Police Reports / News / Southampton Press / 2404749

UPDATE: Body of Second Kayaker Recovered From Shinnecock Bay

2 Photos

Southampton Town Police said Shane Garcia, left, sent this selfie of himself and his friend, Aaron Montemarano, to his girlfriend when they were kayaking on Saturday, November 1.

Shane Garcia

UPDATE: MONDAY, 4:50 PM

Southampton Town Police announced this afternoon that the body of Aaron Montemarano, 25, of Riverhead had been recovered from Shinnecock Bay at approximately 11:30 a.m.

Montemarano and his friend, Shane Garcia, 27, of Southampton went out kayaking on Saturday and were reported missing when they did not return that evening. Garcia’s body was found on Sunday.

Police said drones and 4-by-4 vehicles were used to search the area on Monday and that New York State Police divers recovered Montemarano’s body.

UPDATE: SUNDAY, 9 P.M.

The body of 27-year-old Shane Garcia, of Southampton, was recovered in Shinnecock Bay on Sunday afternoon, Southampton Town Police said. The search for Aaron Montemarano, 25, of Riverhead, continued until police suspended their efforts due to darkness.

The men went kayaking in Shinnecock Bay in Hampton Bays on Saturday but did not return home and were reported missing.

Police renewed their search at about 6 a.m. on Sunday. At about 12:30 p.m., New York State Police and Southampton Town Marine Patrol Units were patrolling Shinnecock Bay when they came upon two kayaks washed ashore as well as two paddles in the vicinity of Shinnecock East County Park, police said.

Officers with the town’s detective division responded to the area to continue the investigation. They were assisted by other officers as well as the department’s drone unit. A Suffolk County Police Department helicopter assisted, as did state police divers.

Police said after marine patrol officers located “an area of interest,” state police divers searched the area and recovered Garcia’s body.

ORIGINAL STORY:

Two men who were out on a two-person kayak in Shinnecock Bay near the Ponquogue Bridge on Sunday, November 1, are missing.

Southampton Town Police said Shane Garcia, 27, and Aaron Montemarano, 25, went out on Garcia’s lime green, ocean kayak earlier in the day. Garcia sent a photograph of the two men on his kayak to his girlfriend, who reported to police at 8:44 p.m. that he had not returned.

Police found Garcia’s work van parked at the end of Shinnecock Avenue in Hampton Bays. Police said a search of Shinnecock Bay and the surrounding area proved fruitless.

Garcia has been described as 6-foot 2-inches tall and weighing 185 pounds. Police said he was wearing a gray jacket and shirt, black pants and tan Nike sneakers. A description of Montemarano was not provided by police. In the photograph, he appeared to be wearing a gray jacket and black hooded sweatshirt, brown pants and a New York Yankees cap.

Anyone with information about the incident has been asked to call the town police detective division at 631-728-3400 or the town police TIPS hotline at 631-728-3454. Information can also be sent to police by email, to crimetips@southamptontownny.gov .

Hampton Bays Girls Volleyball Team Shows Heart Despite 3-0 Semifinal Loss to Hills West

The scoreboard told one story, but their effort told another. And it’s how the Hampton ... 3 Nov 2025 by Desirée Keegan

Mattituck Ends Southampton Girls Volleyball's Bid for Second Consecutive County Final Appearance

Eying its second-straight Suffolk County Class B Championship appearance, the Southampton girls volleyball team fell ... by Drew Budd

Southampton Boys Soccer Falls to Eventual County Champion Babylon in County Semis

The Southampton boys soccer team, staked to a 1-0 halftime lead, was 40 minutes away ... by Drew Budd

Useless Durak

In a recent post, Ed Surgan paraphrased an article he claims was from Newsday about the “No Kings” rally: “Demonstrators were concerned with cuts to Medicare, government job cuts and free speech. While the first two may be legitimate differences over policy, they pose no threat to democracy.” Here is an actual quote from Newsday: “Thousands of protesters at more than a dozen locations from Port Washington to East Hampton rallied Saturday to denounce what they view as an increasingly authoritarian regime under the Trump administration. … Dozens of protesters interviewed in Mineola, Port Jefferson and Patchogue voiced concern over ... by Staff Writer

Turned Away

Perhaps to close out the discussion of the Working Families Party candidates, local voters should be aware of what happened during the primary election earlier this year. I work as a poll official in Westhampton Beach, and we had a total of eight voters come in to cast ballots all day. None of them was a registered Working Families Party voter. And so, although they were well meaning, we had to turn them away, thanking them nonetheless for trying to exercise their right to vote. There were at least 10 poll officials seated all day, from 6 a.m. to 9 ... by Staff Writer

Growing Silent

According to 27east.com, intense rainfall led to “significant scour and erosion” on the west side of the Sunrise Highway bridge abutment over the Shinnecock Canal in Hampton Bays [“Lane Restrictions on Sunrise Highway Will Last at Least Through Next Week,” 27east.com, October 31]. Many commuters are experiencing this firsthand. These kinds of rain events will become more commonplace here and elsewhere due to the increase in water vapor in the atmosphere. Water vapor is increasing because our planet is heating. Scientists tell us this: “For every degree Celsius in warming, the water-holding capacity of the atmosphere increases by about 7 ... by Staff Writer

Tom Zaloga of Riverhead Dies October 27

Tom Zaloga of Riverhead died on October 27. He was 79. Born on March 17, ... by Staff Writer

Oddly Misguided

Last week’s Express Session at The American Hotel focused on the subject of parking [“Sag Harbor Panel Tackles Parking Problems, Business Impacts at ‘Local Matters’ Discussion,” 27east.com, October 29]. The format called for the audience to ask questions of the panelists, unlike prior Express Sessions, where preprepared subjects were given to the panel by the moderator for comment. About halfway through this meeting, former Mayor Jim LaRocca rose to deliver an off-topic statement critical of the village’s review boards’ conduct regarding the 2 Main Street/7-Eleven properties on West Water Street. Mr. LaRocca suggested that the review boards were working in ... by Staff Writer

Poisoned Dialogue

To John Neely [“Get Facts Right,” Letters, October 23], thank you for your comments. I’ll try to address them briefly. James Comey, John Brennan and James Clapper seriously damaged the United States’ reputation for fairness and justice. They have been exposed for using politically motivated lies to subvert our presidency. There is plenty of evidence to back up my argument. Unfortunately, it will be difficult to convict, due to legal statutes of limitation. Your comments about the affordability of health care, housing, etc. are problems directly attributable to the obscene amounts of money Democrats flooded our economy with during COVID. ... by Staff Writer

Welcome Home

The Pierson High School Class of 1995 extends its sincere appreciation to Sag Harbor Elementary School Principal Matt Malone and his security staff for their warm hospitality during a recent tour of both the elementary and high school campuses. The alumni also wish to recognize Jorge Maya for his time and effort in serving as the group’s guide through the elementary school. In addition, the Class of 1995 expresses its deepest gratitude to Eric Peele and the staff at Page Sag Harbor restaurant, as well as Amber Tagliasacchi and the staff at Il Cappuccino, for their generous support and exceptional ... by Staff Writer

Welcome

UPDATE: Body of Second Kayaker Recovered From Shinnecock Bay

You May Also Like:

Modal header