Restaurant Defaced With Racial Slurs And Obscenities In Noyac. - 27 East

Restaurant Defaced With Racial Slurs And Obscenities In Noyac.

icon 3 Photos
Pelligrino Restaurant was vandalized on Tuesday night.  COURTESY PAMELA BLACKBURN

Pelligrino Restaurant was vandalized on Tuesday night. COURTESY PAMELA BLACKBURN

Pellegrino's Restaurant was vandalized on Tuesday night. COURTESY PAMELA BLACKBURN

Pellegrino's Restaurant was vandalized on Tuesday night. COURTESY PAMELA BLACKBURN

Pellegrino's Restaurant was vandalized on Tuesday night. COURTESY PAMELA BLACKBURN

Pellegrino's Restaurant was vandalized on Tuesday night. COURTESY PAMELA BLACKBURN

Kitty Merrill And Alec Giufurta on Jun 24, 2020

Brian and Pamela Blackburn planned to spend Tuesday prepping the dining room at their Noyac restaurant, Pellegrino’s Pizza Bar and Restaurant, for the long-awaited reopening of phase three indoor dining.

Instead, they spent the day power washing racial slurs and profanity from the front of their Noyac Road eatery. Vandals spray painted the N-word and a common four-letter obscenity, as well as “white matters,” and “slaves are white,” and more, across the building. Green painted letters, over 2 feet high in some places, marked the white soffit and filled three picture windows. The front door and the right side of the building were tagged with racist language.

The couple learned of the defacing Tuesday morning.

“I was alerted to it by a phone call from my aunt and a cousin who were driving by,” Ms. Blackburn said. “Honestly, my first reaction was shock, then anger and just really disbelief … you don’t expect something like that to happen to you.”

When she and Mr. Blackburn arrived at the restaurant, she recalled, was even more upsetting.

“Seeing it in person was a little bit more intense,” she said.

Her feelings shifted from anger to sadness.

She took to social media and crafted a Facebook post reporting that she and Mr. Blackburn, “spent the day scrubbing and power washing this person’s anger away.”

Some of what she described as “disgusting words and phrases and racial slurs” were hidden behind a hedge on the site. The couple washed shingles and windows, easily removing the graffiti.

“We wanted to get rid of the words as quickly as possible,” Ms. Blackburn said.

On Wednesday morning, a professional cleaning company removed the remainder of the spray paint.

Feelings of anger and hurt morphed into being thankful the damage could be washed away, she continued.

“No windows were broken, nothing stolen, and thank God nobody was injured,” Ms. Blackburn said.

“The main feeling we are left with, however, after all of the visible evidence is gone is one of sadness,” Ms. Blackburn’s post continues. “We feel so sad that this is the state of our world, our country, our community. And this is not a new situation by any means but we need for all of you to really think about what is happening right now in this country. In the year 2020. This kind of hate and racism and pure ignorance is STILL HAPPENING. And so many people are STILL IGNORING it or worse, taking part in it.”

As soon as the couple arrived at their restaurant Tuesday morning, Ms. Blackburn called the Southampton Town Police. A patrol officer arrived and took pictures, and, the couple was asked to delay cleaning until after a detective was able to view the scene.

Ms. Blackburn was told the case would be investigated and camera footage from the North Sea Fire Department substation next door would be viewed. Security camera at the restaurant caught a grainy image of a gloved hand and the top of what looked like a head covered by a bandanna. Their camera set the time of the vandalism as 12:52 a.m. about an hour after the restaurant closed.

Police are actively investigating the matter, according to Lieutenant Susan Ralph, the department’s spokeswoman. Right now, it’s labeled as making graffiti. The lieutenant noted that in order to be classified as a hate crime, it would need to target a specific person or group.

“I don't think we were personally targeted,” Ms. Blackburn said, calling the family establishment “a convenient canvas.”

Describing herself as a “very strong supporter of equality,” she said she has no tolerance or patience for bigotry. In her social media post, Ms. Blackburn told friends, “Don’t be upset this happened to us, to Pellegrino’s. Be upset that this is happening. Period.”

You May Also Like:

Caroline Grace Fairley of Sag Harbor Dies July 22

Caroline Grace Fairley, affectionately known as “Caro,” passed away unexpectedly in her home in Sag ... 1 Aug 2025 by Staff Writer

Rose L. Nabel of Southampton Dies July 25

Rose L. Nabel, 94, of Southampton, New York, passed away at Bayshore Medical Center on ... by Staff Writer

Quogue Police: Woman Stole Money From Cash Register, Had Physical Altercation With Shop Owner

Quogue Village Police arrested Maria Gutierrez-Monterrey, 43, of Westhampton Beach on Wednesday, July 30, at 11:52 a.m., and charged her with fourth-degree grand larceny and fourth-degree criminal possession of stolen property, both felonies, as well as fifth-degree criminal possession of stolen property and two counts of petit larceny, all misdemeanors. At 11:46 a.m. on that day, police had been called to a Jessup Avenue shop, where the owner said there was a larceny in progress. The officers were informed that a woman had stolen money from the register, and when the shop owner confronted her, they got into a physical ... by Cailin Riley

Head Start’s New Start: From Uncertainty to a $2.25M Lifeline | 27Speaks Podcast

A year ago this week, Kristina Foster, supervisor of the Southampton Head Start Center, received ... by 27Speaks

Southampton Police Reports for the Week of July 31

WESTHAMPTON BEACH — Dmitri Shadrin, 54, of New York, was arrested by Westhampton Beach Village Police on July 26 at 11:06 p.m. and charged with misdemeanor DWI. Shadrin was pulled over at the intersection of Old Riverhead Road and Rogers Avenue. An investigation revealed he had a blood alcohol level over .08, police said. He was held overnight at Southampton Town Police headquarters and released the next morning. SOUTHAMPTON VILLAGE — James T. Ficco, 33, of Prescol, Pennsylvania, was arrested by Village Police shortly before midnight on July 25 and charged with DWI and resisting arrest, both misdemeanors, after he ... by Staff Writer

Promise of Better Cell Service Is Still Just That in Sagaponack

At the end of last year, the issue of notoriously bad cellphone service in and ... by Cailin Riley

Watermill Center Founder Robert Wilson Dies at 83

Robert Wilson — an artist, theater and opera director, architect, set and lighting designer, and ... 31 Jul 2025 by Staff Writer

St. John's Episcopal Church To Host First Art Show Since 2019

St. John’s Episcopal Church and St. Andrew’s Dune Church are hosting an art show on ... by Dan Stark

The Senior Surge

People often speak wistfully about young people being the future of this country. They certainly are — but let’s take a moment to recognize that the next few decades are actually going to belong to senior citizens. Which makes a group like Seniors Taking Action, founded by Mary Mulvihill of North Haven and Judy Loeb of East Hampton six years ago, even more impactful. Their small gathering of seniors is growing, in size and stature — it now has 1,400 members — and could well become an advocacy group that serves as a voice for those 65 and older. And ... 30 Jul 2025 by Editorial Board

Estuaries Are a Bargain

Whichever side of the political aisle you sit on, there’s a reality in play in 2025: Government spending is going to be on the chopping block, and only the most compelling arguments are going to save individual investments. Why, then, does federal spending on estuaries seem so precarious? The argument is rock solid, the benefits are clear and demonstrable, and it seems unlikely that the dollars going to places like the Peconic Estuary are raising ire among voters. If this funding is at risk, nothing is sacred. U.S. Senator Kirsten Gillibrand was in Riverhead last week pledging to fight proposed ... by Editorial Board