Southampton Village ZBA Sued Over Denying Residential Use In Office District - 27 East

Southampton Village ZBA Sued Over Denying Residential Use In Office District

icon 1 Photo
99 Sanford Place in Southampton Village.  DANA SHAW

99 Sanford Place in Southampton Village. DANA SHAW

Brendan J. O’Reilly on Dec 8, 2021

The owner of 99 Sanford Place, an office building off North Sea Road in Southampton Village, is suing the Village Zoning Board of Appeals after the ZBA rejected an application to change the use of the property from office to residential.

The lawsuit seeks to reverse the ZBA’s decision and asks the State Supreme Court to force the village to pay attorney’s fees.

The owner, who is identified only as 99 Sanford Place LLC, wants to subdivide the 51,955-square-foot property into two lots then raze the former Platt, Platt & Platt law office and build two single-family residences in its place. In addition to needing subdivision approval from the Village Planning Board, the owner needs a special exception permit from the ZBA to allow for residences in an office district.

When the request was brought before the ZBA in June, the chairman, Mark Greenwald, noted that the village’s comprehensive plan from the year 2000 called for an analysis of the office district, but the analysis never happened. He suggested that the applicant pay for a study of the entire office district so the ZBA could make an informed decision and consider whether granting the request would change the character of the community. He pointed to a provision in the village code that puts the onus of paying for professional review by an expert, on the applicant.

Attorney Liz Vail of the law firm Farrell Fritz, who was representing the applicant, told Greenwald that only the Village Board had the authority to order planning studies. “You are the Zoning Board of Appeals,” she said. “You are not the legislative board of the Village of Southampton.”

The Village Board has decided that residential use was permitted in the office district and the application conforms with the comprehensive plan and subsequent planning studies, Vail said.

She further argued that 99 Sanford Place is located in an area that is already has more residences than commercial properties and that the ZBA had recently granted the same request to an applicant on White Street.

One board member agreed with Vail.

“We’re overstepping our bounds when we ask for a study of the office district,” then-ZBA member Kevin Guidera said. He wanted to approve the application immediately.

David Gilmartin, Vail’s fellow attorney at Farrell Fritz, followed up with proof that the ZBA granted a special exception permit for a residential use across the street from 99 Sanford Place and provided letters from neighbors on the street who supported a “less obtrusive” residential use to an office.

In a 3-1 vote at its September 23 meeting, the board turned down the request. Greenwald, Julia McCormack and Joyce Guiffra were in the majority and Susan Stevenson was in the minority. The fifth ZBA seat was vacant at the time.

“It is the determination of the Board that the application here has not met with the required criteria,” the written ZBA decision states. “As such, it is the determination of this Board that allowing the special use exception in this case would adversely affect the neighborhood.”

According to the eight-page decision, those criteria include protecting the established character and social and economic well-being of private and private property and promoting the use of land for the public interest.

Meanwhile, Gilmartin has brought a subdivision application to the Planning Board to allow for two office buildings instead of one.

At their November 29 meeting, members of the Planning Board were baffled by the ZBA’s decision.

“My client had hoped to have residential structures there, which we thought would be more appropriate,” Gilmartin explained to the Planning Board. “But the zoning board did not agree with that.”

“That’s a shame,” said Planning Board Chairman Tony Piazza.

Gilmartin said the decision makes very little sense, but “it is what it is.”

You May Also Like:

King James Is Latest Headliner To Work Out at Southampton High School Gym

Jimmy Butler, Draymond Green, Kyle Kuzma, Kevin Love, J.J. Redick, Myles Turner. And now LeBron ... 1 Jul 2025 by Drew Budd

Where Have the Bunker Gone?

So where are all the bunker? After building steadily for a decade, the number of ... by MIKE WRIGHT

Tyler Breaks Through With First Win at Long Island Women’s Amateur Stroke Play Championship

That’s one. After only joining the professional golf circuit a few months ago, at which ... by Drew Budd

After Three-Year Layoff, Hampton Bays Returns to District 36 Tournament With Softball Team

For the first time in three years, Hampton Bays Little League entered a team into ... by Drew Budd

Southampton Could Add Girls Flag Football as Early as Next Spring

Girls in the Southampton School District may be getting a chance to play flag football. ... by Drew Budd

SYS To Host Third Annual Summer of Wellness Slate With New Pickleball Tournaments That Has Open Slots

The third annual Summer of Wellness presented by the Southampton Hospital Foundation will be taking place at Southampton Youth Services for the first time ever on Saturday, July 19, and included in what is a slate chock full of activities that run from 8 a.m. to 11 a.m. is a pair of pickleball tournaments that still have some open team slots available. The first tournament is for recreational players and runs from 8:30 to 9:30 a.m. The second tournament is for advanced players and will run from 9:30 to 10:30 a.m. Presented by the Southampton Hospital Foundation’s Vision Board, this ... by Staff Writer

34th Annual Firecracker 8K Is This Sunday

The 34th annual Firecracker 8K, along with a 3-mile walk, in memory of Roy Wines Jr., past Southampton Rotary district governor, is set for this Sunday, July 6, in Southampton Village. The 7:30 a.m. rain or shine race begins and ends at Agawam Park, located at 25 Pond Lane, Southampton. The Firecracker 8K is the primary fundraiser for the Southampton Rotary Scholarship and Endowment Fund, which provides local students with scholarships and supports other important community groups across Southampton Town, including local fire and ambulance squads, Little League and other youth groups, food banks and other nonprofits like the Ellen ... by Drew Budd

Have You Hit the Wall in Your Pickleball Skills? Part Two: Becoming a Skilled Attacker

My last column focused on drilling to improve your soft game around the kitchen, and ... by Vinny Mangano

Weekly Ticket Packages Available for the 126th U.S. Open at Shinnecock Hills Golf Club

With the 2025 U.S. Open at Oakmont — where championship round tickets sold out — now in the books, fans can now secure their spot for next year’s national championship. Weekly ticket packages are on sale for the 2026 U.S. Open, set for June 15-21 at iconic Shinnecock Hills Golf Club, where the world’s best will once again compete for golf’s ultimate prize. Now available at usopen.com, various weekly ticket options include gallery, Trophy Club, Champions Pavilion and reserved grandstand, as well as special food and beverage bonus packages. Juniors 12 and under with a ticketed or credentialed adult can ... by Staff Writer

In a Time of Need, Friends Give OLA a Boost at Sag Harbor Fundraiser

Kidd Squid Brewing Company in Sag Harbor was packed on Thursday, June 26, as well ... by Stephen J. Kotz