Revisiting Villa Maria, A Water Mill Landmark - 27 East

Real Estate News

Real Estate News / 1412170

Revisiting Villa Maria, A Water Mill Landmark

icon 4 Photos
Louise and Vince Camuto at Villa Maria for the God’s Love We Deliver cocktail party they hosted in 2013.  PRESS FILE

Louise and Vince Camuto at Villa Maria for the God’s Love We Deliver cocktail party they hosted in 2013. PRESS FILE

Villa Maria in Water Mill. JAKE RAJS/SOTHEBY'S INTERNATIONAL REALTY

Villa Maria in Water Mill. JAKE RAJS/SOTHEBY'S INTERNATIONAL REALTY

Villa Maria in Water Mill. BRUNO SHRECK/SOTHEBY'S INTERNATIONAL REALTY

Villa Maria in Water Mill. BRUNO SHRECK/SOTHEBY'S INTERNATIONAL REALTY

Villa Maria in Water Mill. JAKE RAJS/SOTHEBY'S INTERNATIONAL REALTY

Villa Maria in Water Mill. JAKE RAJS/SOTHEBY'S INTERNATIONAL REALTY

authorVirginia Garrison on Feb 2, 2015

Villa Maria, the stately mansion with vast lawns rolling out to Mecox Bay, continues to turn travelers’ heads as they drive through Water Mill—just as it did in previous lives as a convent and a palatial estate.In 2005, Vincent Camuto, founder of the Nine West shoe brand, and Louise Camuto, an interior designer, bought the 14.6-acre property from the Dominican Sisters for $35 million. The sisters had used the local landmark as a school, convent and spiritual center starting around 1930.

The Camutos went on to have the once Victorian-style mansion built in 1897 both modernized and restored to its former glory—the pinnacle of which had followed an earlier expansion in 1919 under the private ownership of a Brooklyn ship builder who’d nearly doubled its size and greatly expanded its grandeur. And then, just as they’d said they might do at the time of their purchase, the Camutos put Villa Maria on the market just three years after buying it.

As of Mr. Camuto’s death on January 21 at his home in Greenwich, Connecticut, at age 78, the mansion was still listed for sale with Corcoran and Sotheby’s, despite rumors that it had been sold in 2013. The asking price seems to have been as high as $100 million and as low as $49.5 million since 2008, but Villa Maria, at 51 and 56 Halsey Lane, is currently listed with an asking price of $69 million.

Timothy Davis, one of the listing agents at Corcoran, confirmed that the Camuto family still owns the property. The house will remain for sale as planned before Mr. Camuto’s death, he said.

“The house was masterfully rebuilt from top to bottom and would never be demolished, nor could it,” Mr. Davis said in answer to an email question this week.

The land is subdivided into three parcels, and the villa itself is listed with 11 acres with a dock and 950 feet of bulkheaded waterfront.

“Louise and I are passionate about interior design and the restoration of old houses,” Mr. Camuto had told The Press in 2005 at the time of the purchase. He added that he and his wife planned to continue to live in Greenwich and perhaps sell the mansion when the renovation was complete. They also owned Wooldon Manor in Southampton, a former Woolworth family estate, which they sold in 2013.

Mr. Camuto may not have spent a great deal of time at Villa Maria, but it must have been on his mind: A Vince Camuto line of bedding is named for the Water Mill estate.

The sisters gave Villa Maria its present name; in earlier incarnations it had been called Red Gables, and then Grey Gables, for its roof color.

A huge expansion by Edward P. Morse of the Morse Dry Dock & Repair Company in 1919 more than doubled the mansion’s size to include a grand ballroom, a sweeping staircase, limestone, stucco, and imposing colonnades, according to “Houses of the Hamptons 1880-1930,” by Anne Surchin and Gary Lawrance.

“He transformed the bumptious late Victorian cottage into a stately Italian villa by the sea,” the book says.

About 10 years after that renovation, the Dominican Sisters paid $250,000 for the estate, intending to use it for a school. They donated the Corwith Windmill, which the estate’s earliest owner had moved to the property, to the Water Mill Improvement Association.

About 75 years later, when they could not afford to maintain Villa Maria, they sold it to the Camutos. One condition of the sale was that the main house would not be destroyed, although it reportedly had extensive water damage and was split into dormitory-style rooms. Another was that the public’s view of the water would be preserved.

The Camutos enlisted architect Andre Tchelistcheff, landscape designer Edmund Hollander and restoration builder John Hummel, as well as interior designers like Ms. Camuto herself, to—to put it mildly—spruce the place up.

Corcoran’s listing describes the finished product as a baronial mansion without equal, “from its impressive grand-entrance foyer with a soaring triple-story spiraling staircase, to its hand-hone limestone floors, imported Carrara marble baths and oversized formal rooms for entertaining on a grand scale.”

According to Sotheby’s, the main mansion has 11 bedrooms, including a six-room master suite, the “handmade stone and wrought-iron staircase, a 60-foot living room with original fresco details, and a state-of-the-art kitchen.”

Outside is a two-story portico and a large stone terrace overlooking the wide lawn and bay, a waterside pool and cabana, a tennis court and a two-bedroom guesthouse. The main house is said to have lots of sunlight as well as panoramic views of Mecox Bay.

And General Ruxton, a favorite horse of Theodore Roosevelt, is reputed to be buried on the property—a relic of its stewardship almost a century ago by Edward P. Morse.

You May Also Like:

Quail Ridge Residents Scramble After Apartments Are Purchased for Redevelopment | 27Speaks Podcast

The tenants of Quail Ridge — the two dozen studio and one-bedroom apartments spread over ... 3 Jul 2025 by 27Speaks

Water Mill Property Where Hal Buckner and Dorothy Lichtenstein Left Their Marks Is for Sale

A Water Mill property that hosts a former dairy barn turned artist’s studio and a ... 30 Jun 2025 by Brendan J. O’Reilly

Sundays on the Bay Hits the Market

Sundays on the Bay restaurant and marina on Dune Road in Hampton Bays has hit ... 29 Jun 2025 by Staff Writer

Hamptons Rental Market Remains Alive and Well

To paraphrase Mark Twain, reports of the demise of the Hamptons summer-rental market are greatly exaggerated. “Any hint that the Hamptons rental market is anything but robust is completely wrong,” said Corcoran associate broker Gary DePersia in East Hampton. An interesting dynamic is stirring in the Hamptons vacation-rental market. Although there has been an unprecedented rise in short-term rentals and the aftershocks of the COVID-19 pandemic linger, it has been a bumper crop year for Wall Street, interest rates have remained steady and a new breed of demanding customer is emerging. Despite it all, the Hamptons vacation-rental market remains as ... 19 Jun 2025 by Joseph Finora

Jon Vaccari Joins Noble Black & Partners at Douglas Elliman

Jon Vaccari, a longtime resident of Sag Harbor, has joined Noble Black & Partners at ... 18 Jun 2025 by Staff Writer

Appeals Court Sides With Landowner Over Southampton Village ZBA

Southampton Village has lost an appeal that sought to reinstate a Zoning Board of Appeals ... 12 Jun 2025 by Brendan J. O’Reilly

Last Parcel of Startop Ranch in Montauk Sells

The last plot of land at Startop Ranch in Montauk, 107 Startop Drive, has sold ... by Staff Writer

Hamptons Real Estate Roundtable, Memorial Day Weekend 2025 Edition

With Memorial Day weekend about to kick the Hamptons into high season, The Express News ... 22 May 2025 by Moderated by Brendan J. O’Reilly

Au-Delà Real Estate Vows To Go 'Beyond'

Au-Delà Real Estate, a new boutique real estate firm based in East Hampton, is now ... 20 May 2025 by Brendan J. O’Reilly

AI Helps Rental Seekers Find Homes That Match Their Aesthetic Preferences

Consumers increasingly have an expectation of superior, more personalized service based on their own particular ... by Steven Loeb