Planned Southampton Village Courtyard Demolition Under Fire - 27 East

Real Estate News

Real Estate News / 1396187

Planned Southampton Village Courtyard Demolition Under Fire

icon 1 Photo
Coconut healthy truffles JANEEN A. SARLIN

Coconut healthy truffles JANEEN A. SARLIN

author on Jul 31, 2018

Susan Madonia has operated her family-owned antique store in Southampton Village for more than 30 years. Next door to Ann Madonia Antiques is a proposed redevelopment project that if approved would see a retail courtyard along Jobs Lane demolished to make way for a pair of two-story commercial buildings that Ms. Madonia said threatens her business.

Ms. Madonia teared up Monday night after the Southampton Village Planning Board would not allow her to submit a letter expressing her concerns at a public work session Monday night, July 30. Although a continuation of the public hearing for East End Holdings LLC’s proposed lot line modification and site plan was on the agenda, because the meeting was a work session, public comments were not accepted, said Village Attorney Elbert W. Robinson. Mr. Robinson added that outbursts from the audience in a public meeting can distract from the board’s, albeit public, debate.

“This plan will impact the neighbors and businesses on Jobs Lane,” Ms. Madonia told board members during the work session. Based on the current site plans, the proposed location of the three new storefronts—with lesser setbacks from Jobs Lane—will require Ms. Madonia to relocate her store’s electrical service system, “at great expense.”

The height of the proposed buildings will block 14 existing windows. The storage of the required mechanical equipment will be on the shared lot line adjacent to Ms. Madonia’s quiet rear garden.

She is calling for additional time to hire an engineer to assess the potential for damage the proposed construction could have on her property—as a foundation is planned to be dug along the shared lot line. According to the site plan, the foundation of Ann Madonia Antiques is listed as “unknown,” which Ms. Madonia said in her letter indicates that inadequate consideration to neighbors has been given.

Other concerned voices from the audience included Dion Lowery of North Sea. “This may sound romantic, but the current courtyard is beautiful, and I am not impressed with what’s going to become of it,” Mr. Lowery said of the proposed storefronts’ flat facade. “We have a beautiful community and we want to keep it that way.”

Regina Greeven, who was in attendance with her husband Rainer Greeven, chairman of the Southampton Association, echoed Mr. Lowery. “Sure, that’s what we need—more empty storefronts and no fountain to enjoy,” Ms. Greevan muttered walking out the door.

The village did accept a letter from the association before the meeting Monday, which called for upgrades that are “at scale and density consistent with existing development,” citing village code. The letter suggested a more modest redevelopment plan, including a small pedestrian walkway that “the character of the neighborhood might be better preserved.”

The public hearing will continue at 5:30 p.m. on Monday, August 6, at Village Hall.

You May Also Like:

Southampton Estate On Meadow Lane Sells For $41 Million

A Southampton Village estate sold at the end of January for $40.91 million — a ... 21 Feb 2020 by Brendan J. OReilly

Bill Proposed To Exempt Summer Rentals From New York State Housing Law

The New York State Legislature’s monumental housing reform enacted last year cast a wider net than planned — and Hamptons summer rentals were caught in it. A provision in the Housing Stability and Tenant Protection Act of 2019, an omnibus bill that comprises many measures pertaining to the landlord-tenant relationship, prohibits landlords from collecting an advance or security deposit in excess of the equivalent of one month’s rent. It had been common practice on the South Fork for homeowners to collect payment for an entire season upfront when renting out their houses for the summer. That’s now illegal. However, Assemblyman ... by Brendan J. OReilly

Airbnb And Other Short-Term Rental Platforms Shake Up Hamptons Market

Phil Keith and his partner, Laura Lyons, are what Airbnb calls “superhosts.” With a near-perfect ... 19 Feb 2020 by Michelle Trauring

Daniel Gale Sotheby’s International Realty Launches DGNY Commercial

Daniel Gale Sotheby’s International Realty, the Cold Spring Harbor-based real estate firm with an East ... 18 Feb 2020 by Staff Writer

Chris Coleman Joins Compass

Real estate agent Chris Coleman, the top producer in Montauk, has joined Compass. Mr. Coleman ... by Staff Writer

Only House On The South Fork With A Rooftop Pool Sells For $8.5M

The only house on the South Fork with a rooftop pool just sold for $8.49 ... by Staff Writer

Pulse East End Roundtable: Analyzing 2019 In Hamptons Real Estate And Looking Forward

Was it the trade war, the global economic uncertainty, the impacts of 2017’s federal tax ... by My27east

Hamptons Real Estate Association’s Listings Website Is Growing Quickly

When new East End real estate website debuted in December 2019, it included rentals ... 17 Feb 2020 by Brendan J. O’Reilly

Sale Of 80 Meadowmere Lane Is One Of 2019’s Biggest Hamptons Real Estate Deals

A major Southampton Village real estate deal closed at the end of December that could ... 14 Feb 2020 by Staff Writer

Three Ponds Farm Was Second-Biggest Hamptons Real Estate Sale Of 2019

Sold in June, Three Ponds Farm is a 58.7-acre, eight-structure compound with its own USGA-rated ... 13 Feb 2020 by Staff Writer

Welcome to our new website!

To see what’s new, click “Start the Tour” to take a tour.

We welcome your feedback. Please click the
“contact/advertise” link in the menu bar to email us.

Start the Tour
Landscape view not supported