When Lake Agawam's Heart Beat Strongly - 27 East

Real Estate News

Real Estate News / 1410239

When Lake Agawam's Heart Beat Strongly

icon 3 Photos
Sofa shopping at Hildreth's in Southampton.    DAWN WATSON

Sofa shopping at Hildreth's in Southampton. DAWN WATSON

At the Sag Harbor home of Lenore and Adam Sender.   DAWN WATSON

At the Sag Harbor home of Lenore and Adam Sender. DAWN WATSON

Living room to kitchen transition by Iris Dankner at Holiday House Hamptons. DAWN WATSON

Living room to kitchen transition by Iris Dankner at Holiday House Hamptons. DAWN WATSON

authorVirginia Garrison on Jul 27, 2015

Life was good for Charlotte Schermerhorn, a rich widow who built up a compound of rental cottages in the late 19th century in Southampton Village—“the most charming of all small cities by the sea.”

“They had their cottage on Lake Agawam and their family friend with them, a great Newfoundland dog named Joe,” says Sally Spanburgh, speaking of Charlotte and family in her new book, “The Southampton Cottages of South Main Street,” which she’ll present at the Rogers Memorial Library on Wednesday, August 5. “They had a schooner at the ready to take rides on the lake at any hour; a garden full of prized fruit, flowers and vegetables; and staff to look after them.”

But tragedy struck—the dog was shot, the second of Ms. Schermerhorn’s three sons died, and the surviving one wrested away his mother’s real estate while threatening to declare her insane. Properties were sold off, generations passed, and, after a 75-year presence, the once-prominent Schermerhorn family had completely vanished from the village, where only a carriage house from the original compound stands today.

That’s one of Ms. Spanburgh’s favorite stories in her second book, which offers an armchair tour of 34 homes built between 1683 and 1930 on South Main Street, of which 29 survive, and whose heavenly names, from Wyndecote to Grassmere to Sunny Hours, evoke a time of leisure well enjoyed.

“I want to have dinner with Charlotte before she loses everything,” the author said. “I’m so intrigued with her.”

It’s hard to imagine what life on Lake Agawam was like 100 or more years ago, right after a wave of new colonists had transformed the colonial farmsteads on the village’s oldest street into sophisticated vacation homes.

The summer residents built sidewalks, put up streetlights and for a short time gave Agawam a new name, “Silver Lake.” Lake Agawam was the lifeblood of the community, completely lined with health-enhancing paths for walking and bicycling, and recreationally used for fishing, swimming, ice boating, ice skating and sailing. There were annual regattas, and outdoor concerts on Saturday nights.

Old postcards show fancy ladies, dressed from head to toe and toting parasols, being pulled in dog carts along dirt paths surrounding the lake.

“I had no idea that Lake Agawam was the heart of the social activity in the summer,” Ms. Spanburgh said. “They swam in it, they fished in it, they stocked it with fish—carp and bass.” It was the Village Improvement Association, whose members were summer colonists and local residents alike, that would keep the lake clean for all these purposes.

Today, of course, the lake is dirty, and the area to the east of it has grown more exclusive and private—Ms. Spanburgh discovered during her research that many residents have no idea who their neighbors might be.

Even so, she said, she found the people whose homes she photographed and chronicled to be committed to taking care of them, and often keen to learn about their origins. “They’re such proud owners of history,” she said. “They love their homes.”

A consultant, writer and researcher whose background is in architecture, interior design and preservation, Ms. Spanburgh is active in local historic preservation, especially in her role as chairwoman of the Southampton Town Landmarks and Historic Districts Board. Her first book, “The Southampton Cottages of Gin Lane,” was published in 2012.

Wednesday’s talk at the library will start at noon. Reservations are recommended and can be made by calling 283-0774 or emailing programs@myrml.org.

You May Also Like:

Ellie Awards Recognize Top Performers

On Wednesday, March 19, Douglas Elliman announced the winners of the 2025 Ellie Awards, which honor the firm’s top-performing agents throughout the nation. “Since stepping into this role at Douglas Elliman, I have been deeply inspired by the dedication and resilience our agents show every day as they navigate an ever-changing market,” said Michael S. Liebowitz, the president and CEO of Douglas Elliman Inc. “Their expertise, entrepreneurial drive, and commitment to excellence not only set them apart as real estate professionals — they are the source of our reputation for providing the highest level of client service. I look forward ... 26 Mar 2025 by Staff Writer

East Hampton's Butterfly House Is on the Market

An East Hampton home known as Butterfly House, which exhibits the butterfly roof design that ... 21 Mar 2025 by Staff Writer

Newsletter Spotlights South Fork Land Use Laws

The mention of land use and zoning may cause the eyes of some people to ... 12 Mar 2025 by Brendan J. O’Reilly

Original North Haven Shores Model Home Hits the Market

One of the original model homes in the North Haven Shores community developed in the ... 11 Mar 2025 by Staff Writer

'Housing in Your Hometown' Presentation Is April 5 in Bridgehampton

The Long Island Housing Coalition and the Bridgehampton Child Care & Recreational Center will present “Housing in Your Hometown” on Saturday, April 5, at the center on the Bridgehampton-Sag Harbor Turnpike. The program will include workshops on: “The Story of Housing in the Hamptons,” “Affordable Housing – How To Get to Yes,” “Housing a Nation – Empowering the Shinnecock,” “How To House Our Teachers,” “First-Time Homebuyer Programs,” “Co-ops and the Missing Middle” and “Senior Housing, Housing Choice Vouchers and Other Resources.” The event will run from 9:30 a.m. to 2 p.m. For more information, contact ERASE Racism senior housing policy ... 9 Mar 2025 by Staff Writer

PJCArchitecture Updates 1970s Sagaponack Spec Home

A lot has changed in the last 50 years in the architecture space, not only ... 3 Mar 2025 by Steven Loeb

Bridgehampton Estate With Putting Green Sells for $16.65M

A Bridgehampton estate by Konner Development with a putting green and deeded ocean beach access ... 24 Feb 2025 by Staff Writer

WATCH: Taking the Pulse of the Hamptons Real Estate Market

During an Express Sessions discussion of the state of the Hamptons real estate market last ... 19 Feb 2025 by Brendan J. O'Reilly

Waterfront Nantucket-Style Home in Quogue Sells for $5.5M

A waterfront home in the Village of Quogue with a dock and views over Quantuck ... by Staff Writer

Top 10 Hamptons Real Estate Sales West of the Canal, 2024

The Hamptons real estate market west of the Shinnecock Canal, like the market east of ... 17 Feb 2025 by Staff Writer