said his board is working to review what some are calling a gray area in the local law. He explained that the law doesn’t specifically state that an 18-hole golf course could be considered a legal accessory use—but it doesn’t appear to prohibit it either.

The law lists some examples, such as tennis courts and swimming pools, but fails to include other amenities, such as bocce courts, which have been built under the same section of the law.

Phil Keith, the Planning Board’s secretary, called the golf course the “principal item of contention” in the application. “The code for these types of projects is a little bit vague and open to some interpretation,” he said. “In other words, they don’t forbid or allow golf courses in the code itself.

“The application has demonstrated that it is an appropriate recreational use to the project,” he continued.

But opponents to the project insist that the golf course cannot be built.

New York State Assemblyman Fred Thiele, who stood with environmentalists who opposed The Hills the last time around, said a golf course cannot be built as part of a subdivision because it is considered “active recreation.”

A planned residential development, or PRD, is a subdivision built under the open space law. Unlike traditional subdivisions, PRDs have open space requirements that are intended to preserve environmentally sensitive land. In the case of the Lewis Road PRD, part of the property falls in the core Pine Barrens, where development is not allowed.

Mr. Thiele—who insisted he was commenting broadly on the law and its intention, not on the project itself—said he has a unique perspective, as he helped write the law in the early 1980s, when he served as the Southampton Town attorney.

Mr. Finnerty added that his board is looking to the current town attorney, James Burke, for legal advice about the open space law.

The law, and its interpretation, is the focus of recent debate as the Planning Board is tasked with approving a project based on its merits, meaning personal opinions of individual board members is not supposed to come into play. When the former application—pitched in the form of a now-outlawed Planned Development District, or PDD—was in front of the Town Board, subjective variables and politics were able to come into play. None of that is allowed at the Planning Board level with the new application.

“It’s a lot more administrative than the PDD process,” Mr. Finnerty said.

Under Discovery Land’s PRD proposal, 35 percent of the property, or about 207 acres, will be developed for the subdivision, with the remaining 65 percent, or about 387 acres, preserved, Mr. Finnerty said. The golf course is included in the 35 percent that can be built on.

The developer is choosing to build 118 single-family homes—instead of the 137 units allowed as of right—to make room to build the golf course. The homes are expected to employ standard septic systems that meet Suffolk County Department of Health Services standards.

Mark Hissey, a Discovery Land vice president, did not respond to requests for comment.

In addition to open space concerns, Robert DeLuca, president of Group for the East End, another longtime opponent of Discovery Land’s plan, said he is concerned that the golf course would be too intense of a use of the property. That is the reason, he said, that such an application should not be entertained at all.

“The issue here is, you can’t have two primary uses, and a golf course isn’t allowed in a residential zone,” Mr. DeLuca said.

Lisa Liquori, an environmental planning consultant and a former East Hampton Town planning director, and Jeff Bragman, an East Hampton attorney who currently serves as an East Hampton Town councilman, submitted letters to the Planning Board. Both Mr. Liquori and Mr. Bragman were hired by Group for the East End to review the application, and both backed Mr. DeLuca’s position.

Mr. Finnerty said his board is reviewing the golf course to see if it qualifies as an accessory use or, instead, a second primary use, as Mr. DeLuca suggested.

He said one aspect appears to be definitive: “It’s a large accessory use.”

Mr. Keith said that he and the other members of the Planning Board are still far from making a decision on the application. The written comment period for the public hearing held last month recently closed, and the Planning Board is reviewing all materials. The board ultimately will compile a report to give back to the developer, possible as early as next month, with recommendations for filing a formal application.

Next, a draft environmental impact statement and a state environmental review would have to be completed. Once they are reviewed and approved, the applicant will move on to a final environmental impact statement.

Along the way there will be several public hearings so the Planning Board can consider public input.

You May Also Like:

One-Time Summer Home Of Mets Owner Steve Cohen Sells For $23 Million In East Hampton

A 2-acre East Hampton estate with a recently expanded 9,795-square-foot residence recently sold for an ... 22 Jun 2021 by Staff Writer

East End Community Housing Fund Bill Heads To Governor’s Desk

State Assemblyman Fred W. Thiele Jr.’s bill to allow the five East End towns to establish Community Housing Funds — like the Community Preservation Fund but for affordable housing initiatives — has passed in both houses of the State Legislature and now goes to Governor Andrew Cuomo for his signature or veto. The legislation would permit towns to use Community Housing Fund proceeds to provide financial assistance to first-time homebuyers for up to 50 percent of the purchase price and would allow towns to underwrite the production of housing for sale or rent. The money could also be used for ... by Brendan J. O’Reilly

The Latch Southampton Village Recognized For Historic Preservation

Vision Long Island recently awarded the Beechwood Organization, one of the biggest builders in New ... by Staff Writer

A Flash In The Pan Or The New Normal?: Hamptons Real Estate Pros Examine Lasting Effects Of The Pandemic

The COVID-19 pandemic has permanently changed the nature of the Hamptons real estate market and ... 16 Jun 2021 by Brendan J. O’Reilly

OLA To Help East End Residents Gain Access To Rental Assistance

Suffolk County has designated OLA of Eastern Long Island to help East End residents gain access to rental and utilities assistance through New York State’s Emergency Rental Assistance Program. The relief is available to low- and moderate-income households at risk of experiencing homelessness or housing instability and includes help for paying back rent, future rent and overdue utility bills. The Emergency Rental Assistance Program also includes a method for the landlord to apply directly. Either way, payments will be sent directly to landlords. “Immigrant community members, especially if they are undocumented, can be extremely vulnerable to exploitation by landlords,” said ... 14 Jun 2021 by Staff Writer

Circa 1860 Sag Harbor Home Renovation And Staging Celebrates House’s History

Where thoughtful renovation and designer staging meet in the hot Sag Harbor housing market, a ... by Brendan J. O’Reilly

Bridgehampton South-Of-The-Highway Traditional Sells For Nearly $10 Million

A traditional gambrel-style residence south of the highway in Bridgehampton recently sold for $9.79 million ... by Staff Writer

Rose Hill Road Estate By Lifton-Green, Raymond Renault Sells For $14.9 Million

A 4.25-acre traditional estate by Lifton-Green Builders and architect Raymond Renault completed in 2019 in ... by Staff Writer

New Signed Home Contracts Up Year-Over-Year For 12th Month In A Row

In May 2020, New York State social distancing mandates prohibited in-person real estate showings with ... 8 Jun 2021 by Staff Writer

New Build In Bridgehampton Designed By Bates Masi Sells With $25 Million Price Tag

A brand new waterfront residence in Bridgehampton by Bates Masi + Architects and Breitenbach Builders ... by Staff Writer

Welcome to our new website!

To see what’s new, click “Start the Tour” to take a tour.

We welcome your feedback. Please click the
“contact/advertise” link in the menu bar to email us.

Start the Tour
Landscape view not supported
Send this to a friend