Top Five Residents Who Thumbed Their Noses At The Law Top Five Residents Who Thumbed Their Noses At The Law - 27 East

Real Estate News

Real Estate News / 1407254

Top Five Residents Who Thumbed Their Noses At The Law

icon 5 Photos
authorCarey London on Feb 23, 2016

We’re always amazed by the cajones of property owners who thumb their noses at the law. Sometimes it comes in the form of so-called “tree farms” that give homeowners tax benefits; sometimes it’s a total disregard for local history; and sometimes it’s just gratuitous building with little care for what anyone thinks. They would almost be admirable if their actions weren’t so annoying. With that, here are five brazen homeowners who legally stretched the limits of the law and made us sad in the process.

1. A Bitter Compound

Remember this guy? Reclusive billionaire Ira Rennert’s 65-acre beachside compound in Sagaponack inspired deep bitterness when presented in 1998. Known as Fair Field, the property became home to a 57,770-square-foot mansion, a playhouse, power plant, 20-car garage, beach pavilions and more. It was completed in 2003 on a former potato field, and the entire complex effectively used up the last of the hamlet’s seaside fields. Outraged by the project’s scale and grandiosity, residents formed a homeowners association whose sole mission was to challenge the town’s green light for the project. There was a series of full-page ads in the local press denouncing “the rape of Sagaponack,” and more. We cannot imagine having that many people hate us. We’d just curl up in a ball and die. More than a decade later, things have clearly calmed down, but this property is still seen by many as a very large stain on the landscape.

2. No Ghosts Allowed

Last fall, the owners of a home in Southampton installed a fence and hedge in a town-owned cemetery. The cemetery is home to the remains of some of the first settlers of Southampton—and the fence, which was about 10 feet inside the property line, potentially disturbed historic grave sites or headstone pieces that may have broken off and been buried along the edges of the cemetery. Sigh. Let’s show a little respect for our dead, shall we? The homeowners, Mirek Denis and Anne Chwat, blamed their landscaper for mistakenly placing the fence on cemetery grounds (nice move), had it removed and agreed to pay for remediation of the site. We’re glad it’s resolved, but with a modicum of planning, it all could’ve been avoided.

3. Rock Star Turned Farmer

Our favorite Material Girl apparently decided to become a farmer last summer, or at least look like one. After purchasing a parcel adjacent to her horse farm in Bridgehampton, Madonna created a tree farm much to the chagrin of neighbors, who believed she was using the tree farm to secure privacy at her mansion. It also blocked pastoral views for passersby. The parcel was a bargain at a reported $2.2 million, as the development rights had already been purchased for $10 million by Southampton Town and Suffolk County. Don’t celebs realize that most people driving down these roads just want to see open land? They’re not hoping to spy a celebrity while moving at 40 mph. Just putting that out there.

4. A Merry Christmas By The Beach

Meet more tree farmers, this time in Sagaponack. Marc Goldman, Michael Hirtenstein and Milton Berlinski, who own a 43-acre oceanfront property in the village, pledged to keep about 25 acres undeveloped, maintaining scenic views of the property’s farmland. In exchange, they enjoyed tax relief on that portion of the land. Ahh, must be nice. But after Mr. Goldman, who owns the majority share, was denied permission to build a rather giant home, much of the preserved land suddenly became home to Christmas trees. The plantings were believed to be an act of retaliation, but Mr. Goldman denied that, saying he had always planned to do something agricultural. Mm hmm. And the move didn’t violate the easement because the Peconic Land Trust said so. In short, the public lost a beautiful vista that was promised to them, because laws have loopholes that need to be stitched up.

5. History Shmistory

Here’s one for the books. In 2013, David and Silvia Hermer purchased a home in Southampton Village and wanted to build a new one in its stead. But when they proposed it, opponents said that the current house was believed to have been inhabited by Pyrrhus Concer, an African-American who was born an indentured servant. The couple’s request to demolish it was denied and they threatened to sue the village, charging their rights as property owners were being denied. The two parties reached an agreement, and the village salvaged historic artifacts before the building was demolished. It was later noted that the core frame of the home was, in fact, owned by the Concer family and worthy of landmark status. Gah! Fast forward to last summer and Southampton Town agreed to purchase the property for $4.3 million, using Community Preservation Fund monies. So basically the Hermers demolished what should’ve been a local landmark and then made the town pay them to give it up. Having paid $2.75 million for the property, they got a $1.55 million windfall and didn’t even have to build anything! We have no words.

You May Also Like:

Water Mill Estate Sells For $14 Million, Discounted Nearly $11 Million

A Water Mill estate on a 1.46-acre peninsula fronting Meyer’s Pond and overlooking Mecox Bay ... 5 Dec 2019 by Staff Writer

Community Preservation Fund Revenue Down 22 Percent So Far This Year

Revenues for the Peconic Bay Region Community Preservation Fund during the first 10 months of the year are down 22 percent compared to the same period last year, according to New York State Assemblyman Fred W. Thiele Jr. Each of the five East End towns maintains its own CPF, funded through a 2 percent real estate transfer tax. Altogether, the towns collected just $63.35 million from January to October 2019, while $81.27 million was brought in during those months in 2018. Every month so far in 2019 has underperformed 2018, Mr. Thiele noted. October revenues were $5.15 million, down from ... 3 Dec 2019 by Staff Writer

New State Law Allows Development Rights To Move Inland From Flood-Prone Areas

To aid in the relocation of development from areas at high risk of flood to areas with lower risk, a new state law authorizes the owners of flood-prone properties to transfer their development rights inland. Assemblyman Fred W. Thiele Jr. of Sag Harbor was the prime sponsor of the legislation that Governor Andrew Cuomo signed into law last month. Under the law, land identified as at risk from sea-level rise, flooding and storm surge, and land on steep slopes, will be eligible to send development rights to land that is better suited to development. Transfer of development rights, or TDR, ... by Staff Writer

New Requirements For Landlords, And Rights For Tenants, Laid Out

Tenant’s rights advocates have hailed the Housing Stability and Tenant Protection Act of 2019, which ... 25 Nov 2019 by Brendan J. OReilly

Newsday Investigation Finds Some Long Island Real Estate Agents Engaged In Discriminatory Practices

A three-year Newsday investigation into how real estate agents on Long Island serve homebuyers of ... 23 Nov 2019 by Brendan J. O’Reilly

Mel Brooks And Anne Bancroft’s Former Southampton Beach Cottage Sells For $5 Million

The Southampton home that once, briefly, belonged to comedian and director Mel Brooks and his ... 21 Nov 2019 by Staff Writer

Neighboring Landowners Object As Sagaponack Farm Proposes Deer Fence

The Fosters say the deer population has grown to the point that they have no ... 15 Nov 2019 by Brendan J. OReilly

Elie Tahari’s Sagaponack Home Now Asks $39 Million

More than two years after it hit the market for $45 million and failed to ... 7 Nov 2019 by Staff Writer

Peter Matthiessen’s Former Sagaponack Home Could Become Center For Writing, Conservation, Zen

When author and naturalist Peter Matthiessen died in the spring of 2014, uncertainty reigned. His ... 6 Nov 2019 by Hannah Selinger

Attorney Jack Lester Helping OLA Help Renters Wronged By Landlords

For renters on the South Fork who feel that they have been mistreated by their ... by Brendan J. OReilly

Welcome to our new website!

To see what’s new, click “Start the Tour” to take a tour.

We welcome your feedback. Please click the
“contact/advertise” link in the menu bar to email us.

Start the Tour
Landscape view not supported