Southampton Village ARB To Re-Open Mocomanto Hearing - 27 East

Real Estate News

Real Estate News / 1397566

Southampton Village ARB To Re-Open Mocomanto Hearing

icon 1 Photo
Mocomanton in Southampton Village.  DANA SHAW

Mocomanton in Southampton Village. DANA SHAW

authorGreg Wehner on Apr 4, 2018

A hearing on an application to nearly double the size of Mocomanto—a 125-year-old Victorian home in the estate section of Southampton Village, on Lake Agawam—will be re-opened to look into allegations that the village’s historical consultant overstepped his boundaries and gave private advice to the applicant’s historical consultant.

The application for 472 First Neck Lane, which was first presented to the Southampton Village Board of Historic Preservation and Architectural Review, or ARB, in November, seeks to add a two-story addition to the north along with a smaller one-story addition. ARB members closed the hearing on February 26 after nearly four months of going back and forth with the developer to adjust various aspects of the plans, and listening to residents who opposed the project.

According to a letter from ARB attorney Elbert “Beau” Robinson Jr., members of the ARB made the decision to re-open the hearing in an executive session—during which cameras are off and the public may not be in the meeting room. The letter was addressed to John Bennett, the attorney representing Mocomanto homeowner Ken Fox; and Patrick Fife, the attorney representing neighbors Robert Giuffra, Joyce Giuffra and Whitney Stevens.

Mr. Robinson Jr. said in the letter that the re-opened hearing would be limited to testimony related to allegations concerning the conduct of Mr. Studenroth.”

Mr. Fife submitted a letter to the board on March 8 requesting that the hearing be left open until the ARB reviews a string of emails between Mr. Studenroth and Joel Snodgrass, a historic preservation consultant hired by Mr. Fox.

Mr. Fife said Mr. Studenroth and Mr. Snodgrass had communications that the ARB members were not made privy to.

“The communications reveal that Mr. Studenroth afforded the applicant preferential treatment, including providing Mr. Snodgrass feedback on the applicant’s plans before they were presented to the board,” Mr. Fife said in his letter. “Mr. Studenroth even sent his February 7, 2018 report to Mr. Snodgrass before he sent it to the ARB, stating: ‘Please let the others receive through their regular channels.’”

Some people are questioning whether or not this constitutes a violation of ethics.

“The difficulty is perception,” Southampton Village Mayor Michael Irving said in an email on Thursday, April 5. “When done in a prudent and transparent manner, it is not an ethical issue, but becomes a useful tool in helping boards reach rational and balanced decisions.”

Mr. Robinson said the hearing will not be open to discussing anything other than these claims.

Because of public notification requirements, the earliest that ARB members will be able to discuss these matters in a public meeting is on Monday, April 23.

You May Also Like:

Ground Broken On Five Affordable Houses In Riverside

The Southampton Housing Authority and Habitat for Humanity of Suffolk broke ground on November 22 ... 30 Nov 2021 by Brendan J. O’Reilly

Jennifer Ponzini Joins Saunders & Associates

Associate broker Jennifer Ponzini, who is licensed in both New York and Florida, has joined ... 19 Nov 2021 by Staff Writer

Parrish Pond Estate Sells For $6.2 Million

A Southampton estate in the Parrish Pond neighborhood with water views recently sold for $6.2 ... by Staff Writer

Sagaponack Traditional Sells Above Asking Price For $10.3 Million

A Sagaponack traditional just a few doors down from Sagg Main Beach recently sold for ... by Staff Writer

Shinnecock Hills Bayfront Home Sells For $7.3 Million

A modern bayfront home in Shinnecock Hills recently sold for $7.32 million after seeking $8 ... by Staff Writer

Leos Lane Home Trades For $6.3 Million

A Southampton Village residence built in 2014 recently sold for $6.3 million, which is $1.5 ... by Staff Writer

Thiele: Concerns About Eligibility To Collect Advances For Seasonal Rentals Are Easily Remedied

The New York State Association of Realtors has raised concerns that some homeowners will not benefit from a new law that allows landlords to collect rent for the entire season upfront, but the legislation’s author explained Friday how landlords and municipalities can easily meet the law’s eligibility requirements. In September, Governor Kathy Hochul signed into law Assemblyman Fred W. Thiele Jr.’s legislation that clarifies that seasonal rentals are not subject to caps on collecting deposits and advance payments. A few requirements must be met in order for landlords to take advantage of that exemption. Tenants must occupy the rental unit ... 16 Nov 2021 by Brendan J. O’Reilly

Sagaponack’s ZIP Code Is Third Most Expensive In U.S.

Sagaponack’s 11962 is the third most expensive ZIP code in the United States, dropping one ... by Staff Writer

West End Road Residence By Roger Bullard Listed For $60M

An oceanfront residence in the Georgica section of East Hampton that was designed by the ... 15 Nov 2021 by Staff Writer

East Hampton Village Traditional Sells For $13 Million

An East Hampton Village residence just two blocks from Two Mile Hollow Beach recently sold ... by Staff Writer

Welcome to our new website!

To see what’s new, click “Start the Tour” to take a tour.

We welcome your feedback. Please click the
“contact/advertise” link in the menu bar to email us.

Start the Tour
Landscape view not supported
Send this to a friend