New Plans Presented For Mocomanto Addition - 27 East

Real Estate News

Real Estate News / 1398482

New Plans Presented For Mocomanto Addition

icon 2 Photos
Mocomanto in Southampton Village.  DANA SHAW

Mocomanto in Southampton Village. DANA SHAW

authorGreg Wehner on Jan 8, 2018

The team behind a proposal to expand the Southampton Village estate section home Mocomanto presented plans in December that reduce the size of a proposed addition, while also trying to restore the look of the residence to how it appeared in the 1920s.The revised plans were submitted in response to the Southampton Village Board of Historic Preservation and Architectural Review members’ wariness toward the original plans’ use of a modern-looking connector that would join the historic home, located at 472 First Neck Lane, with an addition creating an L-shape.

On November 27, members of the board gave their first round of input on the project, and all agreed that the connector, which would be used as a kitchen and would be surrounded by glass, needed a little work. At the time, Chairman Curtis Highsmith told the architect and the attorney representing the homeowner, Ken Fox, that the connector appeared to be a “foreign element.”

“We went back to the drawing board,” said Lisa Zaloga, the architect working on the project. “We’ve now relocated the addition; we’ve detached the garage.”

Ms. Zaloga told board members in December that the two-story addition is very reminiscent of photos of Mocomanto from the 1920s.

The wing will be flush with the north side of the home, and appear as one continuous wall.

Initially, the addition would have included the garage, but now the plans call for a detached garage. Ms. Zaloga described the garage as 16 feet high, very simple and reminiscent of the barns that were on the property at one time.

John Bennett, Mr. Fox’s Southampton Village-based attorney, said the new addition will still have only nine bedrooms, 
and the coverage in the 150-foot wetland setback that was approved by the Southampton Village Zoning Board of Appeals will be the same.

He added that the proposed addition will be 24 feet, 11 inches high.

“This is going to take a lot of review, but certainly what is being proposed is within the spirit of the history of the structure itself, which is 180 degrees of what we have seen before,” said Zachary Studenroth, the board’s architectural consultant.

Patrick B. Fife, an attorney representing neighbors in opposition to Mr. Fox’s project, submitted a letter to the Board of Historic Preservation and Architectural Review expressing his clients’ discontent with the proposal.

Specifically, Mr. Fife addressed a report put together by architect Jonathan S. Foster, who was hired by the neighbors to review the project.

“In Mr. Foster’s opinion, the Applicant’s proposed northern addition is historically inappropriate because it is out of proportion with the size, scale and massing of the existing house,” Mr. Fife wrote. “The proposed addition is also inconsistent with the size, scale and massing of Mocomanto’s previous northern wing.”

According to Mr. Fife, the proposed 57-foot-long addition would be 143 percent longer than Mocomanto’s 40-foot eastern-facing facade and the footprint would be 90 percent larger than the historic home’s existing footprint.

Even more so, Mr. Fife said the addition would continue to be inconsistent with the village code’s standards and the Secretary of the Interior’s standard number nine, which says additions to historic structures “shall be differentiated from the old and will be compatible with the historic materials, features, size, scale and proportion, and massing to protect the integrity of the property and its environment.”

The hearing was expected to continue at the next Board of Historic Preservation and Architectural Review meeting, which was scheduled for Monday, January 8, at 7 p.m. at Southampton Village Hall.

You May Also Like:

The Gables: New Condo Community Rises in Westhampton Beach

Phase 2 is underway at The Gables at Westhampton Beach, the new 45-unit condominium community ... 10 Sep 2025 by Brendan J. O’Reilly

Noble Black Rejoins Corcoran

Top real estate agent Noble Black and his team, Noble Black & Partners, have joined ... 9 Sep 2025 by Staff Writer

Modern Water Mill Residence With Panoramic Water Views Sells for $22.5M

An ultramodern waterfront home in Water Mill with a rooftop deck that has panoramic water ... 3 Sep 2025 by Staff Writer

Jennifer Brew and Charlotte Sasso Join Saunders & Associates

Jennifer Brew and Charlotte Sasso, two Hamptons real estate veterans, have joined Saunders & Associates. ... 28 Aug 2025 by Staff Writer

Southampton Village Estate Sells for $16.5 Million

A traditional estate built in Southampton Village in the private community of Pheasant Pond in ... by Staff Writer

Water Mill Compound Sells for $17 Million

An approximately 3-acre Water Mill compound with two legal residences — including one that integrates ... 25 Aug 2025 by Staff Writer

Hamptons Real Estate Roundtable August 2025

At the midpoint of summer, The Express News Group asked Hamptons real estate professionals from ... 14 Aug 2025 by Moderated by Brendan J. O’Reilly

CPF and CHF Revenue for the First Half of 2025

The Peconic Bay Community Preservation Fund and Peconic Bay Community Housing Fund brought in nearly ... by Staff Writer

Waterfront Residence in Water Mill Sells for $12.63 Million

A Water Mill residence built in 1987 fronting a cove that leads to Mecox Bay ... 12 Aug 2025 by Staff Writer

Serhant Agents Form 'Hamptons Home Team'

Dawn Watson of Serhant, in collaboration with fellow agents Lisa Oehler and Catherine Smyth, has ... 5 Aug 2025 by Staff Writer