State Supreme Court Sides With Southampton Village ZBA in Sanford Place Case - 27 East

State Supreme Court Sides With Southampton Village ZBA in Sanford Place Case

icon 1 Photo
The office building at 99 Sanford Place, where the owner wished to subdivide the property and build two residences.  DANA SHAW

The office building at 99 Sanford Place, where the owner wished to subdivide the property and build two residences. DANA SHAW

Brendan J. O’Reilly on Sep 27, 2022

A State Supreme Court justice has sided with the Southampton Village Zoning Board of Appeals after the ZBA denied a property owner’s application for a special exception permit to build two residences in the village’s office district.

On Tuesday, September 20, Justice Linda Kevins dismissed a petition that had asked the court to annul the ZBA’s September 2021 denial of 99 Sanford Place LLC’s permit application.

Among other arguments, the petition contended that the ZBA had recently granted a special exception permit request in a similar situation on White Street and had a responsibility to adhere to that precedent by also approving the Sanford Place application.

The justice did not see it that way.

“Although a zoning board is bound to follow its own precedents … the court found that the unrelated matter is sufficiently distinguishable from the present case,” Kevins wrote in dismissing the petition to annul the ruling.

The property owner had wanted to subdivide 99 Sanford Place, where the former Platt Platt & Platt law office currently stands, into two lots and develop a residence on each. The Planning Board could approve the subdivision, but to build residences in the office district a special exception permit from the ZBA would be required. In a 3-1 vote, the board turned down the permit request.

At a meeting three months prior to the board rejecting the permit request, ZBA Chairman Mark Greenwald noted that the village’s comprehensive plan from the year 2000 called for an analysis of the office district that never happened, and he suggested that the applicant pay for a study of the entire office district. That way, he explained, the board could make an informed decision on whether granting the permit would be wise and whether it would change the character of the community. He pointed to a provision in the village code that puts the onus of paying for professional review by an expert on the applicant.

Attorney Liz Vail, who was representing the applicant, had told Greenwald that only the Village Board has the authority to order planning studies. “You are the Zoning Board of Appeals,” she said. “You are not the legislative board of the Village of Southampton.”

Vail argued that the Village Board had already decided that residential use was permitted in the office district and that the application conforms with the comprehensive plan and subsequent planning studies. She also told the ZBA that 99 Sanford Place is in an area that has more residences than commercial properties.

Kevins wrote that the ZBA “submitted sufficient evidence to demonstrate the rationality of the Zoning Board’s denial of the application” and that the property owner “failed to demonstrate that the proposed project ‘… is particularly suitable for the location in the community.’”

You May Also Like:

Southampton July 4th Parade Delights Crowd

The Southampton July Fourth parade was held on Friday morning and did not disappoint with ... 7 Jul 2025 by Staff Writer

Come and Tell Us

When Tim Bishop was our congressman, he held numerous town hall meetings with his constituents. They were raucous affairs. Those were the days of the Tea Party, and its members were outraged that the federal government was expanding health care insurance to millions of Americans. And they let Congressman Bishop know it. Usually loudly and sometimes rudely. They seemed unmoved that thousands of their fellow Americans were being driven to bankruptcy by medical debt. They were unconcerned that thousands were dying prematurely due to their lack of access to affordable health care. Many I spoke to seemed more worried that ... by Staff Writer

A Suggestion

I have a suggestion for Craig Catalanotto, who is on record for opposing cross-endorsements and for allegedly switching alliances from Democratic to Republican Party candidates, such as Cyndi McNamara and Stephen Kiely. When the Pine Barrens Commission was in the process of reviewing a proposed golf course development in East Quogue (known as the Lewis Road Planned Residential District, or PRD), I wrote to the commission recommending that a task force be formed to investigate land use on the Lewis Road corridor. The area in question is easy to investigate. One side of Lewis Road includes a sand mine adjacent ... by Staff Writer

Followed Their Lead

While I respect the journalistic integrity of The Southampton Press, I disagree with your editorial awarding the Southampton Village Ethics Board a “dunce cap” for Open Meetings Law violations [“Gold Stars and Dunce Caps,” Editorial, July 3]. The Ethics Board may very well have failed to follow procedural notice requirements. But the dunce cap belongs to the village mayor and his board majority, whose job it is to ensure that all appointed boards receive proper, up-to-date training in the Open Meetings Law and Freedom of Information Law. The mayor and board must mandate training for themselves and all regulatory boards. ... by Staff Writer

Shooting Wildly

As a 30-year litigation-scarred veteran of the sand mining/composting wars waged in Southampton Village and Town, I am a proponent of the amortization of sand mines proposed by the town. In our battles, we were up against the “pre-existing use” free pass, and the town’s and village’s “maintenance” of the sites to dump whatever they chose to, and their reluctance to enforce existing laws, or impose any oversight, which allowed for all manner of activities to flourish. Thrown into the trenches, we learned firsthand how the public was ignored, then penalized; how the inspectors applied existing law selectively; how the ... by Staff Writer

Wonderful Turnout

On behalf of the Fourth of July Parade Committee and the Southampton Village Commission on Veterans Patriotic Events, I would like to thank the community for such a wonderful turnout for the Fourth of July parade. I would like to thank the Village of Southampton employees, police department and Chief Suzanne Hurteau, fire department and Chief Polis Walker, Volunteer Ambulance and Chief Christopher Epley, and the Board of Trustees and Mayor Bill Manger. I also would like to thank the large group of volunteers who stepped up this year when we were concerned that we were not generating enough support ... by Staff Writer

A More Nimble Plan

“It feels like Southampton has lost its soul.” That’s how one local merchant recently described the state of our village business district. Many would agree. Local businesses reported a soft July 4, but a much better July 5 and 6. Just a few miles away, East Hampton and Sag Harbor reported a record weekend. In East Hampton, stores are now staying open late to meet the demand. Southampton Village, by contrast, looked neglected. Trash swirled in the air. Sidewalks were stained and littered with candy wrappers and gum. Mismatched waste receptacles overflowed. This is not the look or feel of ... by Staff Writer

A Simpler Solution

It has taken me a few weeks to respond to the recent “Cup o’ Joe” newsletter, where Executive Editor Joe Shaw ventured onto an editorial limb, venting about village issues, particularly the controversy surrounding Pond Lane. Let’s set the record straight. First, a beautiful proposal, indeed, was submitted to convert the vacant parcel of land into a park. However, this initial proposal did not involve closing Pond Lane. The subsequent idea of transforming Pond Lane into a bike and walking path — what I regard as “the bike path to nowhere” — is impractical at best. You implied that I ... by Staff Writer

SAT Prep Course Offered by Child Care Center

The Bridgehampton Child Care & Recreational Center is offering an SAT prep course ahead of the August 23 test date. Classes will be held Mondays in July and August, with an additional session on Wednesday, August 13, from 6 to 9 p.m.
The cost is $40 and includes a workbook; scholarships are available. To register, email Camryn@bhccrc.org or call 631-537-0616. The center is located at 551 Bridgehampton-Sag Harbor Turnpike.
“SAT Prep can be an important part of that journey,” said executive director Bonnie Michelle Cannon. by Staff Writer

Jazz Mass In Bridgehampton On Sunday

St Ann’s Episcopal Church on Main Street in Bridgehampton will host its annual Jazz Mass on Sunday, July 13, at 10 a.m. All are welcome. The band will include Ada Rovatti and Eric Schugren on saxophone; Mike Gari, guitar; John Mele, drums; and Steve Shaughnessy, bass. The choir will sing Bob Chilcott’s “Little Jazz Mass,” and all are encouraged to join in singing the hymns. A hospitality hour for all follows the service. by Staff Writer