Southampton Village Architectural Review Board Closes Mocomanto Hearing - 27 East

Southampton Village Architectural Review Board Closes Mocomanto Hearing

icon 1 Photo
Mocomanto on Lake Agawam in Southampton Village.

Mocomanto on Lake Agawam in Southampton Village. DCIM100MEDIADJI_0344.JPG

authorGreg Wehner on Feb 28, 2018

The Southampton Village Board of Historic Preservation and Architectural Review voted on Monday to close the hearing on an application to nearly double the size of a 125-year-old home known as Mocomanto, clearing the way for a vote in April—though the decision split the board.

Chairman Curtis Highsmith, Christine Redding and the board’s newest member, Rob Coburn, voted for the hearing to be closed, while Susan Stevenson and Jeff Brodlieb voted against the motion.

“When these things are closed … the debate ends,” Mr. Brodlieb told board members before the vote. “I don’t support this application and will not vote for it.”

The proposed changes include nearly doubling the size of the residence at 472 First Neck Lane by adding a two-story addition to the north, along with a smaller one-story addition. The home is within the village’s historic district, though the structure itself has no official protection as a historic property.

According to a report issued on February 7 by the board’s historical consultant, Zachary Studenroth, the changes are “consistent with both local and national standards” and the scale is “visually subservient” to the existing home.

“That’s not subservient,” Ms. Stevenson told fellow board members on Monday. She added that alternative plans were presented by Siamak Samii, an architect who was hired by neighbors who oppose the project, showing that the homeowner, Ken Fox, can increase the size of the house and modernize it “without destroying the historic facade that is facing the lake, and without increasing the size so that it overpowers” the home.

While Mr. Highsmith noted that he appreciated Mr. Brodlieb’s and Ms. Stevenson’s comments, he reminded the ARB members that it is their responsibility to look at appropriateness. He added that the board is not charged with redesigning the home—nor is that a neighbor’s responsibility.

When asked whether any other changes would be submitted, John Bennett, the Southampton-based attorney representing Mr. Fox during the application process, said no.

Attorney Patrick Fife, who represents neighbors Joyce and Bob Giuffra and Whitney Stevens, submitted a new letter to the board hours before the meeting. In the letter, Mr. Fife reiterated many of his clients’ arguments against the project, citing its size and scale, and sought to ensure that the Secretary of the Interior’s Standards for the Treatment of Historic Properties are followed.

“My clients are not opposed to an addition to Mocomanto, but they believe the applicant must submit a plan for a more historically appropriate addition that respects Mocomanto’s original structure and comports with its history as the leading house during the establishment of Southampton’s resort community,” Mr. Fife said in his letter.

He also included a string of emails from Mr. Studenroth, including a November 16, 2017, email in which Mr. Highsmith said he would meet Mr. Studenroth at 472 First Neck Lane to get a firsthand look at the house. Mr. Fife suggested during Monday’s board meeting that Mr. Highsmith had met individually with the homeowner’s representatives—a suggestion that Mr. Highsmith later firmly denied.

“I met with no representative to discuss anything pertaining to 472 First Neck,” Mr. Highsmith said in an email to The Press on Tuesday. “This was a very important application, but I was unfamiliar with the site, and, therefore, it would be customary to do a site visit and not rely on only third-party information reported to me.

“I questioned the board if any member had communications with any opponents to the application, representative of the opponents, or the counsel, to offer the opportunity to disclose and put it on the record. My response remains an affirmed NO I HAVEN’T!” he added in the email.

Mr. Highsmith also asked members of the board on Monday, if they had communications with the applicant or representatives for the applicants, in an effort to put it on the record.

Though the board closed the hearing, written comments can still be submitted until Thursday, March 8. Mr. Highsmith told board members if new material is submitted that could change the minds of the board members, the hearing could be reopened for further dialogue.

If the hearing is not reopened, then a decision is expected to be announced at the ARB’s Monday, April 23, meeting.

You May Also Like:

The Future of Farming, with Amanda Merrow of Amber Waves | 27Speaks Podcast

In the spring of 2008, Amanda Merrow and Katie Baldwin met for the first time ... 8 May 2025 by 27Speaks

Barbara Ann Muller of Southampton Dies March 30

Barbara Ann Muller “Bam” Cancellieri, of Southampton, New York, passed away on March 30, 2025, ... by Staff Writer

Southampton's Wall of Distinction Welcomes New Class of Honorees

As the athletic director of the Southampton School District, Darren Phillips deals primarily in the ... by Michelle Trauring

Southampton Police Reports for the Week of May 8

QUOGUE — Quogue Village Police arrested Steven Failla, 48, of Quogue on May 3 at 12:14 a.m. at Jessup Avenue and charged him with third-degree assault, a misdemeanor. The officers were responding to a physical dispute at a residence on Jessup Avenue. Officers on scene performed an investigation and subsequently arrested Failla, as the victim of the assault sustained a physical injury to a hand, police said. Failla was held for morning arraignment. RIVERSIDE — A Wood Road Trail resident reported to Southampton Town Police that $17,000 dollars in cash was taken from a safe within her home sometime between ... 7 May 2025 by Staff Writer

Southampton DWI Arrests for the Week of May 8

Gintaras Satas, 58, of Mastic was arrested at about 11:30 p.m. on May 2 and charged with misdemeanor DWI and several vehicle and traffic violations after the vehicle he was driving nearly struck a Southampton Town Police car that was on the side of Montauk Highway in Water Mill with its lights on conducting a traffic stop of another vehicle. When approached by the officer, Satas was found to be unsteady on his feet and a breath alcohol test indicated he had been drinking more than the legal limit, according to police. by Staff Writer

Southampton Police Reports for the Week of May 1

SOUTHAMPTON — Elizabeth Phillips, 46, of East Quogue was arrested shortly before 9 a.m. on April 28 and charged with misdemeanor driving while ability impaired after she was involved in a car accident on Montauk Highway near West Gate Road and was found to be impaired by drugs. She was taken to Stony Brook Southampton Hospital for treatment of non-life-threatening injuries. RIVERSIDE — A Priscilla Avenue resident told Southampton Town Police that on April 22 at 10 a.m. two men had approached her at her home and identified themselves as New York State Department of Motor Vehicles investigators and that ... by Staff Writer

Southampton DWI Arrests for the Week of May 1

Renny Lopez-Bermeo, 27, of East Hampton was arrested by Southampton Town Police at about 7 p.m. on April 27 and charged with felony DWI after he was pulled over for driving erratically on Lynncliff Road near Ponquogue Avenue in Hampton Bays. A minor — under the age of 17 — was in the car with him at the time, elevating the DWI charge to a felony under Leandra’s Law. He was also charged with endangering the welfare of a child, a misdemeanor. Jeisson Cardozo-Ramirez, 28, of Hampton Bays was arrested at about 10 p.m. on April 27 and charged with ... by Staff Writer

Sand Mines Sue Southampton Town Over Amortization Law

Three companies controlled by John Tintle, who has been the strongest voice in support of ... by Stephen J. Kotz

Turkeys and Eagles

The turkey is the loudest thing in the predawn hours. A “gobble” descriptor does not come close to capturing his overture. From the distant darkness, it’s no songbird tuning-in when the turkey lets loose his call. So much like the bird itself, it’s a big and a slightly comical noise, followed then by a long silence. Saying nothing more, he flaps down from his roost to begin his day. There are ladies to court and toms to fight, grubs to be scratched from the earth. To be a turkey in Sagg is not so bad. No longer needing reintroduction, their ... by Marilee Foster

'Solving' the Traffic

It’s not fair to suggest that the last two weeks, when Southampton Town, with Suffolk County’s blessing, tested some various strategies for managing the flow of traffic westward in the afternoon rush hours, will be enough to “solve” anything. This is a Gordian knot, but Charlie McArdle is no Alexander the Great, sword in hand, ready to cut the snarl free. At best, the town’s highway superintendent is diligently picking at various parts of the heap, hoping to loosen it a tiny bit. Suffolk County officials were active participants this time, which is helpful, and they will be sitting down ... by Editorial Board