Southampton Village Architectural Review Board Closes Mocomanto Hearing - 27 East

Southampton Village Architectural Review Board Closes Mocomanto Hearing

icon 1 Photo
Mocomanto on Lake Agawam in Southampton Village.

Mocomanto on Lake Agawam in Southampton Village. DCIM100MEDIADJI_0344.JPG

authorGreg Wehner on Feb 28, 2018

The Southampton Village Board of Historic Preservation and Architectural Review voted on Monday to close the hearing on an application to nearly double the size of a 125-year-old home known as Mocomanto, clearing the way for a vote in April—though the decision split the board.

Chairman Curtis Highsmith, Christine Redding and the board’s newest member, Rob Coburn, voted for the hearing to be closed, while Susan Stevenson and Jeff Brodlieb voted against the motion.

“When these things are closed … the debate ends,” Mr. Brodlieb told board members before the vote. “I don’t support this application and will not vote for it.”

The proposed changes include nearly doubling the size of the residence at 472 First Neck Lane by adding a two-story addition to the north, along with a smaller one-story addition. The home is within the village’s historic district, though the structure itself has no official protection as a historic property.

According to a report issued on February 7 by the board’s historical consultant, Zachary Studenroth, the changes are “consistent with both local and national standards” and the scale is “visually subservient” to the existing home.

“That’s not subservient,” Ms. Stevenson told fellow board members on Monday. She added that alternative plans were presented by Siamak Samii, an architect who was hired by neighbors who oppose the project, showing that the homeowner, Ken Fox, can increase the size of the house and modernize it “without destroying the historic facade that is facing the lake, and without increasing the size so that it overpowers” the home.

While Mr. Highsmith noted that he appreciated Mr. Brodlieb’s and Ms. Stevenson’s comments, he reminded the ARB members that it is their responsibility to look at appropriateness. He added that the board is not charged with redesigning the home—nor is that a neighbor’s responsibility.

When asked whether any other changes would be submitted, John Bennett, the Southampton-based attorney representing Mr. Fox during the application process, said no.

Attorney Patrick Fife, who represents neighbors Joyce and Bob Giuffra and Whitney Stevens, submitted a new letter to the board hours before the meeting. In the letter, Mr. Fife reiterated many of his clients’ arguments against the project, citing its size and scale, and sought to ensure that the Secretary of the Interior’s Standards for the Treatment of Historic Properties are followed.

“My clients are not opposed to an addition to Mocomanto, but they believe the applicant must submit a plan for a more historically appropriate addition that respects Mocomanto’s original structure and comports with its history as the leading house during the establishment of Southampton’s resort community,” Mr. Fife said in his letter.

He also included a string of emails from Mr. Studenroth, including a November 16, 2017, email in which Mr. Highsmith said he would meet Mr. Studenroth at 472 First Neck Lane to get a firsthand look at the house. Mr. Fife suggested during Monday’s board meeting that Mr. Highsmith had met individually with the homeowner’s representatives—a suggestion that Mr. Highsmith later firmly denied.

“I met with no representative to discuss anything pertaining to 472 First Neck,” Mr. Highsmith said in an email to The Press on Tuesday. “This was a very important application, but I was unfamiliar with the site, and, therefore, it would be customary to do a site visit and not rely on only third-party information reported to me.

“I questioned the board if any member had communications with any opponents to the application, representative of the opponents, or the counsel, to offer the opportunity to disclose and put it on the record. My response remains an affirmed NO I HAVEN’T!” he added in the email.

Mr. Highsmith also asked members of the board on Monday, if they had communications with the applicant or representatives for the applicants, in an effort to put it on the record.

Though the board closed the hearing, written comments can still be submitted until Thursday, March 8. Mr. Highsmith told board members if new material is submitted that could change the minds of the board members, the hearing could be reopened for further dialogue.

If the hearing is not reopened, then a decision is expected to be announced at the ARB’s Monday, April 23, meeting.

You May Also Like:

Tracking Reality

Thank you for “Water Hogs” [“The Water Hogs of the Hamptons, 2025,” Residence, 27east.com, August 28], a deeply necessary, smart service to us all, tracking the reality — what the press can do. I teach a course in the spring, “Language as Action: Reading & Writing Water,” and I will use “Water Hogs.” Kathy Engel Sagaponack 15 Sep 2025 by Staff Writer

Rare Treasure

I am urging the Southampton Town Board to keep this land as is, regardless of classification [“Fate of Southampton Town-Owned Poxabogue Field, Within Sagaponack Village, Is Debated at Town Board Meeting,” 27east.com, September 10]. I understand that it is in consideration to be returned to an agricultural use, but it has become an increasingly rare treasure here on the East End: an “old field” environment that now serves as habitat for wildlife, as well as having become a natural water quality buffer to Poxabogue Pond. As development continues to insidiously encroach on our wild neighbors, we threaten that very unique ... by Staff Writer

Ecologically Important

I am a resident and voter in Sagaponack and Southampton Town. Poxabogue Field provides many important ecological services. It serves as: • A wildlife sanctuary, and if farmed, as projected, would be fenced and plowed, obliterating the wildlife that has come to live there. • A natural buffer protecting Poxabogue Pond, its wetlands, and our aquifer. • An important ecosystem for ground-nesting birds, like the American woodcock (photographed in the field last month by Jane Gill), salamanders and turtles, grasshoppers and beetles, butterflies and moths. • A shelter for foxes, rabbits, deer, field mice, raccoons, chipmunks and more. • An open, natural field vista. I believe ... by Staff Writer

Essential Programming

As many East End town residents know who tried to access their public, educational and government (PEG) channels recently, they were no longer available on channels 20 and 22. Instead you were directed to find your channels somewhere in the 1300s. Because of the hue and cry in Newsday and all the local East End print and online media, and by town and village officials and the PEG industry, Altice/Optimum later backtracked and promised to return the channels to their original slots “on or about September 16, 2025” [“Optimum Walks Back Public Access Shakeup With Plan To Restore LTV, Sea-TV ... by Staff Writer

Bought and Sold

I am writing in response to last week’s letter, “Pay To Play” [September 11]. At first, some of the names mentioned sounded familiar, but I couldn’t put my finger on it. Then it hit me. Leon Black — a billionaire campaign donor to Mayor Bill Manger, Robin Brown and their slate — was the same Leon Black that I had just read about in The New York Times, who allegedly sent Jeffrey Epstein a birthday card. The U.S. Senate Finance Committee stated that Black paid Epstein at least $158 million. The horrible accusations surrounding him go further, though many are ... by Staff Writer

Community News, September 18

YOUTH CORNER Read and Play The John Jermain Memorial Library, 201 Main Street in Sag ... by Staff Writer

School News, September 18, Southampton Town

As Hampton Bays educators prepared their classrooms for the first day of school, they also ... by Staff Writer

Bridgehampton Museum's Fall Fundraiser Is at The Bridge

The Bridgehampton Museum will host its fall fundraiser, Cocktails at the Bridge, on Saturday, October 4, from 5 to 7 p.m. at The Bridge golf club in Bridgehampton. This year’s event will honor two longtime museum supporters: past president Gerrit Vreeland and former board member John Millard. According to a press release, their vision, leadership, and perseverance were instrumental in the acquisition and restoration of the Nathaniel Rogers House, the historic landmark that now anchors the east end of Main Street in Bridgehampton. Along with the rest of the board at the time, Vreeland and Millard raised much of the ... by Staff Writer

Sponsorships Available for Golf Outing at Sebonack

The Suffolk Community College Foundation will host its 41st Annual Golf Classic on Monday, October 20, at Sebonack Golf Club in Southampton. While the event is sold out, a limited number of sponsorship opportunities are still available. Proceeds from the Golf Classic will benefit student scholarships and academic programs at Suffolk County Community College. This year’s honoree is Ryan T. Kesner, principal of Ryan T. Kesner Architect PC, a leading architectural firm based in Southampton. A proud alumnus of Suffolk County Community College, Kesner has played a pivotal role in shaping Long Island’s architectural landscape, with more than one million ... by Staff Writer

Working Diligently

On Thursday, I attended the Southampton Village Board meeting on traffic and realized I had previously misspoken. I said the trustees had taken only “baby steps” in addressing this issue. I was wrong. The truth is, they have been working diligently for months, but their efforts are constrained by town, state and federal laws, as well as by the legitimate concerns of neighbors who are directly affected by traffic changes. The mayor and trustees deserve our appreciation for their tireless efforts. One theme was clear at the meeting: No neighbor should shoulder more of the burden than another. Whatever action ... by Staff Writer