IRS Rules Septic Grant Recipients Should Receive 1099s And Pay Taxes On Funds - 27 East

IRS Rules Septic Grant Recipients Should Receive 1099s And Pay Taxes On Funds

icon 1 Photo
The Internal Revenue Service has stated that Suffolk County residents who have received grants for septic upgrades should pay tax on the funds. PRESS FILE

The Internal Revenue Service has stated that Suffolk County residents who have received grants for septic upgrades should pay tax on the funds. PRESS FILE

Brendan J. O’Reilly on Feb 12, 2020

The Internal Revenue Service has issued a ruling that deals a blow to Suffolk County’s septic replacement grant program — and means there will be a tax liability for grant recipients after all.

The IRS determined that recipients of grants to replace cesspools and aging septic systems with innovative and alternative nitrogen-reducing systems should pay federal income taxes on the grant proceeds.

County Comptroller John Kennedy had requested an IRS ruling last spring after he was blasted for issuing 1099 tax forms to both the grant recipients and the installers who put in the septic systems. The grant program was initiated to reduce nitrogen loading in Suffolk County bays and ponds and, as a result, improve the water quality.

Critics accused Mr. Kennedy, a Republican, of making politically motivated decisions to undermine the septic improvement program, a hallmark initiative of County Executive Steve Bellone, a Democrat. Mr. Kennedy — who was the Suffolk County Legislature minority leader before being elected comptroller in 2015 — unsuccessfully challenged Mr. Bellone for county executive in 2019 as they also butted head over the 1099s.

Mr. Kennedy last year said it was his understanding that both the grant recipient and the company being paid to conduct the work should be issued a federal tax form, and that he was doing what was necessary so that the county would not be fined by the federal government.

“The decision by County Comptroller John M. Kennedy to issue 1099 tax forms to Suffolk homeowners have cost them thousands of dollars that they otherwise would not have to pay for installing new advanced septic systems to reduce nitrogen pollution and improve our water quality,” Mr. Bellone said in a statement Wednesday morning. “But then Comptroller Kennedy went even further — he chose to seek an IRS opinion, against the advice of the county’s tax counsel, as part of his scheme, and the IRS has now decided to go along with this costly plan.”

In the IRS ruling dated January 15, Branch Chief Angella L. Warren wrote that, whether paid directly to homeowners or to third-party contractors on their behalf, the grants are included in the homeowners’ gross income, and Suffolk County is required to report it to the IRS.

U.S. Senator Charles Schumer of New York, who last spring called upon the IRS not to tax the homeowners, criticized the decision in a statement Tuesday.

“The IRS got this flat wrong, because the local program is a win-win for Suffolk homeowners and the environment, which is overrun with nitrogen pollution in our waterways,” Mr. Schumer said. “Homeowners and Suffolk County are already taxed by nitrogen and shouldn’t also get a bill from the IRS for trying to reduce it. Uncle Sam isn’t losing out on a dime when a Suffolk homeowner participates in this grant program, because the local contractors are already paying the tax — it’s just that simple.”

Deputy County Executive Peter Scully, who serves as Mr. Bellone’s water czar, said in a phone call on Tuesday that the program had previously been retooled so that grant checks went only to the installers — not the homeowners — with the goal being that the grant recipients would not be subject to taxes.

He said one person involved in discussions about what to do next observed: “We shouldn’t really be surprised. The IRS is in the business of collecting revenue, and asking them whether they think we should tax this revenue stream is like asking a dog if it wants a piece of steak — they’re unlikely to say anything other than ‘yes.’”

The average cost of a nitrogen-reducing septic system is $21,900, according to Suffolk County, and grants can be as much as $30,000 per income-qualified household. The towns of East Hampton and Southampton offer grants of up to $20,000, using Community Preservation Fund money, which, combined with the county grants can reduce the cost to the homeowner to $0.

But the IRS ruling could make those amounts received by the homeowner taxable income.

“It’s unfortunate that the comptroller made a decision to seek this private letter ruling and fund the request with taxpayer dollars, to add insult to injury,” Mr. Scully said. “And the outcome, while unexpected, is unfortunate.”

He noted that similar programs administrated by the Catskill Watershed Corporation and the Maryland Department of the Environment do not issue 1099 forms to homeowners — a fact that Suffolk County officials confirmed with administrators of those programs back in 2017. Rather, the vendors receive the tax forms and are responsible for the taxes.

He added, “This issue is too important, and we need to find a way to tweak the program so homeowners are protected.”

Mr. Scully said that even though applications had been modified last year to make homeowners aware that they could be subject to income tax if they receive a grant, completed applications are pouring in at record numbers. In January, 111 applications from county residents were received, compared to just 40 in January last year.

He said it is obvious that some people have decided not to move forward, but there are still so many applications that it is hard to keep up with the pace — and many applications are coming from the South Fork.

“Let’s be clear — the comptroller’s actions have been contrary to the intent of the Suffolk County Drinking Water Protection Program, the legal opinion by the county’s tax counsel, and longstanding practices used by similar programs in Maryland and other municipal jurisdictions,” Mr. Bellone said in his statement. “He chose to politicize water quality and decimate a program that has been praised by environmental, labor and business leaders alike.”

Mr. Kennedy did not respond to requests made to his office Tuesday for comment, and county offices were closed Wednesday for President Abraham Lincoln’s Birthday.

Mr. Scully said that Mr. Bellone intends to work with other elected officials to find a solution that protects homeowners, which could include changes to the grant program or a legislative fix. Discussions have begun with Mr. Schumer U.S. Representative Tom Suozzi, whose district includes parts of Suffolk and Nassau counties, as well as Queens.

Mr. Suozzi sent a letter opposing the ruling to IRS Commissioner Charles Rettig on Tuesday.

“I strongly oppose this decision, as it undermines the program’s mission, and similarly constructed programs such as the State of Maryland’s Bay Restoration Fund did not require 1099 forms to be issued to homeowners,” the letter reads.

Mr. Suozzi cited the contributions that cesspools and septic systems have made to declining water quality in touting the septic replacement program.

“I am eager to discuss potential solutions to help protect our environment and groundwater without putting additional onus on Suffolk County homeowners who are already struggling with the recent cap on their state and local tax deductions,” the letter concludes.

You May Also Like:

Westhampton Beach Cheerleaders Take National Stage

Lana Blowes stepped on stage and couldn’t contain her excitement. While there were some nerves ... 16 Feb 2025 by Desirée Keegan

'With Love From the SHM': Southampton History Museum Postcards Offer a Window Into the Past

Inside the archive of the Southampton History Museum sits a vast yet unassuming time capsule ... by Michelle Trauring

Bringing Art to Life: Esly Escobar’s Mission to Inspire Young Creatives in Guatemala

Standing in front of a group of curious students, Esly Escobar held up a potato ... 15 Feb 2025 by Michelle Trauring

Candidates To Debate On February 25

The Hampton Bays Civic Association will host a debate/forum for candidates running in the special election for the open seat on the Southampton Town Board. The debate/forum will be held on Monday, February 24, at Hampton Bays Middle School, 70 Ponquogue Avenue in Hampton Bays, from 7 to 8:45 p.m. Former Southampton Town Councilman Rick Martel will face John Leonard in the March 18 special election for the open seat on the Southampton Town Board. The winner will serve until the end of this year, completing the term vacated by Tommy John Schiavoni, who was elected to the New York ... by Staff Writer

Construction Career Scholarship Applications Being Accepted

The Construction Career Charitable Fund has opened applications for its 2025 scholarship program. High school seniors from Westhampton to Montauk, who are planning careers in the construction trades industry immediately after graduation, may apply. With awards of up to $10,000, the CCCF is dedicated to supporting local students with a passion for the trades, providing both financial assistance and career resources. In addition to scholarships, CCCF offers mentorship and job placement assistance, connecting students with leading area contractors in fields such as carpentry, electrical work, plumbing, and more. By partnering with local school districts and top-tier trades professionals, CCCF ensures ... by Staff Writer

Hurdles To Clear

It was a culinary and historic disaster: bird flu striking the Crescent Duck Farm, the last duck farm on Long Island. Some 99,000 ducks, the farm’s entire flock, had to be euthanized because of bird flu. The future of the Crescent Duck Farm involves several thousand eggs. Not only is Crescent Farm the last of what had been many duck farms on Long Island, it has produced — and I think many would agree — the finest ducks to eat, certainly in the nation and probably in the world. “Crescent Duck was started by Henry Corwin in 1908 in Aquebogue ... by Karl Grossman

No Good Reason

Donald Trump always begins with a big lie, which becomes viral through X and Fox News. His newest big lie: The federal workforce is the Deep State, bloated, filled with waste and fraud, pushing useless regulations, with employees sitting home not working. It needs to be dismantled. None of this is true. But Trump and Elon Musk want the public to believe their lie and turn a blind eye to the destruction of the federal government. America needs to wake up before Trump/Musk gut the regulations and federal agencies that keep us safe. It should be noted, many of the ... by Staff Writer

Constant Churn

Kevin Menard said he would like to solicit help from a business school to undertake a study of business conditions [“Sag Harbor Businesses Say They See More Visitors, but Fewer Customers,” 27east.com, February 5]. May I suggest a simple way to evaluate the problem? Buy a Jenga game. The tower of blocks where play is simply pulling one block out, turn by turn, until one is pulled out and the entire tower collapses. Label the bottom four blocks “poverty.” Label the top four blocks the “20 percent.” Everything else is the middle class. Need I make further explanation? The tower ... by Staff Writer

Enforce Zoning

People purchasing property have the expectation that the Town of Southampton’s zoning laws protect the area’s scenic beauty and rural charm. These laws aren’t just promises, they’re commitments to preserving the character and identity of this cherished community. When my wife and I bought our house in Water Mill almost 20 years ago, we paid a premium for the beautiful, unrestricted views and felt reassured that the property next door came encumbered with an easement whose purpose is to “protect the scenic, open space and rural character of the town and to protect the town’s resort and agricultural economy.” The ... by Staff Writer

Meets the Criteria

I am writing to recommend John Leonard for the Southampton Town Council, for the opening to be voted on in the special election on March 18, for the position Tommy John Schiavoni vacated when elected to the New York State Assembly. We all know it is hard to decide on whom to support for leadership in our democracy, especially after watching the selection of the cabinet for our president. What do we look for in a candidate? I think the best criteria should include intelligence, career choices and relevant experience in government. These are the best predictors of success — ... by Staff Writer