Rizzo Leads Pierson Girls Country to Second-Place Finish at Division Championships

icon 3 Photos
Pierson seventh-grader Evenlyn Rizzo won the team qualifier race at the Division Championships on Monday.   DREW BUDD

Pierson seventh-grader Evenlyn Rizzo won the team qualifier race at the Division Championships on Monday. DREW BUDD

Pierson sophomore Josie Mott.  DREW BUDD

Pierson sophomore Josie Mott. DREW BUDD

Whalers Bennett Greene, left, and Maggie Greenwald at the start of Monday's race.  DREW BUDD

Whalers Bennett Greene, left, and Maggie Greenwald at the start of Monday's race. DREW BUDD

Drew Budd on Oct 29, 2025

Evelyn Rizzo appears to have a competitive streak in her.

In the only other meet the Pierson cross country team had at Sunken Meadow State Park prior to Monday afternoon’s Division Championships is when it competed against Port Jefferson. Rizzo, a seventh-grader, came across the finish line visibly upset, perplexing head coach Yani Cuesta.

It was the first time the young Rizzo hadn’t won a race she competed in this season, and that still remains.

Competing in the team qualifier 5K on Monday, Rizzo won the 5K in 20:39.70, over 20 seconds ahead of the next finisher, Savannah Tychnowitz, a freshman from Rocky Point.

“She’s very, very competitive,” Cuesta said of her new top runner, Rizzo. “I’m sure she’s super happy and psyched. This is the first Sunken Meadow race that she’s finished in front of the entire pack, so I’m sure in that sense that ego boost is going to be great for her. That competitive thing is what drives her.”

Rizzo’s top time helped the Whalers finish second out of 20 teams in their race with 137 points only behind Bayport-Blue Point. Sophomore Josie Mott finished 18th overall out of 154 runners in 22:50.80. Senior Sara O’Brien finished right behind her at 19th in 22:52.50. Sophomore Maggie Greenwald (23:49.50) finished 43rd, senior Bennett Greene finished 79th in 25:11.10 and freshman Olivia Stiglitz finished 134th in 28:59.20.

A rule change this season had only the champions of each league run in the championship 5Ks on Monday, leaving 12 open spots for teams to petition to get into that race. All others competed either in the team qualifier or individual races. Previously, the top two teams in each league would automatically compete in the championship race and the rest of the teams in the county would compete separately in what’s called team qualifier or individual races.

Cuesta petitioned, she said, so she could have her runners compete against the county’s best runners to try to improve their times, but outside factors altered those plans a bit. Scheduled to leave Sag Harbor at 10:30 a.m. to make it to Sunken Meadow with plenty of time to spare for a 1 p.m. start, the team eventually left at 10:45 a.m. and finally reached the park just after 1.

Scuffling to make sure her team could run, Cuesta called officials and informed them they would be late and they allowed her team to run in the team qualifier race instead. Although not what she wanted, it turned out that maybe things worked out anyway, being that Port Jefferson, the team the Whalers will be vying with for a Suffolk County Class D Championship against at the Section XI Championships on Thursday, November 6, also ran in the team qualifier race.

“In that sense, it’s good and everything happens for a reason,” Cuesta said. “Maybe that was the reason we had our issues and got here when we did, so we’ll see how things pan out. Next week, we run at 2 so that will give us a little more time to get here.”

Overall, as it pertains to her runners, Cuesta thought they ran well.

“The top three looked good,” she said. “I’m glad [Rizzo] didn’t get passed along here. We had been working on hills, which was her biggest fear. We talked about how if you have a hard time going up the hills then you have to make up the time going down. I think that competitiveness drove her to really work on it and we had done it the past two weeks, so it was really good to see she had a girl right behind her at the base of Cardiac, and then to see her come off Cardiac with about 50 yards. She’s so intense.”

As for the Pierson boys, they didn’t have enough runners to compete as a team in the team qualifier race, but they did have four who ran. Freshman Lincoln Fischer was the fastest of the bunch, finishing 42nd out of 184 runners in 20:03.40. Freshman Jaxson Schumann finished 114th in 21:44.60, eighth-grader Leo Mogavero finished 126th in 22:13.80 and junior Quincy Renaud finished 168th in 25:22.

You May Also Like:

Rizzo's Top-20 Finish Earns All-State Honors at Cross Country Championships

Evelyn Rizzo capped her breakout cross country season with an 11th place finish at the ... 18 Nov 2025 by Drew Budd

Rizzo Dominates State Qualifier, Continues Breakout Run as Teammates Also Punch Tickets to States

Off cross country courses, Pierson’s Evelyn Rizzo appears to be a typical, unassuming and quiet ... 11 Nov 2025 by Drew Budd

Pierson Boys and Girls Run Well in Losses to Bayport-Blue Point

Last week’s tri-meet against Bayport-Blue Point and Southold marked the beginning of a new era ... 15 Oct 2025 by Casey Finelli

Weekly Roundup: Bonac Football Avenges Last Year's Playoff Loss at Hills West; Cook Leads Mariners Cross Country to First Win; Hampton Bays Girls Soccer Tallies Two Wins

Bonac Football Avenges
Last Year’s Playoff Loss The East Hampton/Pierson/Bridgehampton football team defeated host Half Hollow Hills West, 35-10, on Saturday afternoon, on the same field the Bonackers suffered a 52-6 loss in the opening round of the Suffolk County Division III playoffs last season. Theo Ball threw for 190 yards and three touchdowns, one of them to Jackson Ronick who also rushed for 75 yards and two touchdowns. Charlie Stern caught three receptions for 115 yards and recorded six tackles on defense. Livs Kuplins had six tackles and an interception and caught a 25-yard reception for a touchdown for the ... 23 Sep 2025 by Staff Writer

Weekly Roundup: Bridgehampton Boys Soccer, Hampton Bays Boys Volleyball Picks Up First-Ever Victories; East Hampton Girls Soccer On Fire

Bonac Boys Cross Country
Defeats Harborfields The East Hampton boys cross country team defeated Harborfields, 17-38, in its season opener on its home course on school grounds on September 9. According to head coach Kevin Barry, it’s only the second dual meet loss for the Tornadoes in the last five years. The Bonackers swept the top four placements to win the meet outright. Senior Sean Perez, in his first-ever cross country race, won the 2.5-mile race in 13:52, followed closely by senior Liam Knight (13:59) and sophomores Jasper Samuelson (14:09) and Watts Comly-Bolick (14:13). East Hampton Girls Soccer
Stays Undefeated The Bonackers ... 17 Sep 2025 by Staff Writer

Talented Pierson Girls Cross Country Team To Face Tough Competition

Pierson girls cross country head coach Yani Cuesta has grown accustomed to having competitive teams ... 10 Sep 2025 by Drew Budd

Pierson, Bridgehampton Student-Athletes Earn Postseason Awards for Efforts During Fall Season

Pierson Boys Cross Country All-Division Edmar Gonzalez-Nateras, David Kriegsman Both Gonzalez-Nateras and David Kriegsman each qualified for the New York State Cross Country Championships. — Ed First Team All-League Edmar Gonzalez-Nateras Second Team All-League Ben and David Kriegsman, Ben Ezier Pierson Girls Cross Country All-State, Class C/D Individual County Champion, All-County Greylynn Guyer All-League Bennett Greene, Maggie Greenwald, Greylynn Guyer, Josie Mott The girls went undefeated (6-0) in all League IX dual meets to win the league title outright. Greenwald, Guyer, Mott and Sara O’Brien each qualified individually for the New York State Cross Country Championships. — Ed. Pierson Field ... 26 Feb 2025 by Staff Writer

Penelope Greene Earns Second All-American Honors After Placing Third at Nationals

Penelope Greene is now a two-time NCAA Division III All-American after the 2021 Pierson graduate ... 26 Nov 2024 by Drew Budd

Greylynn Guyer Earns All-State Honors at New York State Cross Country Championships

For the first time ever, Greylynn Guyer is an All-State cross country runner. The Pierson ... 19 Nov 2024 by Drew Budd

Guyer Wins C/D County Race, but Girls Finish Behind Port Jeff; Gonzalez-Nateras, Kriegsman Qualify for States

The Pierson girls cross country team was expected to win its sixth consecutive Suffolk County ... 12 Nov 2024 by Drew Budd