Southampton firefighter 'Eggie' Raynor dies at 82. - 27 East

Southampton firefighter 'Eggie' Raynor dies at 82.

icon 4 Photos

authorColleen Reynolds on Mar 3, 2010

In more than 60 years as a local volunteer firefighter, Herbert C. “Eggie” Raynor battled blazes while making innumerable friends. The modest man who followed a family tradition of firefighting earned deep respect in Southampton Village for his devotion to the fire department, promotion of fire safety to schoolchildren and genuine passion for life.

Always eager to help others, Mr. Raynor fell while taking out the garbage at his Breese Lane home two weeks ago. He died from natural causes at Southampton Hospital on Saturday at the age of 82.

Although Mr. Raynor was a lifelong resident of the East End, his richly deserved reputation radiated beyond the region, particularly within firefighting circles.

“If you go anywhere on Long Island and say you’re from the Southampton Village Fire Department, people will ask, ‘Do you know Eggie Raynor?’” said Mr. Raynor’s friend Chris Brenner, the Southampton Fire Department public information officer.

Over the decades, Mr. Raynor became a fixture at local parades. He sent flurries of postcards and letters to friends and family members, enjoyed backyard games with children and camping on the beach and sparked his son David’s interest in becoming a firefighter, a great source of pride for him.

The Westhampton Beach native started extinguishing flames for the Westhampton Beach Fire Department in 1948, alongside his father and brothers. Upon moving to Southampton Village in 1957 with his wife, Patsy, he joined the Southampton Village Fire Department’s Hook and Ladder Co. #1, where he ascended the ranks rapidly, holding the title of chief from 1979 to 1982. Simultaneously, he served as the deputy county fire coordinator. Mr. Raynor continued to don his gear until his 70s and remained active at department functions until the end.

“My dad was kind of old school,” David Raynor of Southampton said. “He would stand up at firehouse meetings and address his own son as ‘Mr. Captain.’”

Mr. Raynor acquired his beloved nickname “Eggie” during a football game as a teenager. A fellow player knocked him down and said, “You’re such an egghead,” according to Mrs. Raynor. The name stuck and Mrs. Raynor, who met her husband through football games, said she knew him only as “Eggie” for a long time. The amusing part, his family noted, was that Mr. Raynor was actually very athletic, relishing many sports, including donkey basketball, played on the backs of animals for fund-raisers decades ago.

As a youth, Mr. Raynor was a lifeguard at several local beaches. Long after he exchanged his lifeguard rescue tubes for firefighting gear, however, Mr. Raynor saved the life of a 3-year-old girl in 1976, when he resuscitated Janice Strong’s limp body after a fire near the Southampton Village train station. He earned the Suffolk County and Southampton Fire Department medals of valor for his heroics.

A member of the Westhampton Beach High School class of 1945, Mr. Raynor left school to enlist in the U.S. Navy during World War II, serving for two years, stationed in Florida. He received an honorary diploma in 2002.

“As far as I’m concerned, Eggie was an ambassador for the fire department and the antique truck committee,” noted Steve Phillips, president of the Southampton Village Antique Truck Committee, which tends to antique trucks. Mr. Raynor also participated in the Southampton Village Antique Muster Committee.

“It strikes me that he was probably the most passionate man I’ve ever known when it comes to the fire department,” said Southampton Village Trustee Paul Robinson, who is the liaison to the department.

In his professional life, Mr. Raynor worked as a foreman at Duryea & Baird, a family-owned construction company. Upon the company’s dissolution, he joined the Teamsters Union, where he worked as a foreman for 25 years.

Yet it is his personable spirit that endures. He was so caring, his family noted, that he would thank the silverware at family dinners, in addition to saying grace.

“There comes a time when we all have to leave this world,” said his wife of 58 years, “and I’m happy for the years that we had together.”

In addition to his wife and son, Mr. Raynor is survived by two daughters, Denise Connors and her husband Dennis of Riverhead and Dawn Mielke and her husband Jon of Loveland, Colorado; two brothers, Milton and his wife Martha of Eastport and Rich and his wife Kathy of Calverton; and a granddaughter, Mackenzie Mielke of Loveland, Colorado.

Mr. Raynor was predeceased by his mother, Irene; his father, Russ; two brothers, George and Henry; two sisters, Lillian Gowan and Cora Kametler; and a granddaughter, Amanda Mielke.

Visitation hours were held on Wednesday, March 3, and are scheduled for today, Thursday, March 4, from 2 to 4 p.m. and 7 to 9 p.m. at O’Connell Funeral Home at 30 Little Plains Road in Southampton Village.

The Benevolent Order of Elks held a service on Wednesday, March 3, at 7:30 p.m. at the funeral home and a Firematic service will be held today, Thursday, at 7:30 p.m. at the funeral home. Religious services will be held on Friday, March 5, at 11 a.m. at the First Presbyterian Church of Southampton

In lieu of flowers, memorial donations may be sent to the Southampton Fire Department, P.O. Box 1435, Southampton, NY 11969. All donations will be given to the Stony Brook Burn Center and New York Firemen’s Home.

You May Also Like:

Southampton Police Reports for the Week of May 15

SOUTHAMPTON VILLAGE — A Village Police officer spotted a commercial pickup truck traveling on North Sea Road with flames leaping up out of the rear of the vehicle on May 7. The officer stopped the truck, whose driver had not noticed the flames, and extinguished the fire before it caused serious damage to the vehicle. SOUTHAMPTON VILLAGE — A caller told Southampton Village Police that they had seen a suspicious person “hiding in the bushes” outside a Windmill Lane bank on May 7. An officer responded to the scene and reported back that there was an employee washing the building’s ... 14 May 2025 by Staff Writer

The East End's Founding Industries: Fishing and Farming, in the Spotlight at Express Sessions

Sitting over the waters of Montauk Harbor, champions of the local farming and fishing communities ... by Michael Wright

The Bounty That Surrounds Us

When the Community Preservation Fund gets its well-earned accolades for the good it has done for the East End in the past quarter century, the focus often is on the preservation of land, keeping it from being developed and thus protecting the region from becoming too intensely suburban. Without question, that effort to maintain the region’s rural appeal is a significant, historic accomplishment. But sometimes we forget the importance of the CPF in keeping agriculture alive as a major contributor to the region’s agroeconomy, which has quality-of-life benefits of its own for both farmers and those who live among their ... by Editorial Board

Election Realignment Would Upend Town Votes

An upstate appellate court has thrown out a challenge to a realignment of town and ... by Michael Wright

East Quogue School District Budget of $32.3 Million on the Ballot Tuesday

The East Quogue School District will ask voters to approve the district’s proposed $32.3 million budget for the 2025-26 school year, which hikes spending by more than 5 percent but does not pierce the state tax cap. The proposed budget is a $1,578,988 increase in spending over the current school year’s budget, driven mostly by contractual salary hikes for staff and increasing costs of health insurance, rising tuition costs for students who attend the Westhampton Beach School District’s middle school and high school, and expanding the English language arts and science curriculum, according to the district’s budget documents. The district’s ... by Staff Writer

Quogue School District Budget Proposal Is $10 Million

The Quogue School District has proposed a 2025-26 operating budget of just under $10.1 million that includes a 4.5 percent increase in spending and a 3.29 percent increase in the tax levy but remains within the state-mandated tax cap. The growth in spending is driven primarily by increases in the cost of health insurance premiums, busing costs and tuition for students who have graduated from the Quogue School and moved up to the Westhampton Beach School District’s middle school and high school. To cover the nearly $1 million in additional spending over the amount that the state tax cap would ... by Staff Writer

Four Competing for Three Seats on Quogue School Board

There are three seats on the five-member Quogue Board of Education up for election this ... by Michael Wright

Southampton Village and Village PBA Agree to Terms on New Contract

Southampton Village Mayor Bill Manger announced at last Thursday night’s Village Board meeting that the ... by Cailin Riley

New NYU Langone Office Is Now Open in Westhampton Beach

Residents of Westhampton Beach and the surrounding area now have new options at their disposal ... by Cailin Riley

Westhampton Doubles Team of Volpe and Groth Place Third in Division Tournament

Giancarlo Volpe is headed back to the Suffolk County tennis tournament. And this year, the ... by Desirée Keegan