Parking Variance Request Ignites Debates Over Residential-To-Office Conversions In Sag Harbor - 27 East

Real Estate News

Real Estate News / 1715076

Parking Variance Request Ignites Debates Over Residential-To-Office Conversions In Sag Harbor

icon 1 Photo
The Sag Harbor Village Zoning Board of Appeals July 21 meeting.

The Sag Harbor Village Zoning Board of Appeals July 21 meeting.

Brendan J. OReilly on Jul 28, 2020

A request for a parking variance to convert a third-floor Main Street apartment into office space ignited a debate at the July 21 Sag Harbor Village Zoning Board of Appeals meeting over whether such conversions should ever be allowed in the village.

The applicant wants to move his office staff to 66 Main Street, but the building would need 13 total parking spaces to do so. The existing, grandfathered parking for the property consists of just 10 spaces, so the owner is asking for the Zoning Board of Appeals to waive the last three required spaces.

The question put to the board was that of an area variance — the parking spaces themselves — and not a question of a use variance. Changing the use of the upper floors of Main Street buildings from residential to office is permitted under the law, as of right, with no use variance needed.

Tiffany Scarlato, the attorney representing the owner of 66 Main Street, Barbershop Quartet LLC, told that board that a precedent was set for a parking variance at 96 Main Street, where the owner had two fewer parking spaces than required for a conversion to an office.

Board member Susan Mead said she was sorry she voted to approve the 96 Main Street application.

“I think I did it not understanding that every time we vote, we’re screwed if we see a different situation,” Ms. Mead said, adding that now she believes the parking situation on Main Street is worse and a lack of affordable housing is changing the character of the village.

“We can’t grant everybody parking variances for conversion,” she said.

Board attorney Elizabeth Vail said the board must follow precedent if an application is similar, unless the board can identify factual differences.

Board member Alex Matthiessen asked if the board could look to Sag Harbor’s Local Residential Housing Plan and its recommendations on improving housing.

Ms. Vail said the board members may consider all of the information at their disposal in making a decision, from personal observations to previous decisions. However, she said this matter should be decided on parking and not on affordable housing.

Ms. Vail noted that the Planning Board had sent a letter to the Zoning Board of Appeals asking the ZBA to get behind a plan to ban residential-to-office conversions on Main Street. “That’s a matter for the Village Board of Trustees to legislatively handle in their discretion,” she said.

Ms. Scarlato, a former Sag Harbor Village Board member, pointed out that she helped author the 2007 Local Residential Housing Plan. She also stressed that the Village Board previously eliminated office space on the first floor of buildings as a permitted use. The Village Board decided that second and third floors could be used as apartments or offices interchangeably because a use of first floor was taken away from property owners, she said.

“This is out of this board’s jurisdiction, and that decision has always been made by the Board of Trustees,” Ms. Scarlato said.

She also said $3,500 a month for a Main Street apartment — the going rate — is not affordable under any circumstances.

Ms. Mead suggested waiting for the results of a parking study before the board makes a decision.

Ms. Vail said there is no point in the board delaying a decision to wait for a study or to wait for the Village Board to pass a law, because the decision will be challenged in court and the judge will apply the original law.

“It’s unfortunate, but that’s generally how applications go,” he said.

Chairman Tom McGuire said the village has actually added about 20 parking spaces in the last three months by remarking parking areas.

Mr. Mattheissen and Ms. Mead both voted against granting the variance, but it was approved, 3-2.

You May Also Like:

New Southampton Estate Bought For $7.2 Million

A Southampton estate north of the village recently sold for $7.23 million, according to The ... 22 Sep 2020 by Staff Writer

Bridgehampton Traditional Fetches $11.2 Million

A 10,200-square-foot traditional home in Bridgehampton by three top talents recently sold for $11.2 million. ... 21 Sep 2020 by Staff Writer

Three Big Summer Sales In Water Mill

Three big sales in Water Mill that closed over the summer were reported this week, ... 18 Sep 2020 by Staff Writer

Dawn Watson Joins Enzo Morabito Team

Westhampton Beach resident Dawn Watson, an East End journalist and a former Douglas Elliman senior ... by Staff Writer

Parsonage Lane Estate Sells For $23.5 Million

A 7.37-acre Sagaponack Village estate recently sold for $23.5 million, according to The Real Estate Report Inc., in one of the biggest transactions to happen on the South Fork this year to date. The estate at 232 Parsonage Lane abuts 100 acres of reserves and includes a main residence, a pool house, a carriage house, and a 250-year-old barn. The gated entry opens to a tree-lined driveway leading to a pea-gravel motor court. Michael Davis Construction built the 11,000-square-foot main residence in 2010, with interiors by Alexa Hampton. It has eight bedrooms, eight full bathrooms and three half-baths, and a ... by Staff Writer

Wyandanch Lane Pondfront Sells For Nearly $10 Million

A Southampton Village estate section property that was on the market for the first time ... 14 Sep 2020 by Brendan J. OReilly

Habitat For Humanity Home To Be Built For Springs First Responders

A pair of Springs volunteer first responders will get to stay in the area and ... by Brendan J. OReilly

North Haven ZBA Rejects Variances For Baum’s ‘Lighthouse’ Rebuild

By Peter Boody In a rare split vote, the North Haven Village Zoning Board of ... by Peter Boody

Southampton Town Housing Survey Deadline Extended To September 30

The deadline to answer the Town of Southampton’s online housing survey has been extended 15 days to September 30 to give more people the chance to respond. So far, 2,200 people have participated, according to the town. Southampton Town is working with VHB Engineering Consultants to create a townwide housing plan to update the town’s Comprehensive Plan, and they are seeking community input on housing priorities. “This informational survey will allow everyone who works or lives in the town, and those who did not get a chance to participate in the forums, to share their thoughts and ideas,” Diana Weir, ... 11 Sep 2020 by Staff Writer

Suffolk Federal Offers Virtual First-Time Homebuyer Seminar

Suffolk Federal Credit Union is offering a free virtual first-time homebuyer seminar this month, in both English and Spanish, as an alternative to traditional on-site workshops. The English-language seminar will take place on Tuesday, September 22, and the Spanish-language version will follow on Wednesday, September 23. The start time both days is 6 p.m. and the seminar is an hour long. The seminar is designed to prepare prospective homebuyers to manage the process with confidence, providing an abundance of information, focused on minimizing stress, according to Suffolk Federal. “By adapting to a virtual delivery, we are able to support our ... by Brendan J. OReilly

Welcome to our new website!

To see what’s new, click “Start the Tour” to take a tour.

We welcome your feedback. Please click the
“contact/advertise” link in the menu bar to email us.

Start the Tour
Landscape view not supported